Selenium supplementation to prevent short-term morbidity in preterm neonates

Darlow BA, Austin NC

Background -  Methods - Results - Characteristics of Included Studies - References - Data Tables & Graphs


Cover sheet

Title

Selenium supplementation to prevent short-term morbidity in preterm neonates

Reviewers

Darlow BA, Austin NC

Dates

Date edited: 27/08/2003
Date of last substantive update: 01/08/2003
Date of last minor update: / /
Date next stage expected 30/08/2004
Protocol first published: Issue 4, 2001
Review first published: Issue 4, 2003

Contact reviewer

Dr Brian A Darlow
Professor of Paediatrics
Department of Paediatrics
Christchurch School of Medicine
PO Box 4345
CHRISTCHURCH
NEW ZEALAND
Telephone 1: +64 3 3640 747
Telephone 2: +64 3 3644 699
Facsimile: +64 3 3644 634
E-mail: bdarlow@chmeds.ac.nz
Secondary contact person's name: Nina Mogridge, Research Nurse, Dept Paediatrics, Christchurch Hospital, Christchurch

Contribution of reviewers

BD wrote the protocol. Both reviewers searched the databases, excerpted data, analysed results and wrote the review.

Internal sources of support

None

External sources of support

None

What's new

Dates

Date review re-formatted: / /
Date new studies sought but none found: / /
Date new studies found but not yet included/excluded: / /
Date new studies found and included/excluded: / /
Date reviewers' conclusions section amended: / /
Date comment/criticism added: / /
Date response to comment/criticisms added: / /

Text of review

Synopsis

Higher doses of selenium supplements may be able to reduce some complications for preterm babies, but more research is needed

Selenium is an essential trace element gained from nutrients. Babies are born with lower selenium concentrations in their blood than their mothers. In very preterm babies, low selenium is associated with an increased risk of complications. The review of trials of selenium supplementation for preterm babies found that it reduces sepsis (blood infection). It has not been shown to reduce other complications or increase survival. No adverse effects were reported. Higher than usual levels of selenium supplementation may be beneficial, but more research is needed as most of the evidence comes from a country where selenium levels were unusually low.

Abstract

Background

Selenium is an essential trace element and component of a number of selenoproteins including glutathione peroxidase, which has a role in protecting against oxidative damage. Selenium is also known to play a role in immunocompetence. Blood selenium concentrations in newborns are lower than those of their mothers and lower still in preterm infants. In experimental animals low selenium concentrations appear to increase susceptibility to oxidative lung disease. In very preterm infants low selenium concentrations have been associated with an increased risk of chronic neonatal lung disease and retinopathy of prematurity.

Objectives

To assess the benefits and harms of selenium supplementation in preterm or very low birthweight infants.

Search strategy

Searches were made of the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL, The Cochrane Library, Issue 2, 2003), MEDLINE (1966-May 2003), and Embase (1980-May 2003). The reference lists of recent trials were also searched and abstracts from the Society for Pediatric Research from 1990 were hand-searched.

Selection criteria

Randomised controlled trials which compared selenium supplementation either parenterally or enterally with placebo or nothing from soon after birth in preterm or very low birthweight infants and which reported clinical outcomes were considered for the review.

Data collection & analysis

Data on selenium supplementation dose, formulation and route of administration; mortality, oxygen requirement at 28 days and 36 weeks post-menstrual age, retinopathy of prematurity, and one or more episodes of sepsis; blood selenium and glutathione peroxidase concentrations at or close to 28 days, were excerpted by both reviewers independently. Data analysis was conducted according to the standards of the Cochrane Neonatal Review Group.

Main results

Three eligible trials were identified. Two trials, including one trial with a much larger sample size than the others combined, were from geographical areas with low population selenium concentrations. Meta-analysis of the pooled data showed a significant reduction in the proportion of infants having one or more episodes of sepsis associated with selenium supplementation [summary RR 0.73 (0.57, 0.93); RD -0.10 (-0.17, -0.02); NNT 10 (5.9, 50)]. Supplementation with selenium was not associated with improved survival, a reduction in neonatal chronic lung disease or retinopathy of prematurity.

Reviewers' conclusions

Supplementing very preterm infants with selenium is associated with benefit in terms of a reduction in one or more episodes of sepsis. Supplementation was not associated with improved survival, a reduction in neonatal chronic lung disease or retinopathy of prematurity. Supplemental doses of selenium for infants on parenteral nutrition higher than those currently recommended may be beneficial. The data are dominated by one large trial from a country with low selenium concentrations and may not be readily translated to other populations.

