American Memory Videodisc
The American Memory Project began in 1990 as a five-year pilot
program to develop "electronic" versions of selected Library of
Congress historical collections and disseminate them to a test
group of libraries and institutions around the country. The project
produced three videodiscs of early motion pictures from the collections
of the Motion Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound Division,
and the discs are available for public use in the Motion Picture
and Television Reading Room. The three videodiscs, THE LAST DAYS
OF PRESIDENT MCKINLEY: FILMS OF WILLIAM MCKINLEY AND THE PAN-AMERICAN
EXPOSITION, 1901, THE LIFE OF A CITY: EARLY FILMS OF NEW YORK FROM
THE PAPER PRINT COLLECTION, 1898-1906, and EARLY FILMS OF SAN FRANCISCO,
BEFORE AND AFTER THE GREAT EARTHQUAKE AND FIRE, 1896-1915, each
contain from 90 to 120 minutes of silent, black and white motion
pictures, primarily from the Library of Congress's Paper Print
Collection.
American Memory has been assimilated into the Library of Congress's
National Digital Library Project, and many of the original collections
developed by American Memory (including these early films) are
now accessible via the World Wide Web at the American
Memory Home Page
I. THE LAST DAYS OF PRESIDENT MCKINLEY: FILMS OF WILLIAM MCKINLEY
AND THE PAN-AMERICAN EXPOSITION, 1901
Introduction
There are twenty-six films on this videodisc. They include scenes
of President William McKinley at his second inauguration, of the
Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo, New York where he was assassinated,
and of his funeral. All of the films were produced by the Edison
Manufacturing Company, a motion picture production company founded
by inventor Thomas Alva Edison, in operation from 1893 to 1917.
All of the films on the videodisc are paper prints, submitted
to the Library of Congress by the Edison Manufacturing Company
to obtain copyright. Because no motion picture copyright law existed
until 1912, early film producers who desired protection for their
work sent paper contact prints of their motion pictures to the
U.S. Copyright Office at the Library of Congress, where they were
registered for copyright as photographs. The Paper Print Collection
at the Library of Congress contains over 3,000 complete motion
pictures produced prior to 1912, which have been rephotographed
from the original paper rolls to motion picture film. In most instances
they are the only surviving copies of the film, providing a unique
insight into America at the start of the twentieth century and
the beginnings of the motion picture industry in America.
The Films
MCKINLEY'S SECOND INAUGURATION [1901]
- President McKinley and Escort Going to the Capitol [1901]
- President McKinley Taking the Oath [1901]
MCKINLEY'S ASSASSINATION AND FUNERAL
- Arrival of McKinley's Funeral Train at Canton, Ohio [1901]
- Execution of Czolgosz, with Panorama of Auburn Prison [1901]
- Funeral Leaving the President's House and Church at Canton,
Ohio [1901]
- McKinley's Funeral Entering Westlawn Cemetery, Canton [1901]
- The Martyred Presidents [1901]
- The Mob Outside the Temple of Music at the Pan American
- Exposition [1901]
- President McKinley's Funeral Cortege at Buffalo, New York [1901]
- President's McKinley's Funeral Cortege at Washington, D.C.[1901]
- President Roosevelt at the Canton Station [1901]
- Taking President McKinley's Body From Train at Canton, Ohio
[1901]
- Panoramic View of the President's House at Canton, Ohio [1901]
THE PAN-AMERICAN EXPOSITION, BUFFALO, N.Y., 1901
- Circular Panorama of Electric Tower [1901]
- Esquimaux Game of Snap-the-Whip [1901]
- Esquimaux Leap-Frog [1901]
- Esquimaux Village [1901]
- Horse Parade at the Pan-American Exposition [1901]
- Japanese Village [1901]
- Pan-American Exposition by Night [1901]
- Panorama of Esplanade by Night [1901]
- Panoramic View of Electric Tower From a Balloon [1901]
- President McKinley Reviewing the Troops at the Exposition [1901]
- President McKinley's Speech at the Pan-American Exposition
[1901]
- Spanish Dancers at the Pan-American Exposition [1901]
- A Trip Around the Pan-American Exposition [1901]
- Opening, Pan-American Exposition [1901]
- Sham Battle at the Pam-American Exposition
II. THE LIFE OF A CITY: EARLY FILMS OF NEW YORK FROM THE PAPER
PRINT COLLECTION, 1898-1906
Introduction
THE LIFE OF A CITY: EARLY FILMS OF NEW YORK FROM THE PAPER PRINT
COLLECTION, contains forty-five films dating from 1898 to 1906
from the Library of Congress's Paper Print Collection. Of these,
twenty-five were made by the American Mutoscope and Biograph Company,
while the remaining twenty are Edison Company productions. They
are, with the exception of the "Fireboat New Yorker in Action" excerpt,
complete copies of the original paper roll versions. It is important
to remember that prior to 1912, film companies usually deposited
unedited, pre-production versions of their films for copyright.
