Cataloging Branch Operations Update
Remarks by Thomas A. Downing
Chief, Cataloging Branch
Library Programs Service
U.S. Government Printing Office
GODORT Cataloging Committee
American Library Association Midwinter Meeting
Sunday, February 16, 1997
Washington, DC
Good morning. I am pleased to have this opportunity to
provide an
update on Cataloging Branch operations and to be available for
questions
during our meeting. Thank you Dena for inviting me to provide a
review of
our operations. In particular, I join others in thanking you for
creating
an opportunity for people to hear the perspectives of Steve
Uthoff, our
administrative librarian for cataloging policies, and two of our
catalogers, Mike Levinson and Bob Luoma, regarding our Internet
cataloging
initiatives.
Given a full schedule and our keen interest in hearing
from Erik
Jul, of OCLC, and Eliot Christian of USGS, and other program
participants,
I will try to be brief. This overview will include remarks
concerning
cataloging related activities, dissemination of Monthly Catalog
records,
and the potential use of PURLs for maintaining online access to
Internet
documents.
Cataloging Operations
Since our fiscal year began in October, 1996, we have
continued to
witness and to become increasingly involved with the increased
use of the
Internet as a publishing medium for Federal agencies.
Statistical
information indicates a continuing decline in the number of
physical forms
with a continuing and dramatic increase in the number of titles
with
website locations.
Overall, the number of titles to be cataloged has
declined from
previous years. Last year our total count for work to be
cataloged was
32,102 titles. The total work processed related to 35,425 pieces
of work.
Of this figure, approximately 433 titles were associated with
Internet
sites.
In the current fiscal year, from October 1996 through the
end of
this January, we received 9,904 pieces of work. Annualized
projections
for this figure suggest that we may receive approximately 29,712
pieces of
work during this fiscal year. To date, we have processed 6,874
pieces.
Of this number, 5,734 titles have been cataloged. Of these
titles
cataloged, approximately 734 titles are related to Internet
titles.
Internet Titles
Many of these 734 Internet related titles were held in
save files
during FY 1996 and were produced this fiscal year (awaiting the
resolution
of some GPO website related problems. Nonetheless, it appears
that
production of Internet related Monthly Catalog records during the
first
four months of this fiscal year has exceeded all Internet related
records
produced during the previous fiscal year.
As of the present time, approximately 1,200 Monthly
Catalog
records contain URL data. Of this number approximately 50
records do not
connect to sites as of the first week in January, 1997. While
this is not
a major number of problem URLs, efforts to resolve these URLs,
either by
finding a more recent URL or by determining that the title is no
longer
available via the Internet, has taken considerable time and
effort. I
will discuss PURLs and how this technology may be used later in
my
remarks.
A recent review of our site indicates that approximately
112
Monthly Catalog records with URLs were produced for only an
Internet
document and are not associated with any physical form.
Approximately
1,088 records are associated with both physical forms and
Internet
versions.
Work to be Cataloged
At the present time, our cataloging backlog consists of
approximately 3,238 titles. This information is based on an
inventory
that was conducted last Thursday, February 13th. Approximately
58 of
these titles are Internet related.
We currently catalog most Internet related and paper
titles within
approximately one week of receipt or notification. Microfiche
and CD-ROMs
continue to be cataloged within approximately two weeks after
receipt.
The backlog of Internet titles that I had reported during the
fall meeting
of the Depository Library Council has been cleared.
We continue to focus efforts to assure that cataloging
occurs soon
after notification or receipt of titles and we maintain these
objectives
even as some catalogers leave or retire. Within the last six
months, one
cataloger has transferred to another organization within the
Library
Programs Service and one person has retired. We have recently
posted a
vacant cataloger position and have brought some copies of the
announcement
to our meeting to encourage interest. We may post yet another
vacancy to
preclude cataloging backlogs.
With limited personnel resources, our policies for
cataloging
Internet related titles both conform to CONSER policies and make
it
possible for us to catalog titles soon after receipt or
notification and
to avoid major backlogs. Our policies provide electronic access
via
records with Internet related notes and hot linked URLs. I have
been
pleased to work with Jean Hirons, Acting CONSER Coordinator, and
with
Steve Uthoff and others in our Cataloging Branch in joint efforts
to
develop policies.
