You Are Here: AHRQ Home > Clinical Information > Technology Assessments > Call for Public Review > Public Review Form

Technology Assessment Public Review Form

Project Title: Draft White Paper: Potential Conflict of Interest in the Production of Drug Compendia (PDF file, 470 KB; PDF Help) (DRAFT)

Project ID: CMPE1207

Instructions

We greatly appreciate your assistance with the scientific review of this technology assessment!

Please use this form to guide your comments. You do not need to answer all the questions.
You may submit your form by clicking the "SUBMIT" button at the bottom of the form.
Note that review forms must be received by 5 pm Eastern Time on the final day of the review period (November 5, 2008). Late documents will not be accepted.
Review forms received within the review period will be forwarded to the authors.
If you have any questions, please contact ahrqtap@ahrq.hhs.gov.

Reviewer's Contact Information

If you would like to provide your name and contact information, please submit this information below. This is not mandatory; however, it enables us to contact you if we have any questions about your comments.

Name*:

Affiliation*:

E-mail Address*:

Phone Number*:

Review Questions

Please answer the following questions with "YES," "SOMETIMES," or "NO," and add a brief explanation of answers and comments in the "Comments" space provided. Note that you do not need to answer all of the questions.

General Comments:

1) Is the purpose of the paper clear?
2) Is the paper well structured and organized?
3) Were all important issues considered?

Comments:

Methods:
4) Are the methods appropriate?
5) Is any relevant information missing?

Comments:

Results:
6) Were the results stated clearly and were the figures and tables clear?

Comments:

Conclusions:
7) Are the major findings clearly stated?

Comments:

Additional Comments:
If we have missed relevant information, please describe it here:

Please add any other comments and suggestions for improving the content and format of this paper here: