Brian Caldwell is the Farm Education Coordinator
for the Northeast Organic Farming Association of New York. He participated
in this project as part of the Northeast Organic Network (NEON). He
also is an organic apple grower and former extension educator in central
New York.
Emily Brown Rosen is a consultant and the former
Policy Director for the Organic Materials Review Institute, a non-profit
organization that provides technical services to certification
agencies and reviews products for compliance with organic regulations.
She has been an active participant in the development of national
organic standards and serves as an advisor to several organic certification
agencies.
Dr. Eric Sideman has been the Director of Technical
Services, Maine Organic Farmers and Gardeners Association since
1986. Dr. Sideman provides technical support for farmers and gardeners,
serves as staff scientist for MOFGA, plans and produces educational
events for MOFGA and Cooperative Extension, and serves on various
agricultural committees for the Maine Department of Agriculture.
Dr. Anthony M. Shelton has been a Professor of
Entomology at Cornell since 1979. His work focuses on insect ecology
and management of insect pests of vegetables. He has published
over 300 articles on pest management.
More on Dr. Anthony
M. Shelton
Dr. Christine D. Smart has been an Assistant
Professor of Plant Pathology at Cornell since 2003. She studies
induced resistance in plants against pathogens, and the biology
and control of vegetable diseases.
More on Dr.Christine
D. Smart
The number
of farmers and the acreage dedicated to organic farming has been
increasing steadily in the past ten years, as organic food sales
have increased approximately 20% annually. The USDA’s Economic
Research Service found that the northeastern United States has
a large percentage of organic vegetable growers compared to other
regions, with six northeast states ranking in the top 20 for percentage
of organic vegetable acreage in 2001.
Organic farmers rely primarily on preventive, cultural and integrated
methods of pest and disease management. However, there are a number
of materials available for use that can complement and support
organic management. This guide was developed to provide a useful
and scientifically accurate reference for organic farmers and agricultural
professionals searching for information on best practices, available
materials and perhaps most importantly, the efficacy of materials
that are permitted for use in organic systems. Many products available
to organic farmers have not been tested extensively, and current
research has not been summarized or made widely available to the
general producer. A major objective of this guide has been to review
recent literature for published trials on material efficacy in
order to provide reliable information that can be used by farmers
to effectively manage pests. Additionally, a goal was to identify
what materials have shown promise but need more research.
Organic farmers and farmers in transition to organic production, extension
professionals, and farm advisors who want accurate information based on published
research.
The Guide is divided into three sections. The first section provides cultural
information and management practices for a number of important vegetable
crop groups. For each family, key pests and disease problems are described.
Cultural methods and management practices that will help control the problem
are listed, as well as materials that may be recommended for use.
The second section is a set of generic fact sheets about specific
materials that can be used in organic systems. The fact sheets
provide background information about the type of material, how
it is made, how it works, and the types of pests it will control.
They also provide application guidelines for use, and a description
of the effects it has on the environment and human health. Efficacy
is described in a summary account and by means of a graph based
on data from trials reported in Arthropod Management Tests (Entomology
Society of America), Fungicide and Nematicide Tests (American Phytopathological
Society) and other sources. This rating groups the materials in
three categories of effectiveness: good, fair, and poor control.
Replicated field trials on crops grown in the northeast are included.
Results of studies in which a material was used in combination
or alternating with another could not be classified and are not
included, even though in practice such a strategy may be effective.
A complete bibliography of all efficacy data is available by contacting
Brian Caldwell at bac11@cornell.edu.
The last section contains appendices with useful information about
additional practices such as plant resistance, trap cropping, habitats
for beneficial insects, the concepts of induced or systemic acquired
resistance, materials exempt from pesticide regulation, and additional
resources.
Organic growers must use products that meet the requirements of USDA’s
National Organic Program (NOP) as established at 7CFR Part 205. Ingredients
found in farm input products for crop or livestock production must either be
a natural substance, or a synthetic substance that is included on the National
List (included in the regulations at 7CFR 205.600 - 205.607). A few natural
substances are also specifically prohibited. Inert ingredients used in pesticides
(ingredients other than pesticides) must be considered by the U.S. EPA to be
inerts of minimal risk (EPA List 4A or 4B).
Certification agencies are charged with the responsibility of
verifying that products used by farmers meet the requirements of
the National List. They must review both the active and non-active
(inert) ingredients for compliance. Many certifiers use the services
of the Organic Materials Review Institute (OMRI), a non-profit
established to provide this service of product review. Those that
use OMRI services also often provide some in-house review of products
as well, but in all cases a certified farmer must be sure that
any products used on the farm are approved by his/her certification
agency for use in organic production. References to OMRI listed
products in this Guide are based on the June 2004 edition of the
OMRI Brand Name List. Please consult later editions or www.omri.org for more up to date listings.
The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) also has a voluntary label review
program for registered pesticides. A product that meets the USDA-NOP requirements
may use the specific wording “For Organic Production” with
a three leaf logo (See Appendix F). If a product is not listed by OMRI, EPA, or directly
by the certifier, the farmer will generally need to be able to provide enough
information to the certifier to assure that the product is in compliance with
the NOP rules. Use of a prohibited material on an organic farm could result
in loss of certification for 36 months.
Materials used for disease and insect control are also subject
to further restriction by NOP rules which require that preventive,
cultural, and physical methods, including introduction of beneficial
insects must be the first choice for pest and disease control.
If those methods are not effective, a botanical, biological or
synthetic substance on the National List may be used, if the conditions
for this use are documented in the organic farm plan. This requirement
reflects an historic organic practice that relies primarily on
the use of biological and cultural practices such as crop rotation;
diversification; habitat management; beneficial organism releases;
sanitation; and timing before resorting to a limited use of permitted
pest control substances.
Finally, all pesticides must be used according to their label
as required by EPA and state regulations. Label instructions include
directions for use and rate of application as well as permitted
crops and designated target species. It is important to use products
only on labeled crops, because otherwise use of the product may
result in an illegal residue on the food crop.
The authors would like to thank the following people for their valuable assistance
in reviewing, correcting and improving this Guide: Brian Baker, Daniel Gilrein,
Vern Grubinger, Ruth Hazzard, Margaret Tuttle McGrath, and Abby Seaman.
Funds were provided by a grant from the USDA’s Initiative for Future
Agriculture and Food Systems and from the Sustainable Agriculture Research
and Education program (USDA agreement #2002-47001-01329) and the EPA Region
2 under their FQPA/Strategic Agricultural Initiative program. Cornell University’s
New York Agricultural Experiment Station and Cornell Cooperative Extension,
OMRI and MOFGA provided institutional support.
A limited number of copies are available from the
NYSAES
online bookstore for $15 + shipping
The ISBN number is 0-9676507-2-0.
Publication date: October 2005
|