Skip Navigation U.S. Department of Health and Human Services www.hhs.gov
Agency for Healthcare Research Quality www.ahrq.gov
www.ahrq.gov


Table 5.  Nutrition Interventions

Author, Year Nutritional Category Population N Initial Blood Levels Significant Results Adverse Effects
Dalton, 199788 Calcium
Iron
Phosphorus
Infants aged 3.6-6 months in Lawrence, MA. High proportion of low income families. Data collected 1991-1993. Majority Latino (>90%). 103 0.12 µmol/dL - 0.07 µmol/dL There were no significant differences by treatment group in mean or median change from baseline of serum ferritin, total iron binding capacity, erthrocyte protoporphyrin, or hematocrit at 4 and 9 months after enrollment. Incidence of iron deficiency was similar for both groups and no infant developed iron deficiency anemia during the trial. ND
Gallicchio, 200295 Calories
Carbohydrates
Fat
Vitamin C
Children, age 1 (approximately), from low income families, living in urban houses built prior to 1950. 85% African American. 205 mean 4.0 µg/dL (range 1-19 µg/dL) 4.9% > 10 µg/dL Statistically significant positive associations (p<0.05) were found between blood lead and calories, total fat, saturated fat, and monounsaturated fat. Statistically significant negative associations (p<0.05) were found between blood lead and carbohydrates and vitamin C.

After multiple linear regression analyses, statistically significant positive associations were found between blood lead and total fat (p=0.03) as well as blood lead and saturated fat (p=0.02), independent of lead exposure and age of the child. Total caloric intake was found to be a marginally significant effect modifier of the association between lead exposure and blood lead (p=0.06).
ND
Hammad, 199697 Iron Children from 9 months-5 years old cared for at University of Maryland at Baltimore Pediatric Ambulatory Center. Low income, inner-city families. 299 NA Average blood lead was 11.4 µg/dL. After adjusting for confounders using multiple linear regression models, a negative association between blood lead and dietary iron intake was found (p=0.03). No association was found between blood lead and serum iron. ND
Haynes, 200394 Calcium
Iron
Children living in Rochester, NY and were 5-7 months old at baseline visit. Low income families. (same participants in Lanphear, 2002) 275
(245 at 24 months, 239 with adequate blood samples)
NA Calcium intake was inversely associated with children's blood lead (p=0.03) in a multivariate model that included VDR Fok 1 genotype as an independent variable. ND
Lanphear, 200293 Iron
Calcium
Vitamin C
Vitamin D
Children living in Rochester, NY and were 5-7 months old at baseline visit. Low income families. (same participants in Haynes, 2003) 249 2.9 µg/dL (95% CI, 2.7-3.1) At 24 months of age, BLLs were 7.5 µg/dL. 82 (33%) had BLLs >10 µg/dL; 32 (13%) had BBLs >15 µg/dL; 14 (6%) had BBLs   >20 µg/dL.

Dietary iron intake was inversely associated with BLLs (p=0.03) during first year of life. Calcium intake was not associated with BLL concentration.
ND
Lee, 200510 Calories
Fat
Thiamine
Pyridoxine
Vitamin E
Ascorbic acid
Folate
Calcium
Phosphorus
Iron
Women 20-49 years old from National Health and Nutritional Survey (NHANES III) 4,394

(3,716 had complete data for all variables in study)
NA Average BLL of reproductive age woman was 1.78 µg/dL.

