Students at Job Corps Center Learn methods to cut and
install siding. |
Photo
by: Michael Carpenter |
Overview
Studies reveal strong correlations among poverty, lack of a high school
diploma, joblessness, youth violence, and crime. DOL administers youth programs
under the Workforce Investment Act, including the Job Corps program, the youth
formula grant program, the Youth Opportunity Grant Program, as well as the
recently sunset School-to-Work initiative, and research and demonstration
projects that address the persistent unemployment challenges of at-risk youth
both in and out-of-school.
Serving the Public
DOLs youth programs primarily serve those youth who are
out-of-school, and those who are in school but at risk of dropping out of
school. They are intended to provide the necessary support for in-school youth
to complete secondary school, move into post-secondary education, and
transition into successful careers. In addition, these programs provide
education, training, and support services, to the hardest to serve
out-of-school youth providing them with the skills necessary to enter and
succeed in todays workforce.
Statistics support the notion that education and training programs are
more effective when they are delivered with extensive support services. DOL has
found that the following 10 elements are key ingredients of effective youth
programs: (1) tutoring and study skills training; (2) alternative secondary
school services; (3) summer employment opportunities linked to academic and
occupational learning; (4) paid and unpaid work experiences; (5) occupational
skills training; (6) leadership development; (7) supportive services; (8) adult
mentoring; (9) comprehensive guidance and counseling; and (10) long-term
follow-up. The Workforce Investment Act substantially reformed the
formula-funded youth program to require this comprehensive range of services to
meet the employment, career, and educational goals of youth.
In addition to the formula-funded program, the Job Corps administers
services in a concentrated manner. Job Corps provides intensive, long-term
training in a residential setting and offers a wide range of supportive
services, including a secure, drug-free learning environment, medical care, and
career and personal counseling. The Job Corps has also placed increased
emphasis on education especially the attainment of a high school diploma
which has been shown in many studies to increase an individuals
employment and earnings potential. During DOLs recent Summit on the 21st
Century Workforce, the Departments of Education and Labor announced a new joint
proposal to include establishing a Job Corps distance-learning program through
a National High School and forming partnerships between Job Corps centers and
public schools.
Text version
Outcome Goal 1.2 Net Costs ($B) |
|
Program Costs
The decrease in net costs in FY 2000 may be substantially attributed to
the transition from the Job Training Partnership Act program to that under the
Workforce Investment Act. The subsequent increase in costs in FY 2001 reflects:
(1) the increased spending by the States on program operations as the training
tempo increased following the start-up activities in FY 2000, and (2) the
start-up of a new youth opportunity grant program funded at $300 million.
DOL Challenges for the Future
According to 2000 Census data, 16.2 percent of children under 18 years
old (over five million children) are living in poverty. According to the Bureau
of Labor Statistics, the unemployment rate of 16-24 year olds has increased
from 9.1 percent in June 2000 to 10.4 percent through June 2001. Over the next
four years the Census Bureau estimates that the number of 15-24 year olds will
increase by over two million. In order to meet the challenge of serving these
young people most in need, DOL will focus its efforts to improve the delivery
of youth services under its Workforce Investment Act, Job Corps, and Youth
Opportunity Grants programs.
The Department of Labor enters the 21st Century facing many new and
continuing challenges. Preparing all youth for future careers in a rapidly
changing, technologically driven economy presents special challenges. By
focusing on a holistic youth development approach to serving young people, DOL
youth programs will equip youth with the skills necessary to succeed in the
21st Century workforce.
ASSIST YOUTH IN MAKING THE TRANSITION TO WORK
Of the 14-18 year-old youth registered under the WIA youth program,
50 percent will be either employed, in advanced training, post-secondary
education, military service or apprenticeships in the third quarter after
program exit.
Results: This goal was substantially achieved, with 47.4 percent
of youth either employed, in advanced training, post-secondary education,
military service or apprenticeships in the third quarter after program exit.
