This morning, the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations
continues its examination of "property flipping." As
we learned yesterday, flipping is a growing type of mortgage
fraud that has devastated families and neighborhoods throughout
the country.
In a typical flipping transaction, a con artist purchases a
run-down house in a low-income neighborhood. The seller makes
minor, cosmetic improvements to the property and then attempts
to unload the house on an unsuspecting buyer at a grossly
inflated price. These properties are usually resold at a
tremendous markup – often 100% or more – within a few months
or even days. "Flippers" usually target first-time,
low-income home buyers who are eager to own a home of their own
and are willing to trust sellers who promise them the American
dream of homeownership.
Our investigation found that these unsophisticated buyers are
generally unfamiliar with real estate transactions. They are
essentially at the mercy of unscrupulous sellers who are often
aided and abetted by unethical appraisers and lenders.
Once they have hooked the unsuspecting buyers, the sellers
make the arrangements to secure an FHA-backed mortgage loan to
finance the transaction. In some cases, if a buyer’s credit
history or financial condition would scuttle the deal,
fraudulent mortgage applications or phony gift letters are
crafted to grease the transaction.
The combination of inflated property prices, expensive
repairs, and adjustable rate mortgages often leave the buyers
with mortgage payments and other costs that they simply cannot
afford. Contrary to the explicit assurances of the sellers, the
properties are frequently in such poor condition that the buyers
must sink even more money into their homes just to render them
habitable. The result is sadly predictable. The sellers escape
with obscene profits, and the buyers default on their mortgages.
The ultimate result is often foreclosures that leave the owners
with no home, tarnished credit ratings, and broken promises.
Yesterday, we heard heart-wrenching testimony from three
first-time homebuyers who were victimized by property flippers.
They told tragic stories of high hopes that were dashed by
unscrupulous sellers, appraisers, and real estate agents – all
of whom were part of scams to sell them dilapidated, overvalued
houses.
Our witnesses showed the Subcommittee pictures of what they
had hoped would be their dream homes but which proved to be
houses that were crumbling and unsafe. We saw raw sewage backed
up through a toilet onto the bathroom floor, severe termite
infestation, rotting wood exteriors through which rats entered
the dwelling, a roof that was almost completely detached from
the rest of the house, dangerous structural damage, and faulty
electrical systems that repeatedly burned out, placing the
occupants at risk of a fire. The ultimate tragedy is that our
witnesses paid exorbitant prices for these atrocious homes and
are now saddled with mortgages and repairs that they cannot
afford.
I am outraged that hard-working Americans, such as those we
heard from yesterday, have become targets of con men disguised
as legitimate business people. I am particularly disturbed to
learn, however, that all the fraudulent loans examined during
the Subcommittee’s investigation were insured by the federal
government. Consequently, after the sellers walked away with
handsome profits, and the federal government picked up the tab
for the fraudulent loans.
I look forward to hearing from our witnesses this morning.