Editing was left up to the exhibitor, who exercised considerable
control over the content of his "show." This explains the occasional "mistake" which,
while included here as part of the original artifact, probably
would have been edited out for exhibition. It also explains why
the films presented here can differ from written descriptions found
in the Edison and Biograph Company film catalogs of the period.
Forty-three of these films have been designated as "actualities." Predating
the newsreel, actualities are early silent films in which the camera
was used to record actual events, often simply scenes of everyday
life. The remaining two films, "What Happened on Twenty-third Street" a
novelty, and "The Skyscrapers" a melodrama, utilize actors and
contrived action. They are included on this videodisc because they
both contain significant segments of actuality footage. One film, "New
York Harbor Boat Patrol Capturing Pirates" shows a simulated action
scene. However, it may well be footage of a real training drill
so it is included here as an actuality.
The Cameramen
Thomas Edison's great pioneer cameraman and film-maker was Edwin
S. Porter, creator of "The Life of an American Fireman" (1902-1903)
and "The Great Train Robbery" (1903). Porter shot four of the films
included in this collection. Another Edison cameraman, James B.
Smith, photographed seven. Of the Biograph films, Billy Bitzer,
famous for his camera work with D. W. Griffith, shot nine, and
Frederick Armitage made five. Other cameramen whose films appear
on the disc are Alfred Abadie, Wallace McCutcheon, Arthur Marvin,
Robert Bonine, A. E. Weed, James Congdon, and Fred Dobson. In the
very early years of cinema, cameramen had to be inventors, electricians,
projectionists, and directors, in addition to cinematographers.
Some, like Bonine had been professional still photographers. Porter
and Bitzer were gifted electrical mechanics. W. K. L. Dickson,
Edison's first motion picture expert and eventual rival as a founding
partner of the American Mutoscope and Biograph Company, was both
a still photographer and an brilliant engineer.
The Actuality Film
The earliest popular venues for motion pictures were nickelodeons
- peep show parlors where machines played short film loops, or
films on flip cards called mutoscopes, for individual viewers on
demand. By the turn of the century, somewhat longer films were
being exhibited in vaudeville and burlesque theaters, sharing the
bill with a variety of "entertainments," which often included live
dramas, singers, and comedians. This change in venue coincides
with a gradual ascension over the next several years of the fiction
film, which would replace the actuality as the dominant form. The
popularity of actuality films peaked around 1903, then began to
decline. In 1903, the Edison and Biograph companies, combined,
registered three-hundred-and-fifty- one actuality films for copyright
protection (twenty-four of the forty-five films in this collection
were copyrighted that year). By 1908 that number had dropped to
two.(1) By 1911, movie theaters had proliferated, spreading out
from the cities to small-town America. Directors such as D.W. Griffith
and Edwin S. Porter were making tremendously popular dramatic movies,
and the actuality film had all but disappeared from the American
motion picture scene.
These films of New York City are a good representative sample
of the actuality genre. Included are subjects that were popular
not only in the peep show parlors of the 1890's, but much earlier,
in nineteenth century postcards, slides and magic lantern shows:
panoramic views, civic events, parades, new buildings, new inventions,
policemen and firemen in action, risque' novelties, and exotic
looking immigrants. Without question, early movie-makers borrowed
many of their themes and conventions from nineteenth century commercial
photography, and early audiences, while amazed by the moving images,
were very familiar with the subject matter.