Background

The trace element selenium is an essential component of a number of selenoproteins. These include the glutathione peroxidases (a family of enzymes that protect against oxidative injury by catalyzing the breakdown of hydrogen peroxide and lipid hydroperoxides); iodothyronine deiodinase (which converts thyroxine [T4] to 3,5,3'-triodothyronine [T3]); and thioredoxin reductase (which is a key enzyme regulating the redox state of cells), (Arthur 1994; Rayman 2000). Selenium is also known to have a role in immunocompetence, selenium deficiency being associated with impairment of both cell-mediated immunity and B-cell function (Rayman 2000).

Selenium levels in the soil vary considerably in different geographical locations with blood selenium concentrations in both animal and human populations reflecting these variations. Plasma selenium concentrations in newborn infants in all regions of the world are lower than those of their mothers (Litov 1991) and, in breast fed infants, then rise after birth. Preterm infants are born with slightly lower selenium and glutathione peroxidase concentrations than term infants, have low hepatic stores of selenium and, particularly if fed parenterally with solutions lacking selenium, these concentrations decline further in the first months of life (Lokitch 1989; Sluis 1992). In some preterm infants selenium concentrations may fall as low as 0.13 micromol/L (10 micrograms/L) and are amongst the lowest recorded in humans.

The consequences of low selenium concentrations are not fully known. A range of selenium deficiency diseases have been described in animals and in some selenium deficient geographical areas, such as New Zealand, selenium supplements are essential for maintaining animal health. During the late 1970s reports from endemically selenium deficient areas of China described two human diseases associated with severe nutritional selenium deficiency. However, both Keshan disease, a juvenile cardiomyopathy, and Kaschin-Beck disease, a chondrodystrophy, seem to require other causative co-factors in addition to selenium deficiency (Litov 1991; Rayman 2000). Outside of China, selenium deficiency diseases have been rarely recognised and then only following exceptional circumstances such as prolonged parenteral nutrition or severe malnutrition when selenium concentrations fall to <0.20 micromol/L (16 micrograms/L). Clinical features have included muscle pain and tenderness, macrocytosis and pigmentary changes in hair and nails, and fatal cardiomyopathy (Litov 1991). The only reported adverse effect of low selenium levels in preterm infants has been increased erythrocyte fragility, which was accentuated by a diet high in polyunsaturated fatty acids and by iron supplements (Gross 1976).

In experimental animals, selenium deficiency has been associated with increased susceptibility to oxidative lung injury (Hawker 1993; Kim 1991). Sick very preterm infants are exposed to many possible sources of oxygen radical products, including high concentrations of inspired oxygen, frequent alterations of blood flow to major organs, and inflammation with accumulation of neutrophils and macrophages. Low blood selenium concentrations in preterm infants have therefore been suggested as a potential risk factor for chronic neonatal lung disease (Amin 1980; Lokitch 1989) and retinopathy of prematurity (DeVoe 1988; Kretzer 1988). Darlow 1995 in a study from New Zealand, which has low soil and population selenium concentrations, reported that low selenium concentrations at 28 days were associated with an increased risk of adverse respiratory outcome in very low birthweight infants. However, uncertainty exists as to whether selenium supplementation in preterm infants will prevent such morbidity.

Objectives

Main Question: Does selenium supplementation, given either enterally or parenterally, reduce the incidence of neonatal chronic lung disease, retinopathy of prematurity, or of late-onset sepsis in preterm or low birth weight infants, without causing clinically important side effects.

Secondary Questions:
1. Does the route of supplementation (enteral or parenteral) affect outcome?
2. Does the dose of selenium supplementation affect outcome?
3. Does the gestation or birthweight of the infant affect outcome?
4. Does selenium supplementation lead to higher blood or plasma selenium concentrations at or beyond 28 days of age?

Criteria for considering studies for this review

Types of studies

Only randomised and quasi-randomised studies of the effect of selenium supplementation on one or more of: survival, chronic lung disease, bronchopulmonary dysplasia, retinopathy of prematurity and late-onset sepsis will be included.

Types of participants

Preterm infants (defined as gestation less than 32 weeks) or infants with birthweight less than or equal to 2000g.

Types of interventions

Selenium supplementation, in any formulation and either enterally or parenterally, versus no supplementation or placebo.

Types of outcome measures

Primary outcome measures: death before hospital discharge, neonatal chronic lung disease, defined as a) O2 requirement at 28 days, b) O2 requirement at 36 weeks post-menstrual age, retinopathy of prematurity (any and stages 3 or 4), one or more proven episodes of bacterial sepsis after the first week of life.

Secondary outcomes measures: plasma or blood selenium and/or glutathione peroxidase concentrations at or beyond 28 days of age.