Program Description: Title I of the Workforce Investment Act
(WIA) serves eligible low-income youth between the ages of 1421 who have
barriers to employment, including those who have deficiencies in basic skills
or meet one or more of these criteria: homeless, a runaway, pregnant,
parenting, an offender, school dropout, or a foster child. The program also
serves youth with disabilities and others who may require additional assistance
to complete an educational program or to secure and hold employment. Programs
and services are offered to both in and out-of-school youth, with at least 30
percent of the funds being spent on out-of-school youth. Service strategies
prepare youth for post-secondary education by stressing strong linkages between
academic and occupational learning, and preparing youth for employment. Local
communities create opportunities for youth by providing required program
elements, including: tutoring, alternative schools, summer employment,
occupational training, work experience, supportive services, leadership
development, mentoring, counseling, and follow-up services.
Analysis of Results: Two factors have had an impact on the
Departments fully achieving this goal:
- Results for this goal were computed using preliminary data.
Only 42 of the 53 States and jurisdictions have reported final data, and 7 of
the States submitted data that are questionable. For the most part, reporting
problems can be attributed to introducing a new performance data reporting
system with the implementation of the Workforce Investment Act this year. The
Department is now working with States experiencing problems to obtain accurate
data. When the States report final data in January 2002, results should better
reflect actual performance.
- Results include three quarters of participant data from the prior
Job Training Partnership Act (JTPA) Title II-C youth program. Data used to
compute this measure are based on youth who terminated during the final three
quarters of the JTPA program, with only one quarter of data from the WIA
program. Since the JTPA program placed much less emphasis on follow-up and
measuring longer-term outcomes, lower retention levels in this first year of
the program most likely stem from the JTPA data.
Strategies: The Workforce Investment Act, fully effective in
Program Year 2000, introduced substantial reforms for youth programs, placing a
stronger emphasis on more comprehensive, long-term activities coupled with at
least twelve months of follow-up after program completion. During this initial
period of program implementation, DOL mounted efforts to establish Youth
Councils as a new governance body and advocate for youth in the local
communities. DOL also provided technical assistance and training to help the
States and local communities implement the newly required WIA youth services as
well as the performance management and reporting systems that support the
program.
Goal Assessment and Future Plans:
To increase the programs focus on educational attainment for this
age group, the Department has revised the Program Year 2002 performance
measures for the 14 to 18 year-old youth served by the Workforce Investment
Act. The new measure targets attainment of a secondary school diploma or
equivalent by the first quarter after exit for 51 percent of the 14-18 year-old
youth who enter the program without these credentials.
Program Evaluation: The Office of Inspector General issued the
final audit report on Job Training Partnership Act, Title II-C
Out-of-School Program Performance on March 19, 2001. The OIG
reported that:
- Positive outcomes for the Title II-C Out-of-School Youth Program
were significantly lower than those reported;
- Documentation supporting youth employability enhancements was
seriously deficient; and
- Participants post-program earnings were affected by program
interventions and level of their participation.
Recommendations included:
Text version
Workforce Investment Act Youth Programs, 14-18
Year-Old Percent Employed, Advanced Training, Post-Secondary
Education, Military Service or Aprenticeship.
|
|
- Conduct data validation effort as a part of program monitoring; and
- Notify all States and the substate grantees of:
- Audit results with emphasis on the necessity for States and their
grantees to validate outcome data as part of their monitoring program and
training provider eligibility determinations;
- The importance of documenting not only reported outcomes but also
specific services provided, dates services were provided, and actual program
exit date; and
- The importance of not only enrolling youth in occupational skills
training activities, but also finding ways to keep them actively participating
in the program to completion, to maximize their post-program earnings.
In response, to OIGs findings and recommendations, the Department
issued comprehensive guidance on youth services and a notice about this audit
to the States and substate grantees. Finally, DOL is undertaking a data
validation initiative which is attempting to create both more precise
programming specifications and more precise standards for validating data
quality. For further information about this audit, please refer to Appendix 3.