The Life of A City
In many of the New York films, there is a sense of pride, or
perhaps a celebration of the city's emerging infrastructure. The
best of these films convey the sense that the already sprawling
city was in the midst of becomming something much more than a squalid,
chaotic metropolis; there are skyscrapers going up - the tallest
in the world, a great suspension bridge being opened - the largest
in the world, and a brand new subway system - the longest in the
world. We see a proud police force marching in front of a large
crowd, orderly columns of street sweepers parading in clean white
suits, and the most powerful fireboat in the world blasting jets
of water from all of its nozzels simultaneously.
Notable among the New York actualities is a recurring theme of
garbage disposal methods and equipment, showing that the city government
had developed the administrative ability to provide basic services
on a scale never before attempted anywhere. Grace M. Mayer, in
ONCE UPON A CITY points out this warning to visitors of New York
City made in 1842 by Charles Dickens in his AMERICAN NOTES: "Take
care of the pigs. Two portly sows are trotting up behind this carriage,
and a select party of half a dozen gentlemen hogs have just now
turned the corner. . . . They are the city scavengers, these pigs."(2)
The herds of pigs were in fact the first New York street cleaners,
and while there was some progress, little headway was made against
the filth of the city until Colonel George E. Waring and his army
of "White Wings" came on the scene. In 1900 Jacob Riis observed
in A TEN YEARS' WAR: "It was Colonel Waring's broom that first
let light into the slum. That which had come to be considered an
impossible task he did by the simple formula of 'putting a man
instead of a voter behind every broom.' The streets that had been
dirty were swept. The ash barrels which had befouled the sidewalks
disappeared. . . The trucks [more than 60,000 strong] that obstructed
the children's only playground, the street, went with the dirt.
. . . His broom saved more lives in the crowded tenements than
a squad of doctors. It did more: it swept the cobwebs out of our
civic brain and conscience, and set up a standard of a citizen's
duty which . . . will be ours until we have dragged other things
than our pavements out of the mud."(3) Little wonder then that
the "White Wings" paraded proudly in April of 1903, and that there
was an Edison cameraman there to film them.
NOTES
1. Patrick G. Loughney, A DESCRIPTIVE ANALYSIS OF THE LIBRARY
OF CONGRESS PAPER PRINT COLLECTION AND RELATED COPYRIGHT MATERIALS
(Ph.D. Diss., George Washington University, 1988), 369-372.
2. Grace M. Mayer, ONCE UPON A CITY (New York: MacMillan,
1958), 472.
3. Ibid., 474.
Technical Note
The movies on this disc are video transfers of new 35 mm film
copies that were made by sequentially photographing each frame
of the original paper print rolls onto 35 mm motion picture film.
The one-hour-per-side playing time was achieved by copying the
films to video at thirty frames-per-second (the playback speed
of a standard CAV videodisc) and instructing the user to play the
disc at one-half speed. For these early films made with hand-cranked
cameras, the resulting fifteen frames-per-second playback speed
is a good average.
Acknowledgements
This videodisc was produced and edited by Gene DeAnna, Motion
Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound Division, with Carl Fleischhauer
and Joanne B. Freeman of the American Memory Project. Videotape
mastering by James B. Winther, Recording Lab, Motion Picture, Broadcasting
and Recorded Sound Division. Engineering support by Paul Chrisman,
Recording Lab, Motion Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound
Division. Technical video editing by Capitol Video Communications,
Inc., Washington, DC. American Memory software developed by Paul
Heller, Heller Associates, Rockville, Maryland. Cataloging support
by Laurie Duncan, Motion Picture Cataloger, Motion Picture, Broadcasting
and Recorded Sound Division, and Elaine Woods, Consultant to American
Memory. Thanks to Patrick Loughney of the Motion Picture, Broadcasting
and Recorded Sound Division for his expertise on the Paper Print
films. Special thanks to Charles Sachs and the staff at the South
Street Seaport Museum in New York City for all of their help on
this project.