Side effects: skin eruptions, diarrhoea or other pre-defined clinical problems.

Search strategy for identification of studies

The standard methods of the Neonatal Review Group of the Cochrane Collaboration were used. These involved searching the following databases: Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL, The Cochrane Library, Issue 2, 2003); MEDLINE from 1966 to May 2003 (using key words "selenium" and "chronic lung disease" or "bronchopulmonary dysplasia"; MeSH headings "infant, premature" or "infant, low birth weight"; and publication type "randomized controlled trial" or "controlled clinical trial"); and Embase from 1980 to May 2003. In addition, the reference lists of relevant articles were searched and abstracts from the Society for Pediatric Research from 1990 to May 2002 were also be hand-searched.

Methods of the review

Both reviewers examined all identified articles and the decision regarding inclusion/exclusion of the studies was by consensus. Where there were disagreements, the opinion of a third party was sought. Both reviewers completed data collection sheets, these were compared and any discrepancies were resolved by reference to the original sources.

Data were be collected on:

Methodological quality was assessed using the procedure of the neonatal review group. This involves using a simple "yes/ can't tell / no" classification to assess the following study characteristics: blinding of randomization, blinding of intervention, completeness of follow-up and blinding of outcome measurement.

Analysis
Separate analyses were conducted for each of the outcomes: death, neonatal chronic lung disease, retinopathy of prematurity (any and stage 3 or 4) and one or more proven episodes of sepsis. All analyses were conducted on an intention to treat basis. The data were analysed using the standard method of the neonatal review group using a fixed effect model, with use of relative risk, risk reduction, number needed to treat and their 95% confidence intervals.

Description of studies

Nine potentially relevant trials were identified of which three met eligibility criteria and were included (Daniels 1996; Darlow 2000; Huston 1991). The report by Daniels 1996 gives in full data published in abstract form in Daniels 1995, and the report by Darlow 2000 gives in full data published in abstract form in Darlow 1998. Six trials (Bogye 1998a; Bogye 1998b; Ehrenkranz 1991; Rudolph 1981; Smith 1991; Tyrala 1996) were excluded from the final analysis because of inadequate methodology and/or because no clinical outcome data were reported. Data on selenium concentrations have not been reported in a manner allowing comparisons between studies and meta-analysis of these data have not been included in this version of the review.

Participants
The three included studies reported outcomes on 297 infants receiving selenium supplements and 290 control infants. One study (Darlow 2000) was much the largest and included 85% of all infants. This study was a multicentre study involving 8 New Zealand neonatal units and included infants with birthweight <1500g admitted to a participating unit by 72 hours of age and without major abnormalities. Five hundred and thirty-four infants were randomised but five infants were withdrawn from the study, three by parents and two by the neonatal team caring for the infants and no data are available for these infants. Daniels 1996 included infants with birthweight <2000g, who were expected to have parenteral nutrition for more than 5 days and no major congenital anomalies, liver or renal disease. Forty-four infants were enrolled but six excluded, including two who died (day 3 and day 11), three who received parenteral nutrition for less than 6 days and one because of protocol violations. Data, including group assignment, are not available for these infants. in addition, two further infants died before hospital discharge and again group assignment for these infants is not available. The study by Huston 1991 included infants with birthweight <1000g with no congenital, metabolic or chronic white blood cell disease.

Interventions
The study by Daniels 1996 gave 3 micrograms/Kg/d selenious acid in parenteral nutrition, and received for a mean 18 days, in the treatment group versus nothing in controls. The study by Darlow 2000 gave 7 micrograms/Kg/d of sodium selenate added to parenteral nutrition in the treatment group versus nothing in controls, and 5 micrograms/Kg/d of sodium selenite in the treatment group or an equivalent volume of sterile water for control infants, when fed orally until 28 days of age. The study by Huston 1991 gave 1.5 micrograms/Kg/d of selenious acid added to parenteral nutrition, and received for a mean 38 days, in the treatment group versus nothing in controls.

Outcome measures
Daniels 1996 reported CLD (an oxygen requirement plus chest Xray changes) at 28 days, and one or more episodes of sepsis (defined as microbiologically confirmed or requiring antibiotics for at least five days). Darlow 2000 reported deaths pre-hospital discharge, CLD (an oxygen requirement) at 28 days and at 36 weeks post-menstrual age, any ROP in infants who were examined (ROP screening in New Zealand being routinely carried out in infants <31 weeks gestation or <1250g birthweight), and one or more episodes of sepsis (defined as clinical sepsis and a positive culture from either blood or cerebrospinal fluid) after the first week of life. Huston 1991 reported CLD at a mean 35 weeks post-menstrual age, any ROP, and one or more episodes of sepsis (not defined further).

