Tobacco Ingredient and Nicotine1 Reporting
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising
Act (FCLAA)?
- What is the Comprehensive Smokeless Tobacco Health Education
Act (CSTHEA)?
- What products are covered by FCLAA and CSTHEA?
- What tobacco products are not covered by FCLAA or CSTHEA?
- To whom does FCLAA and CSTHEA apply?
- Who receives the Ingredient Report and the Nicotine
Report?
- Are the submission requirements the same for cigarettes
and smokeless tobacco products?
- What does a Nicotine Report consist of?
- When are submissions due?
- Can I submit my Ingredient Report and Nicotine
Report
electronically?
- What are Chemical Abstract Service (CAS) numbers?
- Why must CAS numbers be included with the Ingredient
Report?
- Do I have to report information that is trade secret
or confidential?
- What steps does CDC take to secure confidential information?
- How does a manufacturer, packager, or importer submit
an Ingredient Report or Nicotine Report?
- Must the designated individual disclose the identity
of its clients when submitting an Ingredient Report and/or Nicotine
Report?
- Must an Ingredient Report be submitted if there have been no changes
in the list of ingredients added to the tobacco products?
- Must an Ingredient Report be submitted if no ingredients
have been added?
- What if I am an importer and the manufacturer will
not provide me with the list of ingredients?
- What happens after I submit the Ingredient Report?
- Are there other federal agencies responsible for
collecting information under FCLAA?
- Are there any other federal agencies with whom I may
need to interact?
- Are there penalties for failing to comply with FCLAA or CSTHEA?
- Does FCLAA or CSTHEA preempt state and local initiatives?
1. What is the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act
(FCLAA)?
The FCLAA, Public Law 89–92,
is a statute that was designed to “establish a comprehensive federal program
to deal with cigarette labeling and advertising with respect to any relationship
between smoking and health.” In 1984, this Act was amended by PL 98–474,
the Comprehensive Smoking Education Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1335a(a) to in part
provide the Department of Health and Human Services with a list of the ingredients
added to tobacco in the manufacture of cigarettes.
2. What is the Comprehensive Smokeless Tobacco Health Education
Act (CSTHEA)?
The CSTHEA, Public
Law 98–252, was passed in 1986 to inform the public of any dangers
to human health resulting from the use of smokeless tobacco products. CSTHEA
requires, in part, that each person who manufactures, packages, or imports
smokeless tobacco products to annually submit to the Department of Health
and Human Services the list of ingredients added to tobacco in the manufacture
of smokeless tobacco products as well as a specification of the quantity
of nicotine contained in each smokeless tobacco product.
3. What products are covered by FCLAA and CSTHEA?
FCLAA defines a cigarette as "any roll of tobacco wrapped in paper
or in any substance not containing tobacco, and any roll of tobacco wrapped
in any substance containing tobacco which, because of its appearance, the
type of tobacco used in the filler, or its packaging and labeling, is likely
to be offered to, or purchased by, consumers as a cigarette. . ."
CSTHEA defines smokeless tobacco as “any finely cut, ground, powdered,
or leaf tobacco that is intended to be placed in the oral cavity.”
4. What tobacco products are not covered by FCLAA or CSTHEA?
FCLAA and CSTHEA do not apply to cigars or cut rag tobacco unless
the cut rag tobacco is packaged as a final product for consumption (i.e.,
no further manipulation is required in order to be consumed). Other items
not covered by FCLAA
or CSTHEA
include little cigars; or roll-your-own,
hookah, or pipe tobacco.
5. To whom does FCLAA and CSTHEA apply?
Manufacturers, packagers, and importers of cigarettes and smokeless
tobacco products.
6. Who receives the Ingredient Report and the Nicotine
Report?
Both FCLAA and CSTHEA require manufacturers, packagers, and importers
to annually report ingredients added to tobacco in the manufacture of cigarettes
and smokeless tobacco to the Secretary of Health and Human Services. In
turn, the Secretary has delegated this responsibility to the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention, Office on Smoking and Health (OSH), as stated
in 50 FR 49617, December 3, 1985
(PDF–51.4 KB);
59 FR 4717, February 1, 1994
(PDF–59.7 KB), respectively.
7. Are the submission requirements the same for cigarettes
and smokeless tobacco products?
Both FCLAA and CSTHEA require manufacturers, packagers, and importers
to annually report ingredients added to tobacco in the manufacture of cigarettes
and smokeless tobacco.
However, CSTHEA additionally requires manufacturers, packagers, and importers
of smokeless tobacco products to annually report on the specific quantity
of nicotine in these products by submitting data on total nicotine, unionized nicotine,
total moisture, and pH.
