|
Tools for Grantees: |
A
Guide To Primary Care For
People With HIV/AIDS, 2004 edition |
<
Previous
| Home | Next >
Chapter
18
Keeping Up To Date: Sources Of Information For The Provider
Bruce D. Agins MD, MPH
Renslow Sherer, MD
Caroline J. Teter, PA-C, MPH
Overview
TOP
Doesn't
the Guide itself provide sufficient information about HIV care?
At a pace unlike
that in any other field, rapid change characterizes the field of
clinical HIV medicine. Fortunately, opportunities to stay current
with the fast-paced changes in science and practice are available
through a variety of sources.
What kinds
of resources are available for keeping up-to-date?
One approach
to identifying educational resources for providers is to consider
them an expanding circle of information sources, starting at the
local level, and finally reaching the globally available web of
information on the Internet. Resources can also be grouped by type
of information delivery:
Human
Resources Conferences, training workshops, case-based presentations,
educational consultations (in-person, telephone, distance-learning),
preceptorships, audio tapes, video tapes.
Written
Materials Books, journals, newsletters, self-assessment, slides,
handouts
Web-Based
Information Downloadable articles, webcasts, resource directories,
search engines, listserves, e-newsletters.
What kind
of standards are available to assure that HIV providers are keeping
up-to-date?
Professional
associations and State governments have developed policies defining
HIV specialists that specify the number of patients that providers
should directly manage in order to qualify for this experience-driven
classification, reinforcing through regulations and requirements
the simple notion that providers need to keep current in order to
provide good care. See last section, Integrating HIV Specialty into
Practice, for details.
Human
Resources
TOP
How do you
identify what's available in your own community?
The single
most important step in obtaining current information is to identify
local resources. The first step is to determine whether any HIV
experts are practicing nearby who provide care to with HIV in the
community. HIV specialists are an important source of information
not only about clinical practice, but also about educational
opportunities in the area. Local hospitals or clinics may offer
grand rounds on topics in HIV clinical care or continuing education
programs. Local infectious disease societies or HIV medical associations
may sponsor meetings at which new information is disseminated. Every
region in the United States is targeted by a regional AIDS Education
and Training Center (AETC), funded by the HIV/AIDS Bureau (HAB)
of the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), that
offers a menu of educational programs designed to fit the specific
needs of practicing providers, including physicians, mid-level practitioners,
nurses, and dentists (see Figure 18-1).
AETC educational sessions also present excellent opportunities to
make personal contact with clinical experts. Establishing relationships
with local experts can lead to ongoing communication about advances
in care, telephone consultations when needed, and the potential
for referrals when patient management becomes especially complicated,
such as when drug resistance occurs or salvage therapy is required,
prompting changes in antiretroviral therapy (ART).
Figure
18-1. AIDS Education and Training Centers
Contact information
for regional as well as national and international centers is
available online
(accessed 3/04).
Are AIDS
conferences useful for providers who are not HIV experts?
A number of
national conferences provide opportunities to obtain cutting-edge
information (see Table 18-1). The range of offerings usually meets
the needs of providers just learning about HIV as well as providers
who are already HIV experts.
* Websites accessed 1/04.
What if
you practice in a remote area?
In remote geographic
areas, the nearest HIV expert may actually be far away and attendance
at conferences and meetings may not be feasible. In this situation,
the regional AETC can be contacted to determine how to obtain direct
educational programming. When distance prevents on-site attendance
at educational programs, newer technologies may enable long distance
participation. Satellite broadcasting and down-linking to local
facilities may be available and has been a useful approach in various
parts of the United States. Distance learning and web-based information
also provide important sources of education when other programming
is unavailable. Many sessions are videotaped or audiotaped. Videocassettes
and audiocassettes may be distributed or purchased for a modest
price.
Is clinical
consultation possible even if you are not affiliated with an HIV
specialty practice?
In areas of
the country with no HIV clinical experts, a number of consultative
and co-management options are available through the AETCs or statewide
education initiatives to assure that patient care is of the highest
quality. Informal discussions with experienced providers in the
region are probably the easiest way to access expertise, especially
since these providers may be available for formal clinical consultation
when decisions are made about ART, such as when to initiate, modify,
or discontinue therapy.