Methodological quality of included studies

In the study by Daniels 1996, infants were stratified by birthweight < 1000g and 1000-1999g and randomisation was undertaken in pharmacy, although the method of randomisation is not stated. Investigators were blinded to group assignment. In the study by Darlow 2000, infants were stratified by hospital and by birthweight less than 1000g and 1000-1499g and randomisation was by telephone to the hospital pharmacy. This was the only study to give selenium supplementation orally after a period of parenteral nutrition (if required) and the investigators were blinded as to group assignment. This was also the only study to specify possible side effects of selenium supplementation; skin rashes, diarrhoea or a garlic odour on breath. In the study by Huston 1991, randomisation was by sealed envelopes and investigators were blinded to group assignment.

Results

Primary outcomes

Death pre-hospital discharge, Table 01.01
The studies by Darlow 2000 and Huston 1991 reported deaths pre-hospital discharge with no significant differences between selenium supplementation and control groups.

Oxygen use at 28 days in survivors, Table 01.02
The studies by Daniels 1996 and Darlow 2000 reported oxygen use at 28 days in survivors with neither showing a significant difference between groups. The pooled data also showed no significant difference [summary RR 0.99 (0.82, 1.18); RD -0.01 (-0.09, 0.08)].

Death or oxygen use at 28 days, Table 01.03
Only the study by Darlow 2000 reported death or oxygen use at 28 days with no significant difference between selenium supplementation and control groups.

Oxygen use at 36 weeks PMA in survivors, Table 01.04
The studies by Darlow 2000 and Huston 1991 reported oxygen use at 36 weeks post-menstrual age in surviving infants. Whilst there was no significant difference between groups in the study by Darlow 2000, the study by Huston 1991 did show a reduction in oxygen use associated with selenium supplementation of borderline statistical significance [ RR 0.33 (0.09, 1.27); RD -0.40 (-0.79, -0.01)]. The pooled data showed no significant difference between groups [summary RR 1.02 (0.75, 1.39); RD 0.01 (-0.07, 0.08)].

Retinopathy of prematurity (any grade) in examined infants, Table 01.05
The studies by Darlow 2000 and Huston 1991 reported on retinopathy of prematurity of any grade, with neither showing a significant difference between groups. The pooled data also showed no significant difference [summary RR 0.92 (0.71, 1.18); RD -0.03 (-0.11, 0.05)].

One or more episodes of sepsis, Table 01.06
All three studies reported on one or more episodes of sepsis and in Daniels 1996 and Darlow 2000 there was a significant reduction associated with selenium supplementation. The pooled data show a significant reduction in sepsis associated with selenium supplementation [summary RR 0.73 (0.57, 0.93); RD -0.10 (-0.17, -0.02); NNT 10 (5.9, 50)], with no significant heterogeneity.

Side effects
Only the study by Darlow 2000 reported on side effects of selenium supplementation (skin rashes, diarrhoea or garlic odour on breath), and noted that none were recorded.

Secondary outcomes

Blood or plasma selenium concentrations at or beyond 28 days of age.
Data on selenium concentrations have not been reported in a similar manner across the studies and do not allow a meta-analysis to be performed. The study by Huston 1991, which used the lowest dose of selenium supplementation added to parenteral nutrition (1.5 micrograms/Kg/d), found supplemented infants had significantly higher serum concentrations when oral feeds were commenced (mean day 14-15) than control infants, although these concentrations were below pre-randomisation concentrations. The study by Daniels 1996 used a dose of 3 micrograms/Kg/d added to parenteral nutrition and found plasma selenium concentrations fell compared with pre-randomisation concentrations by three weeks of age in control infants, whilst this decline was prevented by supplementation. By six weeks of age there was no significant difference between the groups with selenium concentrations in both being similar to pre-randomisation concentrations. The study by Darlow 2000 supplemented parenteral nutrition with 7 micrograms/Kg/d and enteral feeding with 5 micrograms/Kg/d of selenium. Supplemented infants had plasma selenium concentrations significantly higher (nearly two-fold) at 28 days and 36 weeks post-menstrual age than pre-randomisation concentrations and these were similar to concentrations found in healthy breast-fed term infants in this population. By contrast, selenium concentrations in control infants showed a non-significant fall at these times compared with pre-randomisation concentrations. Plasma glutathione peroxidase concentrations were also significantly higher at 28 days and 36 weeks post-menstrual age compared with control infants and with pre-randomisation concentrations.

The study by Darlow 2000 included 243 infants with birthweight <1000g and noted that confining analysis to this subgroup of infants did not reveal significant differences between the groups with respect to primary or secondary outcomes, however the data have not been reported.