8. What does a Nicotine Report consist of?
The Nicotine Report is a specification of the quantity of nicotine
(total nicotine, un–ionized nicotine, total moisture, and pH) contained
in smokeless tobacco products from the previous calendar year. A uniform
analytical protocol was developed that consists of standard laboratory methods
to measure nicotine, moisture, and pH in smokeless tobacco products, and
an equation to calculate un–ionized nicotine. It includes standardized parameters
for pH, moisture, and nicotine determination (sample size, sample preparation,
quantity and purity of standards and reagents, instrumentation, measurement
time and conditions, etc.). It is the responsibility of the manufacturer,
packager, or importer to submit the Nicotine Report according to the specifications
set forth in the protocol.
For detailed information on the protocol for testing smokeless tobacco
products and the recommended format for reporting total nicotine, amount
of unionized nicotine, and percentage of unionized nicotine, total moisture,
and pH for each smokeless product, please review the following:
9. When are submissions due?
All submissions are due annually by March 31 and upon initial import.
These submissions reflect ingredients added to cigarettes and smokeless
tobacco products which are manufactured, packaged, or imported in the previous
calendar year; as well as a specification of the quantity of nicotine contained
in smokeless tobacco products manufactured or imported during the previous
calendar year.
10. Can I submit my Ingredient Report and Nicotine Report
electronically?
Because CDC cannot ensure the confidentiality of information submitted
via E-mail, this is not an acceptable format. However, submission of data
by way of mailing a CD, 3-inch floppy disk, or thumb drive is acceptable. Reports may
also be submitted via facsimile, but all faxed lists should be followed-up with
a mailed original.
11. What are Chemical Abstract Service (CAS) numbers?
Each chemical compound has a unique CAS number for purposes of identification,
assigned by the American Chemical Society. A CAS registry is available from
the National Institutes of Health National Library of Medicine at
http://chem.sis.nlm.nih.gov/chemidplus/chemidheavy.jsp or from the
Food
and Drug Administration at
http://www.fda.gov/cder/iig/iigfaqWEB.htm.
Initially natural additives and flavors were not given CAS registry numbers;
however, because these ingredients are now regularly used in manufacturing,
many have been assigned CAS registry numbers.
Flavors made of multiple chemicals will have a separate CAS registry
number for each chemical in that compound.
12. Why must CAS numbers be included with the Ingredient
Report?
CAS numbers are
required to properly identify and reduce ambiguity
among ingredients used in tobacco products. This is particularly important,
as an ingredient with a common name may have different chemical names and
thus, different CAS assignments.
An example of this is sugar, whose chemical
names can be fructose, glucose, or sucrose.
13. Do I have to report information that is trade secret
or confidential?
Yes, the U.S. Congress gave full weight and consideration to the sensitive
nature of tobacco ingredients in drafting
FCLAA
and CSTHEA. The list of
ingredients added to tobacco in the manufacture of cigarettes and smokeless
tobacco products and the specification of the quantity of nicotine contained
in each smokeless tobacco product received by CDC, OSH under 15 U.S.C. Section
1335a(a) of FCLAA and 15 U.S.C. Section 4403(a)(1)(A) and (B) of CSTHEA
are generally trade secret or confidential information subject to section 552(b)(4) of Title 5. However, 15 U.S.C. Section 1335a(2)(B)
of FCLAA and 15 U.S.C. Section 4403(b)(2)(B) of CSTHEA do not authorize
the withholding of the list of ingredients from any duly authorized subcommittee
or committee of the Congress. If a subcommittee or committee of the Congress
requests the Secretary of HHS to provide it such a list, the Secretary
of HHS or a representative of CDC will make the list available to the subcommittee
or committee and shall, at the same time, notify in writing the person who
provided the list of such request.
14. What steps does CDC take to secure confidential information?
A limited number of staff has access to
confidential information. Each of these persons has signed a pledge
of confidentiality and these statements along with a list of their names
are located in a locked safe. Additionally, the list of ingredients and
the specification of the quantity of nicotine are secured in a locked safe
located in a locked office. Electronic information is stored on a removable
hard drive also kept in the safe. Further, OSH redacts privileged, proprietary,
and confidential information from public files.
15. How does a manufacturer, packager, or importer submit
an Ingredient Report or Nicotine Report?
CDC requests all submissions be provided on letterhead of the manufacturer,
packager, importer, or designated individual or entity. They may be mailed
or faxed; however, a faxed copy should be accompanied by a mailed original.
Because CDC cannot ensure the confidentiality of information submitted via
E-mail, this is not an acceptable format. However, submission of data by
way of mailing a CD, 3-inch floppy disk, or thumb drive is acceptable.
16. Must the designated individual disclose the identity
of its clients when submitting an Ingredient Report and/or Nicotine Report?