■
(Goal 1.2A FY 2000 Annual Performance Plan)
ASSIST YOUTH IN MAKING THE TRANSITION TO WORK
Of the 19-21 year-old youth served under the WIA youth program, 70
percent will be employed in the third quarter after program exit.
Results: This goal was achieved. 74.4 percent of
19-21 year-old youth were employed in the third quarter after program exit.
Text version
Workforce Investment Act Youth Programs,
19-21 Year-Old Percent Employed |
|
Program Description: Title I of the Workforce
Investment Act (WIA) serves eligible low-income youth, between the ages of 14
21, who have barriers to employment, including those who have
deficiencies in basic skills or meet one or more of these criteria: homeless, a
runaway, pregnant, parenting, an offender, school dropout, or a foster child.
The program also serves youth with disabilities and others who may require
additional assistance to complete an educational program or to secure and hold
employment. Programs and services are offered to both in and out-of-school
youth, with at least 30 percent of the funds being spent on out-of-school
youth. Service strategies prepare youth for post-secondary education by
stressing strong linkages between academic and occupational learning, and
preparing youth for employment. Local communities create opportunities for
youth by providing required program elements, including: tutoring, alternative
schools, summer employment, occupational training, work experience, supportive
services, leadership development, mentoring, counseling, and follow-up
services.
Analysis of Results: Results were based on fourth
quarter reports as of June 30, 2001. Final data will be available when States
submit the annual report. That data will contain an additional quarter of wage
records so results are expected to vary from this report. The Department will
analyze performance for the first year under the WIA in greater detail when all
data are available. However, the higher rate of success for the 19-21 year old
youth may relate to the similarity of WIA performance objectives for the older
participants to the measures under its predecessor program, the Job Training
Partnership Act. The newer legislation continues the emphasis on employment for
19-21 year old participants, requiring less programmatic redesign than
WIAs focus on education related accomplishments for 14-18 year old
participants.
Strategies: The Workforce Investment Act, fully
effective in Program Year 2000, introduced substantial reforms for youth
programs, placing a stronger emphasis on more comprehensive, long-term
activities for youth coupled with at least twelve months of follow-up after
program completion. During this initial period of program implementation, DOL
mounted efforts to establish Youth Councils as a new local governance body and
advocate for youth in the local communities. DOL also provided technical
assistance and training to help the States and local communities implement the
newly required WIA youth services as well as the performance management and
reporting systems that support the program.
Goal Assessment and Future Plans: The Department
has revised the performance measures for 19-21 year old youth in the FY 2002
Annual Performance Plan, adding an entered employment target of 63 percent and
increasing the target for retention in employment in the third quarter after
program exit to 77 percent.
Program Evaluation: The Office of Inspector
General issued the final audit report on Job Training Partnership
Act, Title II-C Out-of-School Program Performance on March
19, 2001. OIG reported that:
- Positive outcomes for the Title II-C Out-of-School Youth Program
were significantly lower than those reported;
- Documentation supporting youth employability enhancements was
seriously deficient; and
- Participants post-program earnings were affected favorably
by program interventions and the level of their participation.
Recommendations included:
- Conduct data validation effort as a part of program monitoring;
and
- Notify all States and substate grantees of:
-
Audit results with emphasis on the necessity for States
and their grantees to validate outcome data as part of their monitoring program
and training provider eligibility determinations;
- The importance of documenting not only reported outcomes but
also specific services provided, dates services were provided, and actual
program exit date; and
- The importance of not only enrolling youth in occupational
skills training activities, but also encouraging participation in the program
to completion, to maximize their post-program earnings.
In response to OIGs findings and recommendations,
the Department issued comprehensive guidance on youth services and a notice
about this audit to the States and substate grantees. Finally, DOL is
undertaking a data validation initiative to create both more precise
programming specifications and more precise standards for validating data
quality. For further information about this audit, please refer to Appendix 3.