Discussion

The study by Darlow 2000 was a large, multicentre randomised controlled trial with 80% power to detect a 12% reduction in oxygen dependency at 28 days. However, neither this study nor pooled data from this study and one of two smaller studies reporting similar outcomes showed any benefit from selenium supplementation with respect to deaths prior to discharge, oxygen use in survivors at 28 days or at 36 weeks post-menstrual age, or retinopathy of prematurity of any stage, with relative risks for all analyses being close to unity.

The study by Darlow 2000 reported that lower plasma selenium concentrations before randomisation were associated with an increased risk of adverse respiratory outcome at 28 days and a trend to increased risk of adverse outcome at 36 weeks post-menstrual age, after controlling for gestational age, antenatal steroids, CRIB score and hospital. There was a similar association between maternal selenium concentrations at enrolment and neonatal outcome. The relationship between pre-randomisation infant selenium concentrations and total days in oxygen was non-linear with a threshold of between 0.2 and 0.4 micromols/L below which, in this population, selenium concentrations had an effect on days of oxygen requirement. These findings suggest that if oxidative damage contributes to respiratory morbidity in preterm infants, and selenium has a role in preventing or ameliorating such damage, that it may be critical to achieve improved selenium status earlier than was the case in the studies included in this review. Low selenium concentrations at birth reflect low body stores (Bayliss 1985) and also correlate with maternal concentrations. At least in populations with low selenium status, the role of maternal selenium supplementation from perhaps 20 weeks' gestation could be the subject of further study, although given that very preterm infants constitute only around 1% of births, large numbers of pregnant women (at least 5,000) would have to be recruited.

Two of the studies in this review come from geographical areas recognised as having low soil and population concentrations of selenium. There are good theoretical reasons to expect that, if selenium supplementation does result in decreased morbidity, this would be more readily apparent in studies from populations with low selenium concentrations. Nevertheless, the fact that the one large study is from such a population and that no large trials have been carried out in populations with higher concentrations, does mean that the results may not be generalisable.

The mean pre-randomisation plasma selenium concentrations in the study by Daniels 1996 (South Australia) were 0.34 and 0.36 micromols/L, in the study and control groups respectively, and in the study by Darlow 2000 (New Zealand) were 0.33 micromols/L in both groups. In contrast the mean pre-randomisation serum selenium concentrations in the study by Huston 1991 (Portland, Oregan) were 0.91 and 0.81 micromols/L in the study and control groups. Preterm infants generally have lower selenium concentrations than term infants in the same population, and in healthy term breast-fed infants concentrations then rise after birth. North American recommendations are for preterm infants to be supplemented with 2 micrograms/Kg/d selenium whilst receiving parenteral nutrition (Reifen 1993). The data from Huston 1991 show that a slightly lower dose (1.5 micrograms/Kg/d) resulted in serum concentrations still below starting concentrations after two weeks. In another study from North America, Ormsby 1998, reported that a dose of 4 micrograms/Kg/d added to parenteral nutrition for an average of more than three weeks did not maintain day one plasma selenium concentrations in preterm infants. Taken together, the studies of Daniels 1996 and Darlow 2000 suggest that 3 micrograms/Kg/d selenium supplementation in preterm infants may maintain cord concentrations but supplementation of 5-7 micrograms/Kg/d may be required to raise concentrations above those in cord blood to close to those found in healthy breast-fed term infants. Additional factors that may influence selenium concentrations in preterm infants include the form of selenium supplementation, route of administration and interactions with other nutrients, and the selenium content of enteral feeds.

Two studies, Daniels 1996 and Darlow 2000, as well as the pooled data showed a significant reduction in one or more episodes of sepsis associated with selenium supplementation, with the number needed to treat to prevent sepsis in one infant being 10. Selenium is known to have a role in immunocompetence (Rayman 2000). Neutrophils and macrophages from selenium deficient animals have low glutathione peroxidase concentrations, which may affect their antimicrobial properties, and animal studies have also shown that immunoglobulin antibody responses may be enhanced by selenium supplementation (Turner 1991). The relationship between selenium status and infections in preterm infants in different populations and the role of selenium supplementation is an important area for further research.

Limitations of this review.
Two included studies did not report outcome for all participants. Daniels 1996 did not report any data, including group assignment, for six infants, two of whom died. In the study by Darlow 2000 examination for retinopathy of prematurity followed national guidelines (<31 weeks gestation or <1250g birthweight as a routine) and hence not all surviving infants were examined. Darlow 2000 also defined sepsis as episodes after the first week of life.

