By Tony Hotland
Recent
issues of domestic religious freedom have damaged Indonesia's global reputation
as a nation of religious tolerance, experts say.
Noted
Islamic scholar Azyumardi Azra, a professor at Syarif Hidayatullah State
Islamic University, said Sunday that religious communal conflicts were working
against "the government's pretense of trying to be a peacemaker".
"We
rush to get a position at world bodies, to play a role in the resolution of
conflicts such as Palestine-Israel or in Iraq, yet we can't even resolve such
conflicts at home," he said.
Azyumardi, a
member of the advisory board of the UN Democracy Fund (UNDEF) in New York, said
the world community could not fathom why the government "was bowing down
to pressures from vigilante groups globally labeled as hard-liners",
adding that "such violent acts were causing setbacks to Indonesian
diplomacy".
"If
these minorities were to seek asylum and a country took them on the basis of
religious suppression, it would be a slap in our face," he said.
The comments
come in the wake of discussion on the government's role in religious life and
violent acts by hard-liners against religious minorities, as seen in the
controversy surrounding the Ahmadiyah sect and the forcible closure of
minorities' places of worship.
The
Religious Affairs and Home ministries have drafted a joint ministerial decree
regarding Ahmadiyah, the details of which are to be announced Monday at the
Home Ministry in Jakarta.
Bantarto
Bandoro, an international relations analyst at the Centre for Strategic and
International Studies (CSIS), said "Indonesia was practicing fake
diplomacy".
"We say
we are religiously tolerant. But how will the world believe this when they see
people getting evicted from their places of worship, or faiths getting banned
due to pressure from certain groups?" he said.
The scholars
said it was a matter the government should not play down because human
rights-conscious states could put Indonesia in the spotlight.
The UN Human
Rights Council noted last month in its review of Indonesia that religious
freedom remained a serious plight.
The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom recommended last week that Indonesia remain on the U.S.
watch list, citing the growing political power and influence of religious
extremists "who harass and sometimes instigate violence".
Ahmad
Suaedy, executive director of the Islamic think tank Wahid Institute, said the
fact that law enforcement was weak on those hard- line groups made the matter
worse.
He said the
President was "handcuffed" by the Islamic parties, which are
affiliated with the hard-liners, that politically support his administration.
"I
wonder what our diplomats abroad would answer if their counterparts asked of
religious freedom in Indonesia," he said.
|