■
(Goal 1.2E FY 2000 Annual Performance Plan)
ENHANCE JOB PLACEMENT AND AVERAGE WAGES FOR JOB CORPS GRADUATES
Increase the percent of Job Corps graduates who get
jobs or pursue education to 85%; those who get jobs will have an average entry
wage increase from the previous year ($7.49) and 70% will still have a job or
will be pursuing education after 90 days.
Results: The goal was substantially met.
Ninety-one percent of Job Corps graduates entered employment at an average
hourly wage of $7.97 or pursued further education upon completion of the
program. The 90-day job retention rate after initial placement was 67 percent.
Program Description: The DOL Job Corps program is
a highly intensive, primarily residential training program for severely
disadvantaged youth ages 16 to 24. The program provides occupational skills and
academic training, social education, and other support to over 70,000
participants at 118 centers. To realize the objectives of the Workforce
Investment Act, the Department has expanded the scope of the Job Corps
program operations to provide support services for up to 12 months after
students graduate from the program.
Text version
Workforce Investment Act Youth Programs,
19-21 Year-Old |
|
Analysis of Results: In Program Year 2000, the
Department achieved significant success in placing Job Corps graduates into
employment or advanced education. In addition, the starting average hourly wage
for graduates rose to $7.97, exceeding the targeted wage of $7.49 by 48 cents.
The 67 percent of Job Corps graduates who remained in jobs or educational
programs after 90 days fell short of the 70 percent target for this new
measure. Several factors contributed to this result: a target that proved
overly ambitious in light of economic conditions that could have influenced
employers retention of newly hired workers; the need to enhance services
to meet the broader career transition needs of Job Corps graduates; and delays
in revising contracts to introduce the new services.
The Office of Job Corps Management Information
System serves as the source for this data. The reliability of the data compiled
through this rigorously designed and comprehensive data collection system is
routinely monitored and reviewed at several levels by management and a
contractor retained by Job Corps to provide data verification services.
Strategies: To maximize the benefits of the Job
Corps program for disadvantaged youth, the Department emphasizes a number of
strategies including improving the quality of the education and training
programs and tailoring services to the individual needs of each student.
Services that address individual needs may include occupational exploration
programs, a comprehensive academic program, competency-based vocation education
programs, work-based learning at employer work sites, social and employability
skills development, counseling and related support services, drivers
education program, health care, child care support at some centers, and
post-program placement and support. Other strategies focus on management and
outreach, for example: integrating performance measurement into the competitive
procurement process; and maintaining partnerships with communities, employers,
and educational institutions to further enhance the career and educational
opportunities for graduates.
In the future, increased emphasis will be placed on
providing career development services that meet the broader career transition
needs of Job Corps graduates, to ensure their success over the longer term.
During enrollment, expanded services will address areas such as career and
personal counseling, increased career exploration options, and integrated
academic and vocational training. After students leave Job Corps, career
development services may include placement assistance, transitional support
services (housing, transportation, and child care), and linkages with
communities, employers, and other partners to assist in graduates
successful transition to the work force.
|
Edgar, a computer repair student shows his
skills with the installation of a circuit card |
Goal Assessment and Future Plans: In the FY 2002 Annual
Performance Plan, DOL has increased the target rates for Job Corp graduates who
enter employment or education and the average hourly wages, and has added an
indicator for attainment of high school diplomas to measure the expected
outcomes of an inter agency agreement with the Department of Education.