The Films
SCENES OF THE WATERFRONT
- Statue of Liberty [1898]
- Panorama Water Front and Brooklyn Bridge From East River [1903]
- Sky Scrapers of New York City, From the North River [1903]
- Panorama Of Blackwell's Island, N.Y. [1903]
- Emigrants [i.e., Immigrants] Landing at Ellis Island [1903]
- Arrival of Emigrants [i.e.Immigrants], Ellis Island [1906]
- Departure of Peary [and the] "Roosevelt" from New York [1905]
- Panoramic View of Brooklyn Bridge [1899]
- Panorama From the Tower of the Brooklyn Bridge [1903]
- New York Harbor Police Boat Patrol Capturing Pirates [1903]
- Fireboat New Yorker in Action [1903]
STREET SCENES AND BUILDINGS
- Panorama From Times Building, New York [1905]
- Broadway & Union Square, New York [1903]
- Lower Broadway [1903]
- Bargain Day, 14th Street, New York
- New York City Ghetto Fish Market [1903]
- Move On [1903]
- Delivering Newspapers [1903]
- A Street Arab [1898]
- At the Foot of the Flatiron [1903]
- What Happened on Twenty-Third Street, New York City [1901]
- Star Theatre [1902]
- Panorama Of Flatiron Building [1903]
- N.Y. Fire Department Returning [1903]
CENTRAL PARK
- Skating on Lake, Central Park [1902]
- Sleighing Scene [1898]
CONSTRUCTION SCENES
- Beginning of a Skyscraper [1902]
- A Perilous Proceeding [1902]
- Excavating for a New York Foundation [1903]
- The Skyscrapers [1906]
GARBAGE AND WASTE DISPOSAL
- New York City Dumping Wharf [1903]
- Sorting Refuse at Incinerating Plant, New York City [1903]
- Panorama Of Riker's Island, N.Y. [1903]
THE SUBWAY
- Excavation for Subway [1903]
- Pennsylvania Tunnel Excavation [1905]
- Elevated Railroad, New York [1903]
- Interior N.Y. Subway, 14th St. to 42nd St. [1905]
CIVIC CEREMONIES, PARADES AND PROCESSIONS
- Opening the Williamsburg Bridge [1904]
- Opening of New East River Bridge, New York [1903]
- Buffalo Bill's Wild West Parade [1902]
- Funeral of Hiram Cronk [1905]
- White Wings on Review [1903]
- New York Police Parade, June 1st, 1899
- Parade of `Exempt' Firemen [1903]
- Parade of Horses on Speedway [1903]
- Automobile Parade [1900]
III. EARLY FILMS OF SAN FRANCISCO, BEFORE AND AFTER THE GREAT
EARTHQUAKE AND FIRE, 1896-1915
Introduction
Of the twenty-six films on the videodisc "Early Films of San
Francisco, Before and After the Earthquake & Fire, 1897-1916" twenty-four
date from the period 1897-1906 and the remaining two from 1915
and 1916 respectively. The two major American film companies of
the pre-Hollywood era, Thomas A. Edison, Inc. and the American
Mutoscope and Biograph Company, each produced ten of the films.
The great Mack Sennett's famous Keystone Company produced one -
MABEL AND FATTY VIEWING THE WORLD'S FAIR AT SAN FRANCISCO, CAL
(1915). Additionally, there are five films acquired by the Library
from private collections for which there is no production information.
These are composites, pieced together from unidentified shorts.
It is likely that either the Edison or Biograph companies were
involved in the production of parts of at least four of them under
titles which to date have not been identified. The fifth, SAN FRANCISCO'S
FUTURE (1916), is an early civic propaganda film that combines
original animation and segments of newsreel footage. One of the
segments is identified as having come from a Hearst-Pathe newsreel,
but Hearst-Pathe's involvement, if any, in the actual production
of the film is unknown.
All twenty-six of the films are complete copies made from originals
in the collections of the Motion Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded
Sound Division of the Library of Congress. Nineteen of them are
from the Paper Print Collection, which contains more than 3,000
complete motion pictures re-photographed from rolls of paper positive
prints. These paper rolls were struck from the original camera
negatives and sent to the Library of Congress between 1894 and
1915 as still picture copyright deposits. Three films, SAN FRANCISCO
CHINESE FUNERAL (1903), EXPLODED GAS TANKS, U.S. MINT, EMPORIUM
AND SPRECKELS BLDG. (1906), and ARMY PACK TRAIN BRINGING SUPPLIES
(1906), are from the George Kleine Collection. This collection
of over 450 films was purchased in 1947 from the estate of the
pioneer movie producer and distributor, who was one of the first
moguls of the film industry. Another, TR IN SAN FRANCISCO (1903),
comes from the Theodore Roosevelt Association Film Collection,
transferred to the Library of Congress from the National Park Service
in the 1960s. These three great collections consist of thousands
of unique films dating back to the very beginnings of the motion
picture industry. In most instances they represent the only sources
for these films, and together they constitute what may be the world's
largest collection of films from the first two decades of American
cinema (1895-1915).
