![]() |
![]() |
|||||||
|
||||||||
|
Joint Fact Finding: A New Approach to Balancing Science and Politics in Ecosystem- and Resource-Management Decisions
A central tenet of the course was that conventional scientific practice can lead to adversarial science, commonly alienating the public as well as elected and appointed decisionmakers. Joint fact finding, one phase of a broader consensus-building approach, was presented as an alternative strategyÑone that is more effective in generating constructive and lasting agreements about contentious environmental issues. In this process, stakeholders representing a wide variety of interests work together to:
In addition to lectures richly textured with illustrative examples and sprinkled with humor, the fast-moving course (complete with a healthy dose of homework!) also included an exploration of two USGS "real-world" case studies, plus various complex role-playing scenarios. One of the highlights of the course was an address by USGS Director Chip Groat, followed by a lively discussion of the USGS' mission and the role of its scientists in bringing policy-relevant research to the joint-fact-finding process. Lead instructors for the course were Lawrence Susskind (CBI, Massachusetts Institute of Technology), Howard Raiffa (Harvard University), and Lawrence Dixon (CBI). USGS cosponsors were Herman Karl (Geography Discipline), Lisa Robbins (Geology Discipline), and Christine Turner (Geology Discipline) with Richard Zirbes (Geography Discipline). This undertaking was part of the USGS' Integrated-Science Community-Based Values in Land Use Decision-Making (INCLUDE) activity's ongoing research and mission to explore the role of science and scientists in collaborative problem-solving processes. Participants included approximately 40 physical and social scientists, analysts, and managers from USGS offices across the country (representing each USGS discipline plus the Director's Office), as well as Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Collaborative Decisions, Umhverfisrannsoknir ehf of Iceland, the California Coastal Conservancy, Duke University, North Carolina State University, the University of Pittsburgh, the University of Washington, and the National Research Council. Among those associated with USGS coastal science and research were Chris Barton, Tonya Clayton, Jack Kindinger, George Kish, Terri Lee, and Lisa Robbins from the St. Petersburg and Tampa, FL, offices; and Brad Barr (NOAA National Marine Sanctuary Program), Deborah Hutchinson, and Eric Sundquist from Woods Hole, MA.
|
![]() |
![]()
in this issue:
Adriatic Sea Sediment-Transport Cruise Assateague Island Vegetation Mapping Field-Testing New Portable Drilling System Woods Hole Field Center Open House St. Petersburg Field Center Open House Fourth-Graders Tour St. Petersburg Field Center
Planning Gas-Hydrates Research Science and Politics in Ecosystem Decisions Louisiana Coastal-Restoration Advisory Board Air Medical Transport Center Tour ![]() |