skip navigational linksDOL Seal - Link to DOL Home Page
Photos representing the workforce - Digital Imagery© copyright 2001 PhotoDisc, Inc.
www.dol.gov
November 5, 2008    DOL Home > News Release Archives > OSEC/OPA 1997   

Printer-Friendly Version

Archived News Release--Caution: information may be out of date.

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR

Office of Public Affairs

OPA Press Release: U.S. Department of Labor Compliance Survey Finds More Than Half of New York City Garment Shops in Violation of Labor Laws [10/16/1997]

For more information call: (202) 219-8211

 
	 

The U.S. Labor Department announced today the results of the first-ever investigation-based compliance survey of garment shops in New York City for compliance with the provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). Of 94 garment contractors investigated by the Department's Wage and Hour Division, 59 shops--or 63 percent--were found in violation of the minimum wage and overtime provisions of the FLSA.

"Obviously, these results are unacceptable," said Labor Secretary Alexis M. Herman. "They show that neither the Department nor the garment industry can become any less diligent. In fact, we must redouble our efforts to seek solutions to the serious sweatshop problem in New York City."

Investigators found more than 1,400 garment workers due more than $412,300 in back wages. To date, more than $396,073 in back wages have been restored to 1,360 workers.

The overall rate of compliance with the minimum wage and overtime provisions of the FLSA was only 37 percent, and overtime violations were found at more than twice the rate of minimum wage violations. In addition, 70 percent of the shops violated the record keeping requirement.

This year, the Wage and Hour Division has hired 16 additional investigators for the New York City metropolitan area --all with bilingual ability in Chinese or Spanish. In light of the survey results, Wage and Hour has instituted a new strategy for targeting manufacturers with a history of contracting with garment shops routinely found in violation of labor laws. Specifically, this new strategy includes:

  • targeting contractor shops who repeatedly violate labor laws;
  • working with manufacturers who contract with repeat violators to monitor their contractor shops for compliance with labor laws;
  • seeking legal actions, such as temporary restraining orders to prevent the shipment of "hot goods" (goods made in violation) by these manufacturers;
  • increasing surveillance to address the serious payroll falsification problem;
  • working in partnership with other federal, state and city agencies to increase overall enforcement effectiveness; and
  • conducting monthly seminars with manufacturers to assist them in implementing and maintaining an effective monitoring program.

The New York City survey consisted of a random sample of the latest available information regarding known garment contractors in all five boroughs. Among other purposes, this and other investigation-based surveys help establish a statistically valid baseline of compliance in order to track industry compliance over the long term.

Surveys also provide information on how to better focus the department's efforts to improve compliance. For example, Wage and Hour investigators will give increased attention to the locality with the highest violation rate, the Chinatown section of Manhattan, where nearly nine out of ten shops were found in violation of the monetary provisions of FLSA.

Investigators also learned that fewer than 10 percent of the contractors were being informally monitored by their manufacturers, a technique which has been shown to be effective in reducing the number of violations.

"The results clearly suggest that manufacturers should be monitoring contractor shops more," said Herman. "Through effective monitoring and other efforts, all levels of the industry and the government must commit to work in partnership to ensure that these hard-working garment workers are protected and paid the wages they so justly deserve."

A 1996 survey in Los Angeles found a comparable rate of compliance at 39 percent, but nearly one-half of all shops were being monitored. There, 61 percent of the monitored shops were in compliance with the overtime requirement as compared to 25 percent of the non-monitored shops. A 1997 survey in the San Francisco Bay area found 87 percent of the monitored shops in compliance with overtime as compared to 68 percent in the non-monitored shops.


Archived News Release--Caution: information may be out of date.




Phone Numbers