Early San Francisco
The great Chicago fire of 1871 and the 1906 earthquake and fire
of San Francisco link the histories of both places and render them
unique among other great American cities. Large conflagrations
were not uncommon in the cities of the nineteenth and early twentieth
centuries, quite the contrary. But the sheer level of destruction
resulting from these two disasters was extraordinary, exceeding
even that of the southern cities razed during the Civil War. That
comparison further pales since the Civil War pre-dated the phenomenal
growth of American cities that would mark the latter half of the
century. By contrast, 1906 San Francisco was already a booming
metropolis (as was Chicago in 1871 - albeit one built of wood),
having undergone a tremendously prosperous post-Civil War period
of growth and development.
Another difference arises because the destruction in the South
during the Civil War was relatively prolonged, eventually even
expected and inevitable. Unlike the San Francisco and Chicago disasters,
we can't look back to a single, terrible moment, precise and unexpected,
when the old city is doomed to rubble and ash and a new era of
reconstruction forced upon a population that had only the day before
gone about it's business in typical fashion. Americans can be thankful
that since 1906 no other major city has endured a catastrophe that
so starkly and thoroughly divided its history into eras of "before" and "after."
About the Films
On this videodisc, the before and after are separated on the
two sides. Side "A" of the videodisc is made up of seventeen films
which depict San Francisco and environs before the 1906 disaster,
while side "B" contains seven films of the earthquake and fire.
In addition, there is a 1915 travelogue by Keystone starring Mabel
Normand and Fatty Arbuckle that shows scenes of the rebuilt city
and a tour of the Panama Pacific Exposition, and a 1916 propaganda
film warning San Franciscans of the dangers of the isolationist
and radical labor movements.
The earthquake scenes, while spectacular, are essentially reportorial.
But the early movies photographed with no knowledge of the approaching
calamity, in addition to being rare, have a special significance
and poignancy. On one level they document how the buildings, streets,
and people looked. The detailed notes provided include this information
(along with some fascinating speculation) and reveal just how much
can be discerned by a meticulous and knowledgeable viewer. On another
level these hazy, grainy images bring to life a time and place
even further removed from us than the ninety or so years would
suggest, a time and place buried under a layer of ash, soot, and
crumbled brick.
Just looking at the subjects of the films can be revealing, though
most are typical of the actuality genre. Filmed in 1905 and obviously
re-titled after the disaster, A TRIP DOWN MARKET STREET BEFORE
THE FIRE showcases downtown San Francisco along the great boulevard.
To emphasize this (and no doubt to add to the visual excitement
of the scene) the producers had the same few automobiles circle
the cable car-mounted camera as it proceeded toward the Ferry Building
at the foot of Market Street. ARREST IN CHINATOWN (1897) was filmed
on Stout's Alley (now Ross Alley), called "Street of the Gambler's" by
Chinatown photographer Arnold Genthe (1869-1942) in his well known
1896 photograph (p. 179). Using hyperbole to make exotic foreigners
seem sinister and mysterious was standard practice, and while we
don't know how this film was promoted by the Edison Company, one
can imagine a turn-of-the-century "moving picture" exhibitor accompanying
this film with a chilling tale of tong "hatchet men," opium dens,
and white slavery.
The five films relating to Theodore Roosevelt's 1903 visit were
filmed by Herbert Miles for the Biograph Company. Well known for
making fight films and actualities of Alaska during the gold rush,
the Miles Brothers (Herbert and Harry) were also pioneers in the
development of motion picture distribution practices. The Roosevelt
films not only document the presidential visit, they also show
the great western metropolis in all its splendor, and indeed, we
can marvel at how immaculate the city looks. There is no mistaking
these scenes for New York City in 1903!
