Summary of the matter addressed in the submission: The Submitter asserts that the alleged extraction activities have had a negative environmental impact and that Diamond Golf Internacional did not obtain the permits and authorizations required to carry out the mining activities. The Submitter claims it filed a citizen complaint (Denuncia Popular) with Mexico’s Federal Agency for Environmental Protection (Procuraduría Federal de Protección al Ambiente, PROFEPA) and that PROFEPA has taken action against the operator of the extraction activities but not against Diamond Golf Internacional. The Submitter also asserts that corrective measures ordered by PROFEPA have not been carried out. The Submitter asserts that, under Mexican law, the Mexican government should hold accountable Diamond Golf Internacional for restoration or compensation in connection with the environmental damage from the extraction activities.
Summary of the response provided by the Party:
In the first part of its response, Mexico presents arguments as to why it believes that the submission should be dismissed. As to the content of the submission, Mexico asserts that it acted diligently and enforced its law in relation to its handling of the complaint filed by the Submitter on 27 May 2003, and the ensuing inspection procedure, which led to the opening of an administrative file that is now closed. Mexico states that, according to the information in its possession, it did enforce the provisions governing its actions in those proceedings. However, it states that the Submitter did not supply information that would have been relevant in determining the legal nature of the real property mentioned in the complaint and in the citizen submission, and asserts that it became aware of this information only because it was appended to the submission.
Mexico requested that the response be kept confidential, with the exception of certain sections of its response covering preliminary matters. However, it provided a summary of these confidential sections, which is public.
|
Submitter(s)
Inmobiliaria J and B Empresas, S.A. de C.V.
More about the process Bringing the Facts to Light A Guide to Articles 14 and 15 of the North American Agreement on Environmental Cooperation More information >> [Download document]
|