Two of the studies in this review, one of which accounts for 85% of participants, come from geographical areas recognised as having low soil and population concentrations of selenium. There are good theoretical reasons to expect that, if selenium supplementation does result in decreased morbidity, this would be more readily apparent in studies from populations with low selenium concentrations. Nevertheless, the fact that the one large study is from such a population and that no large trials have been carried out in populations with higher concentrations, does mean that the results may not be generalisable.

Reviewers' conclusions

Implications for practice

Supplementing very preterm infants with selenium is associated with benefit in terms of a reduction in one or more episodes of late-onset sepsis. Supplementation was not associated with improved survival, a reduction in neonatal chronic lung disease or retinopathy of prematurity. The data would suggest that the currently recommended dose of selenium for preterm infants receiving parenteral nutrition, 2 micrograms/Kg/d, is inadequate to maintain cord selenium concentrations, whilst doses of 3 micrograms/Kg/d may prevent a decline in cord levels and doses of up to 7 micrograms/Kg/d may be required to achieve concentrations above those in cords and close to concentrations found in healthy breast fed infants. These latter data come from New Zealand, a country with low soil and population selenium concentrations, and may not be readily translated to other populations. Beyond the reduction in late-onset sepsis, the benefits of selenium supplementation remain more theoretical than proven. However, the decline in selenium concentrations seen in non-supplemented very preterm infants is not physiological and, given that selenium is recognised as an essential trace element, should be avoided.

Implications for research

The impact of maternal selenium supplementation from 20 weeks gestation on the outcome for very preterm infants deserves investigation, although given that very preterm infants constitute only around 1% of births, large numbers of pregnant women would have to be recruited.

Further studies are warranted on the relationship between selenium status and infections in preterm infants.

Acknowledgements

We wish to thanks reviewers of the CNRG for helpful comments.

Potential conflict of interest

BD and NA are both authors of the largest trial included in this review.

Characteristics of included studies

Study Methods Participants Interventions Outcomes Notes Allocation concealment
Daniels 1996 Single centre randomised controlled trial
Blinding of randomisation: yes
Blinding of intervention: yes
Complete follow-up: no
Blinding of outcome measures: yes
N=38 [44 infants randomised but data only reported for 38 - see text]
Birthweight less than 2000g; stratified as less than 1000g or 1000-1999g
Expected to have TPN for more than 5 days
No major congenital anomalies, liver or renal disease
19 infants randomised to treatment and 19 to control groups
3 microg/Kg/d of selenious acid added to TPN for as long as this required (mean 18-19 days) vs no supplementation
CLD (defined as oxygen requirement at 28 days plus chest Xray changes
One or more episodes of sepsis (defined as microbiologically confirmed or antibiotics for at least 5 days)
Changes in mean plasma and erythrocyte selenium or glutathione peroxidase activity at 3 and 6 weeks
Total selenium intake from all sources monitored A
Darlow 2000 Multicentre randomised controlled trial
Blinding of randomisation: yes
Blinding of intervention: yes
Complete follow-up: yes
Blinding of outcome measurement: yes
N=529 [534 infants randomised but data only reported for 529 - see text]
Birthweight less than 1500g, stratified by hospital and less than 1000g or 1000-1499g
No major anomalies
268 infants randomised to treatment and 261 to control groups
7 microg/Kg/d of sodium selenate added to TPN vs no supplementation when intravenously fed and 5 microg/Kg/d sodium selenite vs equal volume (0.5 ml/Kg) sterile water when orally fed until 36 weeks PMA or discharge home
Death before hospital discharge
CLD defined as oxygen requirement at 28 days of age and at 36 weeks PMA
ROP of any stage in examined infants
One or more episodes of sepsis (defined as clinical sepsis and positive culture from blood or CSF) after 1 week of age
Plasma selenium and glutathione peroxidase concentrations at 28 days and 36 weeks PMA
Infants changed from parenteral to oral supplements when tolerating 3 ml/hr A
Huston 1991 Single centre randomised controlled trial
Blinding of randomisation: yes
Blinding of intervention: yes
Complete follow-up: yes
Blinding of outcome measurement: yes
N=20
Birthweight less than 1000g
No congenital metabolic or white blood cell diseases
10 infants randomised to treatment and 10 to control groups
1.5 microg?Kg/d of selenious acid added to TPN for as long as this required (mean 42 days) vs no supplementation
Death in hospital
CLD defined as oxygen requirement at 60 days (equivalent to 35.1 weeks PMA from mean gestation of 26.5 weeks)
ROP of any stage and grades III and IV in examined infants
One or more episodes of sepsis (not defined further)
Serum selenium and WBC glutathione peroxidase concentrations at time enteral feeding commenced (mean 14-15 days) and at time fully enterally fed (mean 42 days)
Also assessed serum levels of copper and zinc and WBC superoxide dismutase activity A