Audits and Evaluations: Mathematica Policy Research, Inc.
completed a comprehensive, four year evaluation of the Job Corps program,
entitled Nation Job Corps Study: The Impacts of Job Corps on
Participants Employment and Related Outcomes. The national
longitudinal study concluded that the Job Corps program offers a favorable
return on the taxpayers investment; for example, for every dollar spent
for Job Corps, the benefit to society is $2.02. The study also reported that,
by comparison to a sample of disadvantaged youth who did not enroll in the Job
Corps program, participants realized significant increases in education and
training, including much greater attainment of General Educational Development
(GED) and vocational certificates; positive employment and earnings gains;
higher paying jobs with more benefits; significant reductions in arrests,
convictions and incarcerations; and reduction in the receipt of public
assistance.
|
Photo by: DOL/Job Corps |
John is one of more than 700 Job
Corps students who participated in one of the more unusual vocational training
experiences offered by the Job Corps fighting fires in Americas
National forests. In August, John and his fellow students gathered from 11 Job
Corps Centers to assist professional firefighters in fighting the numerous
forest fires that threatened our National Forests in the western United States
where summer daytime temperatures of 90-plus degrees were further heated
to 110 degrees on the fire lines. During this month of intense training, John
learned the meaning of teamwork, response to supervision, and how to use
fire-fighting equipment. With completion of the program, he is qualified for
fire fighting and camp support assignments with the National Forest service.
|
|
In Program Year 2000, Job Corps, along with over 100 other Federal
Government entities, was selected to participate in the American Customer
Satisfaction Index (ACSI), a national measure of citizen satisfaction with
A Job Corps electrical systems technical instructor
trains students on proper methods and tools for preparing coaxel cable
for installation. Photo by: Michael Carpenter |
Federal services. The survey questioned a national sample of parents
and guardians of Job Corps graduates about their level of satisfaction with the
services their children received while enrolled in Job Corps. Job Corps
received a customer satisfaction rating of 80 on the ACSI index, higher than
both the Federal Government-wide score (68.6 on the index) and the private
sector comparable score (71.2 on the index). Additionally, parents and
guardians demonstrated confidence that Job Corps will continue to be effective
in the future with a rating of 86 on the index, and that they would be likely
to recommend Job Corps to other parents and guardians.
For more information about this program evaluation, please refer to
Appendix 3. ■
(Goal 1.2B FY 2000 Annual Performance Plan)
HELP YOUTH TRANSITION FROM SCHOOL TO WORK
Engage two million youth in School-to-Work activities.
Results: This goal was achieved, as 2.9 million secondary
students participated in School-to-Work activities.
Program Description: The School-to-Work (STW) Opportunities Act
of 1994 established a national framework within which States and local grantees
could build on education and workforce development reforms to facilitate the
education and career preparation of young people. The Acts goals are to
increase academic achievement, improve technical skills, broaden career
opportunities, and prepare all students for high-skill, high-wage occupations.
Students participating in STW classes receive career-related instruction as a
complement to their traditional academic classes. The initiative provides
venture capital to support grantees in building their STW systems.
Analysis of Results: Student participation in STW experiences
has grown considerably. During Program Year 2000, the number of students
engaged in these activities increased from 1.6 million to 2.9 million. This
increase is most likely due to the establishment of the STW infrastructure.
With program components in place schools, teachers, counselors, and
employers are able to promote the availability of services and activities,
thereby increasing student demand.
During the lifetime of the School-to-Work Opportunities, other results
reveal that:
- Between 1995 and 2000, the number of sub-State funded local
partnerships grew from 294 to 1,931 or 560 percent.
- Between 1995 and 2000, the number of secondary schools within the
geographic areas of local partnerships rose from 5,409 to 10,268 nearly
40 percent of the nations public high schools.
- Between 1995 and 2000, the number of employers participating in
any aspect of School-to-Work rose from about 178,000 to nearly 319,000
or 80 percent.
- Between 1995 and 2000, the number of postsecondary institutions
participating in local partnerships grew from 2,600 to 3,450 33 percent.
Goal Assessment: Due to the sunset of the School-to-Work
legislation on October 1, 2001, the Department has discontinued this goal.
■
(Goal 1.2C FY 2000 Annual Performance Plan)
|