One of the films, A TRIP TO BERKELEY (1906), was actually taken
the month following the earthquake and fire, by Biograph cameraman
O.M. Gove. The idyllic views of the outskirts of Berkeley pose
a startling contrast to the scenes of destruction that he filmed
across the Bay during this same month. Obviously he wanted to present
a picture of life "untainted" by the disaster - such a movie would
probably be welcome escape for San Franciscans. In so doing he
anticipates, or perhaps knowingly duplicates, the escape many San
Franciscans made in the days and months following the catastrophe.
The last five films of side "A" present the natural beauty of
the San Francisco region and its attraction as a place of recreation
and leisure. Among the extant pre-earthquake actualities of San
Francisco, this theme is repeated most often. The Paper Print Collection
alone contains five films showing the scenery along the Mt. Tamalpais
and Mill Valley Railroad (only one is included on this videodisc).
It is the image of a prosperous, clean, unspoiled place where the
good life awaits that we see in these films. As the camera slowly
pans the beach in PANORAMA OF BEACH AND CLIFF HOUSE (1903) the
weekend crowds, the children playing in the surf, and the two smiling
young men in straw boaters project an innocent and happy assurance
that life is truly good in old San Francisco.
The Films
EARLY VIEWS OF THE CITY
- Trip Down Market Street Before the Fire [Post] [1902?] [9:29]
- Bird's-Eye View of San Francisco, Cal., From a Balloon [1902]
[2:44]
CHINATOWN BEFORE THE QUAKE & FIRE
- San Francisco Chinese Funeral [Kleine] [1903] [1:50]
- Scene in Chinatown [1903] [1:06]
- Arrest in Chinatown, San Francisco, Cal. [1897] [0:48]
PORT SCENES BEFORE THE EARTHQUAKE & FIRE
- Troops Embarking at San Francisco [1898] [0:52]
- Launch of Japanese Man-of-War "Chitosa" [i.e. "Chitose"] [1898]
[0:52]
THEODORE ROOSEVELT'S VISIT IN 1903
- Over Route of Roosevelt Parade in an Automobile [1903] [1:45]
- Market Street Before Parade [1903] [3:24]
- The President's Carriage [1903] [1:37]
- TR in San Francisco, 1903 [Roosevelt] [2:26]
- Panorama, Union Square, San Francisco [1903] [3:11]
SAN FRANCISCO ENVIRONS BEFORE THE EARTHQUAKE & FIRE
- A Trip to Berkeley, Cal. [1906] [3:05]
- Hotel Vendome, San Jose, Cal. [1897] [0:47]
- Mount Tamalpais R.R., no. 1 [1898] [0:52]
- Panoramic View of the Golden Gate [1902] [2:39]
- Panorama Of Beach and Cliff House [1903] [1:35]
THE 1906 EARTHQUAKE & FIRE
- San Francisco Disaster [1906] [2:43]
- San Francisco Earthquake and Fire [Adams] [1906] [13:00]
- Exploded Gas Tanks, U.S. Mint, etc... [Kleine] [1906] [2:15]
- Scenes in San Francisco #1 [1906] [2:14]
- Scenes in San Francisco #2 [1906] [4:46]
- [Unidentified Staples & Charles No. 1] [1906] [8:00]
- Army Pack Train Bringing Supplies [Kleine] [1906] [1:46]
THE REBUILT CITY / THE PANAMA-PACIFIC EXPOSITION / WORLD WAR
I
- Mabel & Fatty Viewing the World's Fair at San Francisco,
- Cal.[1915] [16:55]
- San Francisco's Future [Post] [1916] [5:41]
Acknowledgements
This videodisc was produced and edited by Gene DeAnna, Motion
Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound Division, with Carl Fleischhauer
of the American Memory project.
Videotape mastering was by James B. Winther, Recording Lab, Motion
Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound Division. Engineering
support was by Paul Chrisman, Recording Lab, Motion Picture, Broadcasting
and Recorded Sound Division. Cataloging support was by Laurie Duncan,
Motion Picture Cataloger, Motion Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded
Sound Division. Thanks to Paul Spehr and Patrick Loughney of the
Motion Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound Division for their
expertise on the paper print films.
Thanks to Library of Congress employees Ricki Erway, Jonese Hodges
and Jane Riefenhauser. The producers would like to especially acknowledge
the outstanding work of San Francisco historian Michael D. Lampen,
whose in-depth descriptions of each film vastly expanded our understanding
of this collection.
|