We have brought some copies of our policies for
cataloging
electronic files for your review. these policies are consistent
with both
national policies and traditional practices associated with the
GPO
Cataloging Guidelines.
Although a number of people have contributed to
developing our
policies, these policies would not exist without Steve Uthoff's
knowledge,
experience, and exceptional and committed efforts. These
policies are
important documents that will guide our work for many years.
Thank you
Steve for your excellent work in this regard. In the near
future, we
expect to publish an electronic version of these policies to add
to
several other cataloging policies now available at the FDLP
Administrative
page.
Given the interest in Internet publishing, I would like
to take a
moment and summarize our approach to cataloging Internet titles.
First, we catalog Internet related titles as personnel of
the
Depository Administration Branch (DAB) notify us of titles.
We do not devote valuable resources to surfing the net
and rely on
DAB personnel to validate electronic titles and notify us of
their
location, class number, and other essential information.
We produce records at the full level for serials and maps
and at
the abridged or "K" level for non-serials. Records include class
numbers,
item numbers, and SuDocs numbers.
If a physical form record is already available when we
are
notified of an Internet version, we update the physical form
record with a
note regarding Internet availability in the 530 note field and
with a URL
in the 856 field. URLs are hot-linked from our website edition
of the
Monthly Catalog. (If the physical form record is full level, we
conform
to OCLC instructions and do not remove existing information to
make the
record conform to "K" level specifications).
If a physical form record is not available, we create a
record for
the electronic Internet title at "I" (full) or "K" level
(abridged)
depending upon whether or not the title is a serial.
If a record for an electronic-only Internet title record
is
available and physical forms are issued after an electronic title
has been
cataloged, we update the existing record with an 074 field (item
number
reflecting the format), and a 530 "other formats available note"
and
produce the record again. Such records will have multiple item
numbers.
In some instances, as in the case of a title that is very
well
known and of major importance, we may, based upon a subjective
evaluation,
create separate records that reflect such versions.
We do not have adequate personnel resources to
consistently
produce separate records for each format of every title. We hope
that
people understand these limitations and find this approach to be
suitable.
In important respects, our policies for using a single record to
reflect
Internet and physical form versions of a title is similar to our
long-standing policy of using a single record to reflect paper
and
microfiche versions of the same title.
Monthly Catalog Dissemination
Before moving on to a brief statement concerning PURLs, I
would
like to provide some information regarding the website and CD-ROM
editions
of the Monthly Catalog.
Our CD-ROM edition of the Monthly Catalog has entered its
second
year with a cumulation of approximately 21,672 records.
Approximately
19,382 records reflect 1996 cataloging production and 2,290
records
reflect production in January of 1997. This is our first
combined year
edition. Each issue includes Periodical Supplements for 1996 and
1997.
We expect to publish monthly editions of several complete years
of
accumulated records as we move towards the next century.
Also, we have another first. We now have an opportunity
to
include the Congressional Serial Set Catalog (102nd Congress) as
a
searchable file as part of the CD-ROM edition of the Monthly
Catalog. If
we publish the Congressional Serial Set Catalog in CD-ROM only,
we should
save approximately $30,000 to $35,000 by eliminating the paper
edition.
This is not a great sum of money, but elimination of a paper
edition would
help to further reduce program costs. We would be pleased to
hear your
advice with regard to this opportunity.
Our Monthly Catalog website edition, (located at:
http://www.access.gpo.gov/su_docs/dpos/adpos400.html), contains
approximately 80,665 records. Approximately 1,200 of these
records
contain hot-linked URLs.
PURLs
No description of current operations would be complete
without
some mention of PURLs, or Persistent Uniform Resource Locators.
With the
significant number of Monthly Catalog records with URLs, PURLs
are of
interest to us because use of OCLC's PURLs software would provide
us with
an alternative to replacing records each time a URL within
records
changes. However, although PURLs may seem to be magic because
they
provide users with a seamless redirection to a current address,
PURLs are
not. We all know that, to be of value, a PURL server must be
maintained
through the efforts of those who keep URLs current.
Not wishing to undertake a project without a thorough
review of
its implications for our limited number of staff, we are
carefully
reviewing how this project should be undertaken within the
Library
Programs Service.
We appreciate Erik Jul's assistance and advice with
regard to
PURLs and look forward to continued discussions as we move in
this
direction.
[ Back to the Table of
Contents ]