Inverse associations (p<0.05) between BLL and thiamine and serum folate. Positive associations (p<0.05) between BLL and iron, pyridoxine intake, and folate.
ND
Lucas, 199696 Calories
Fat
Children ages 9-6 years, cared for at University of Maryland at Baltimore Pediatric Ambulatory Center. Low income, inner-city families. 296 NA Average blood lead was 11.4 µg/dL. After adjusting for confounders using multiple linear regression models, significant positive associations with blood lead were found independently for total caloric intake (p=0.01) and dietary fat (p=0.05). ND
Markowitz, 199681 Iron Moderately lead poisoned children referred to Montefiore Medical Lead Clinic from 1986-1992 with BLLs 25-55 µg/dL. Low income, inner-city families, living in pre-1960 housing. 2/3 Hispanic, 1/3 African American. 79 NA BLLs declined 27% on average over 6 months. Two thirds <25 µg/dL, 7% <15 µg/dL. However, iron status did not account for change in BLLs. ND
Markowitz, 200489 Calcium Children ages 1-6 referred to Montefiore Medical Center with BLLs between 10-44 µg/dL 88 10-44 µg/dL No significant differences between BLLs in either group. Ca supplementation of 1800 mg/day for 3 months or 6 months did not reduce BLLs. Abdominal pain complaints occurred infrequently in both groups.
Sargent, 199990 Calcium
Iron
Phosphorus
Infants aged 3.6 - 6 months in Lawrence, MA. High proportion of low income families. Data collected 1991-1993. Majority Latino (>90%). 103; complete lab data collected for 81 (78.6%) of original random assignment <25 µg/dL There was no significant difference between groups in the mean ratio of urinary calcium to creatinine, serum calcium and phosphorus, or change in iron status (serum ferritin, total iron binding capacity). At month 4, the median increase from baseline BLLs in the treatment group was 57% of the increase for the control group (p=0.039), but this effect weakened after month 4 through the final 9th month of the trial. Because the effect did not last, cannot conclude that calcium glycerohosphate supplement prevented lead absorption. 10 children distributed evenly between groups has at least one urine sample with a ratio of urinary calcium to creatinine above the age-related norm; 2 had repeat elevated levels (one in each group); 1 in control group had elevated serum calcium level; 13 had low serum ferritin concentrations (5 control, 8 treatment).
Schell, 200491 Calcium
Ferritin
Iron
Protein
Supplements
Vitamin D
Zinc
Mother/Infant pairs of low socioeconomic status in Albany County, NY from APILS (Albany pregnancy infancy lead study) 1992-1998 169 1.6-10 µg/dL at birth By 6 months, mean BLLs significantly increased from birth to 2.3 µg/dL (p<0.001); none were >10 µg/dL. By 12 months, mean BLLs significantly increased from 6 months to 5.1 µg/dL (p<0.001) and 18% were >10 µg/dL.

Observed significant inverse relationships between infant's 6 month lead level and intake of zinc (p=0.003), iron (p=0.015), and calcium (p<0.001). At 12 months, low iron intake continued to be associated with higher lead levels (p=0.041), although zinc and calcium did not. Protein had a paradoxal effect (associated with lower lead at 6 months (p=0.001), but higher lead at 12 months. Serum vitamin D and ferritin were not associated with lead levels, nor was vitamin supplement use.
ND
Schnell, 200392 Calcium
Ferritin
Iron
Supplements
Vitamin D
Zinc
Mother/Infant pairs of low socioeconomic status in Albany County, NY from APILS (Albany pregnancy infancy lead study) 1992-1998 220 1.58 µg/dL neonates Mother's BLLs were strongly and positively related to neonates BLLs (p<0.001). For the anthropometric measures of maternal nutritional status, variables measuring gain in weight and arm circumference were negatively related to neonate BLLs (p<0.001). Dietary intakes in iron (p=0.003) and vitamin D (p=0.038) were negatively related to neonates BLLs. The effects of zinc varied substantially. Calcium was negatively related to BLLs before controlling for age, education index, etc. (p=0.042), but not after controlling for these variables. Serum ferritin, serum vitamin D, and supplements were not significantly related to BLLs of neonates. African American mothers and newborns have significantly higher BLLs than Caucasians (p<0.001), except in the 2nd trimester. ND
Simon, 199998 Ascorbic acid Probability sample of US population from the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES III), 1988-1994 without a history of lead poisoning. Adults and youths. 4,213 youths aged 6-16 and 15,365 adults aged >17 ND 22 (0.5%) youths had elevated BLLs. 57 (0.4%) adults had elevated BLLs. Serum ascorbic levels ranged from 0-170 µmol/L, with the mean for the youths 55 micro mol/L and mean for the adults 43 µmol/L.

After controlling for the effects of age, race, sex, income level, and dietary energy, fat, calcium, iron, and zinc intake, youths in the highest serum ascorbic acid tertile had an 89% decreased prevalence of elevated BLLs compared with youths in the lowest serum ascorbic acid tertile (p=0.002). Adults in the highest 2 serum ascorbic acid tertiles had a 65% to 68% decreased prevalence of elevated BLLs compared with adults in the lowest serum ascorbic acide tertile (p=0.03). As a continuous predictor, serum ascorbic acid level was independently associated with decreased BLLs among adults (p<0.001), but not among youths.
ND
Zierold, 200499 Many, not described Data from Wisconsin Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program from 1996-2000. Children ages 0-6. 111,196 Mean 5.29 µg/dL For those in the Special Nutrition Program, mean BLLs declined over the 4 year time period from 7.89 µg/dL to 5.29 µg/dL. Average BLLs decline of 0.64 µg/dL per year.

For the comparison group, mean BLLs declined over the 4 year time period from 5.51 µg/dL to 3.70 µg/dL. Average BLLs decline of 0.42 µg/dL per year. The difference between the groups was not statistically significant (p=0.25). African American children in the Special Nutrition Program BLLs had a significantly quicker decline compared with Caucasian children (p=0.03).
ND

Abbreviations: BLL=Blood lead level; ND= Not described.

Return to Document

 

AHRQ Advancing Excellence in Health Care