Characteristics of excluded studies

Study Reason for exclusion
Bogye 1998a No clinical outcome data
Serum selenium and glutathione concentrations at 14 days only
The Biofactors report is labelled an "Extended Abstract" and repeats data in primary report
Bogye 1998b No clinical outcome data
Serum selenium and glutathione concentrations at 14 days only
Report contains similar data to (includes 36 compared with 28 infants), and may overlap with, Bogye 1998a. The author is being contacted for clarification.
Ehrenkranz 1991 No clinical outcome data
Main aim of study was to assess enteral selenium absorption and retention using a stable isotope
Rudolph 1981 Not a trial of selenium supplementation
Smith 1991 Oral supplementation begun at mean 15-26 days.
Data not reported for 25 of 71 enrolled infants.
No clinical outcome data.
Tyrala 1996 Only infants with no evidence of disease process included.
Study infants not all feeding study formula exclusively until 4 weeks of age.
No clinical outcomes

References to studies

References to included studies

Daniels 1996 {published data only}

* Daniels L, Gibson R, Simmer K. Randomised clinical trial of parenteral selenium supplementation in preterm infants. Arch Dis Child 1996;74:F158-F164.

Daniels LA, Gibson RA, Simmer K. Selenium (SE) supplementation of preterm infants. J Paediatr Child Health 1995;31:A22.

Darlow 2000 {published data only}

Darlow BA, Inder TE, Sluis KB, Buss H, Graham P, Mogridge N, Winterbourn CC, The New Zealand Neonatal Study Group. Randomised controlled trial of selenium supplementation in New Zealand VLBW infants. Pediatr Res 1998;43:258A.

* Darlow BA, Winterbourn CC, Inder TE, Graham PJ, Harding JE, Weston PJ, Austin NC, Elder DE, Mogridge N, Buss IH, Sluis KB, The New Zealand Neonatal Study Group. The effect of selenium supplementation on outcome in very low birth weight infants: A randomized controlled trial. J Pediatr 2000;136:473-80.

Huston 1991 {published data only}

Huston RK, Jelen BJ, Vidgoff J. Selenium supplementation in low-birthweight premature infants: Relationship to trace metals and antioxidant enzymes. J Parent Ent Nutr 1991;15:556-59.

References to excluded studies

Bogye 1998a {published data only}

* Bogye G, Alfthan G, Machay T. Bioavailability of enteral yeast-selenium in preterm infants. Biol Trace Elem Res 1998;65:143-51.

Bogye G, Alfthan G, Machay T. Randomized clinical trial of enteral yeast-selenium supplementation in preterm infants. Biofactors 1998;8:139-42.

Bogye 1998b {published data only}

Bogye G, Alfthan G, Machay T, Zubovics L. Enteral yeast-selenium supplementation in preterm infants. Arch Dis Child 1998;78:F225-26.

Ehrenkranz 1991 {published data only}

Ehrenkranz RA, Gettner PA, Nelli CM, Sherwonit EA, Williams JE, Ting BT, Janghorbani M. Selenium absorption and retention by very-low-birth-weight infants: Studies with the extrinsic stable isotope tag 74Se. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 1991;13:125-33.

Rudolph 1981 {published data only}

Rudolph N, Preis O, Bitzos EI, Reale MM, Wong SL. Hematological and selenium status of low-birth-weight infants fed formulas with and without iron. J Pediatr 1981;99:57-62.

Smith 1991 {published data only}

Smith AM, Chan GM, Moyer-Milieur LJ, Johnson CE, Gardner BR. Selenium status of preterm infants fed human milk, preterm formula, or selenium-supplemented preterm formula. J Pediatr 1991;119:429-433.

Tyrala 1996 {published data only}

Tyrala EE, Borschel MW, Jacobs JR. Selenate fortification of infant formulas improves the selenium status of preterm infants. Am J Clin Nutr 1996;64:860-65.

* indicates the primary reference for the study

Other references

Additional references

Amin 1980

Amin S, Chen SY, Collipp PJ, Castro-Magan M, Maddaiah JVT, Klein SW. Selenium in premature infants. Nutr Metab 1980;24:331-40.

Arthur 1994

Arthur JR, Beckett GJ. New metabolic roles for selenium. Proc Nutr Soc 1994;53:615-24.

Bayliss 1985

Bayliss PA, Buchanan BE, Hancock RGV, Zlotkin SH. Tissue selenium accretion in premature and full-term infants and children. Biol Trace Elem Res 1985;7:55-61.