Yes. Under 15 U.S.C. Section 1335a(a) of FCLAA and 15 U.S.C.
Section 4403(a)(2) of CSTHEA a person or group of persons required to provide a
list of ingredients and a specification of the quantity of nicotine may
designate an individual or entity to provide the above-referenced lists
required by these federal laws. In the event that another individual or
entity is designated to submit the required information, such as an attorney
acting on behalf of a manufacturer or importer; or a manufacturer acting
on behalf of an importer, that individual or entity should clearly state
the name of the company for whom the information is being submitted.
17. Must an Ingredient Report be submitted if there have been no changes
in the list of ingredients added to the tobacco products?
If there have been no changes to the ingredient list in the previous
calendar year, the manufacturer, packager, importer, or designated individual
or entity as addressed above may submit a letter stating that there have
been no changes in the list of ingredients added to the tobacco products
along with a copy of the original submission.
18. Must an Ingredient Report be submitted if no ingredients
have been added?
In order to confirm whether or not a manufacturer, packager, or
importer is compliant with FCLAA or CSTHEA, a statement should be submitted in writing
if no ingredients are added to tobacco in the manufacture of cigarettes
or smokeless tobacco.
19. What if I am an importer and the manufacturer will not
provide me with the list of ingredients?
The manufacturer of the tobacco product or of the flavoring added
to the tobacco products may submit a list of ingredients and/or a specification
of the quantity of nicotine contained in the smokeless tobacco product directly
to CDC on behalf of the importer. As with any submission, the list of ingredients
and the specification of the quantity of nicotine shall be treated as
trade secret or confidential information subject to section 552(b)(4)
of Title 5, United States Code and “shall not
be revealed . . . to any person other than those authorized by the Secretary
in carrying out their official duties under this section.”
20. What happens after I submit the Ingredient Report?
Once the accuracy of the submitted information is verified, CDC
will issue a certificate of compliance for that calendar year. If
missing data or errors are noted (e.g., an invalid or missing CAS registry number),
a letter will be sent requesting clarification of the submission within
60 days.
The process of verifying an Ingredient Report and providing a response
may take several weeks. Frequently, however, this process only takes a few
days, although this can vary depending on the complexity and completeness
of submissions. If the Ingredient Report contains many errors, the process may become
more lengthy.
21. Are there other federal agencies responsible for
collecting information under FCLAA?
Yes. While this is not an exhaustive list of federal agencies that
are responsible for tobacco-related matters, the Federal Trade Commission’s
(FTC) Division
of Advertising Practices is responsible for reviewing and approving
health warning label plans for all cigarette and smokeless tobacco products,
whether manufactured domestically or abroad, that enter the U.S. stream
of commerce.
22. Are there any other federal agencies with whom I may
need to interact?
Yes. While this is not an exhaustive list, other agencies with whom
you may need to interact include the
Federal Trade Commission (FTC);
the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco,
Firearms and Explosives (ATF);
Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and
Trade Bureau (TTB); and
U.S. Customs.
23. Are there penalties for failing to comply with FCLAA or CSTHEA?
Yes. According to
15 U.S.C. §1338 “Any person who violates the provisions of this chapter
shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and shall on conviction thereof be subject
to a fine of not more than $10,000.” 15 U.S.C. Section 4404 has a similar
penalty provision.
24. Does FCLAA or CSTHEA preempt state and local initiatives?
Yes, both laws contain some preemptive provisions, however they do
not preempt stricter state-level requirements regarding the submission of
ingredient information. 15 U.S.C. 1334(a)-(b), of FCLAA reads:
"(a) Additional statements
No statement relating to smoking and health, other than the statement
required by section 1333 of this title, shall be required on any cigarette
package.
(b) State regulations
No requirement or prohibition based on smoking and health shall be
imposed under State law with respect to the advertising or promotion
of any cigarettes the packages of which are labeled in conformity with
the provisions of this chapter.”
And the CSTHEA,
15 U.S.C. §4406(a)-(c), states:
“(a) Federal action
No statement relating to the use of smokeless tobacco products and
health, other than the statements required by section 4402 of this title,
shall be required by any Federal agency to appear on any package or
in any advertisement (unless the advertisement is an outdoor billboard
advertisement) of a smokeless tobacco product.
(b) State and local action
No statement relating to the use of smokeless tobacco products and
health, other than the statements required by section 4402 of this title,
shall be required by any State or local statute or regulation to be
included on any package or in any advertisement (unless the advertisement
is an outdoor billboard advertisement) of a smokeless tobacco product.
(c) Effect on liability law
Nothing in this chapter shall relieve any person from liability at
common law or under State statutory law to any other.”
Page last reviewed 02/28/2007
Page last modified 02/28/2007