Darlow 1995

Darlow BA, Inder TE, Graham PJ, Sluis KB, Malpas TJ, Taylor BJ, Winterbourn CC. The relationship of selenium status to respiratory outcome in the very low birth weight infant. Pediatrics 1995;96:314-9.

DeVoe 1988

DeVoe WM. Prevention of retinopathy of prematurity. Semin Perinatol 1988;12:373-80.

Gross 1976

Gross S. Hemolytic anaemia in premature infants: relationship to vitamin E, glutathione peroxidase and erythrocyte lipids. Semin Hematol 1976;13:187-99.

Hawker 1993

Hawker FH, Ward HE, Stewart PM, Wynne LA, Snitch PJ. Selenium deficiency augments the pulmonary toxic effects of oxygen exposure in the rat. Eur Respir J 1993;6:1317-23.

Kim 1991

Kim HY, Picciano MF, Wallig MA, Milner JA. The role of selenium nutrition in the development of neonatal rat lung. Pediatr Res 1991;29:440-45.

Kretzer 1988

Kretzer FL, Hittner HM. Retinopathy of prematurity: clinical implications of retinal devlopment. Arch Dis Child 1988;63:1151-67.

Litov 1991

Litov RE, Combs GF. Selenium in pediatric nutrition. Pediatrics 1991;87:339-51.

Lokitch 1989

Lockitch G, Jacobson B, Quigley G, Dison P, Pendray M. Selenium deficiency in low birth weight neonates: an unrecognized problem. J Pediatr 1989;114:865-70.

Ormsby 1998

Ormsby AR, Tyrala EE. Se sufficiency is not achieved with currently recommended dosages of IV Se intake. Ped Res 1998;43:268A.

Rayman 2000

Rayman MP. The importance of selenium to human health. Lancet 2000;356:233-41.

Reifen 1993

Reifen RM, Zlotkin S. Microminerals. In: Tsang RC, Lucas A, Uauy R, Zlotkin S, editor(s). Nutritional needs of the preterm infant: scientific basis and practical guidelines. Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins, 1993:195-207.

Sluis 1992

Sluis KB, Darlow BA, George PM, Mogridge N, Dolamore BA, Winterbourn CC. Selenium and glutathione peroxidase levels in premature infants in a low selenium community (Christchurch, New Zealand). Pediatr Res 1992;32:189-94.

Turner 1991

Turner RJ, Finch JM. Selenium and the immune response. Proc Nutr Soc 1991;50:275-85.

Comparisons and data

01 Supplemental selenium vs placebo or nothing

01.01 Death pre-hospital discharge

01.02 Oxygen use at 28 days in survivors

01.03 Death or oxygen use at 28 days

01.04 Oxygen use at 36 weeks PMA in survivors

01.05 Retinopathy of prematurity (any grade) in examined infants

01.06 One or more episodes of sepsis

Comparison or outcome Studies Participants Statistical method Effect size
01 Supplemental selenium vs placebo or nothing
01 Death pre-hospital discharge 1 549 RR (fixed), 95% CI 0.92 [0.48, 1.75]
02 Oxygen use at 28 days in survivors 2 548 RR (fixed), 95% CI 0.99 [0.82, 1.18]
03 Death or oxygen use at 28 days 1 529 RR (fixed), 95% CI 0.97 [0.80, 1.16]
04 Oxygen use at 36 weeks PMA in survivors 2 521 RR (fixed), 95% CI 1.02 [0.75, 1.39]
05 Retinopathy of prematurity (any grade) in examined infants 2 466 RR (fixed), 95% CI 0.92 [0.71, 1.18]
06 One or more episodes of sepsis 3 583 RR (fixed), 95% CI 0.73 [0.57, 0.93]

Notes

Published notes

Amended sections

Cover sheet
Synopsis
Abstract
Background
Search strategy for identification of studies
Methods of the review
Description of studies
Results
Discussion
Potential conflict of interest
References to studies
Other references
Characteristics of included studies
Characteristics of excluded studies
Comparisons, data or analyses

Contact details for co-reviewers

Dr Nicola C Austin
Neonatologist
Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
Christchurch Women's Hospital, Christchurch, New Zealand
Private Bag 4711
Christchurch
NEW ZEALAND
Telephone 1: 64 3 3644699
Facsimile: 64 3 3644883
E-mail: nicola.austin@cdhb.govt.nz
Secondary contact person's name: Brian Darlow


This review is published as a Cochrane review in The Cochrane Library 2003, Issue 4, 2003 (see www.CochraneLibrary.net for information).  Cochrane reviews are regularly updated as new evidence emerges and in response to comments and criticisms, and The Cochrane Library should be consulted for the most recent version of the Review.