Clinical consultations
are available not only through the regional AETCs, but also from
the National HIV Clinical Consultation Center, based at the University
of California San Francisco (UCSF). This service provides a "warmline"
a toll-free phone number staffed from 6:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
PST by physicians, nurse practitioners, and pharmacists who are
available to answer providers' questions. During other times, or
when the phone line is busy, voicemail messages can be left and
calls returned. The HIV experts discuss options with callers, presenting
pros and cons of various approaches with the goal of improving the
capability of the provider to manage the current situation and others
like it. The Center also refers callers to their local resources
for expertise, consultation and training.
National
HIV/AIDS Clinical Consultation
Center Warmline: 1-800-933-3413
Written
Resources
TOP
What books
and journals are most useful for primary care providers?
Although a
basic textbook of HIV/AIDS medicine provides a basic reference of
core knowledge, it becomes outdated nearly as quickly as it is published,
particularly in relation to ART. Small books such as the Pocket
Guide included in this guide contain quick reference materials,
are more frequently updated, and provide summaries that can be useful
at the point of care. Other books provide specialized information
related to the care of specific groups of persons with HIV. For
example, A Guide to the Clinical Care of Women with HIV offers an
excellent comprehensive overview of issues pertaining to the care
of women, with useful tables, photographs, and practical information
for the provider.
Most major
journals include articles about HIV. Clinical trials and review
articles periodically appear in the major internal medicine journals.
Two important peer-reviewed HIV-specific journals, AIDS and JAIDS
(Journal of the Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes and Human Retrovirology),
include studies and review articles in the domains of basic science,
epidemiology, clinical care, and HIV prevention. Other regularly
published bulletins and journals offer review articles on basic
aspects of clinical management that are useful summaries for the
primary HIV care provider. The Johns Hopkins HIV Report provides
summaries of current issues and controversies in HIV care authored
by experts from the Hopkins HIV Service. Question and answer sessions
with experts are often included as part of these publications. See
Table 18-2 for a list of recommended publications. Also, a comprehensive
list of HIV professional journals can be found online
(accessed 3/04).
Can journal
articles be accessed on the internet?
To keep up
with all of the HIV journals is impossible, especially when a practice
is not exclusively devoted to HIV care. Several websites post information
about newly published articles and can easily be scanned to seek
relevant or noteworthy information (see Table 18-3). Medscape, which
has a specific section dedicated to HIV, and HIVInSite are two good
sources of news. An abstract of almost any article can be retrieved
through the National Library of Medicine's website at PubMed. A
useful list of websites, references and news may also be found at
Medline Plus. The Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report offers a daily news
summary that includes both newspaper articles and major clinical
or scientific releases that anyone can subscribe to by registering
at the website. The Aegis website links to news summaries that can
be quickly accessed to obtain the desired summary.
Table
18-3. Selected Sources for Information on the Web
(Websites accessed 01/04)
Search
Engines
General
Searches
Resource
Listings
General
HIV Resources
- HIV
InSite
- AIDS
Education Global Information Services
- AETC
National Resource Centers
- AIDS
Info (formerly AIDS Treatment Information Service)
- Kaiser
Daily HIV/AIDS Report
- U.S.
Food and Drug Administration (therapies, clinical
trials, Fraud Task Forces)
- CDC
Div HIV/AIDS Prevention (news, guidelines, fact sheets,
FAQ, slide sets, surveillance reports, policy documents)
- Johns
Hopkins AIDS Service
(news, medical education, interactive forums)
- New
York State AIDS Institute
(guidelines, quality of care information, best practices,
slide sets)
- National
AIDS Treatment Advocacy Project (NATAP)
- Canadian
AIDS Treatment Information Exchange (CATIE)
- World
Health Organization (WHO)
HIV
CME Websites
Resources
on Specific HIV Topics
Drug
Dependency
|
Are there
guidelines for HIV care?
The Department
of Health and Human Services has sponsored several guidelines panels
composed of HIV clinical experts to develop evidence-based and consensus-driven
practice recommendations for the provision of HIV care. These guidelines
are updated regularly, and are posted on the official
website of AIDSInfo, a service of the U.S. Department of Health
and Human Services. Currently available Federal guidelines address
the following topics:
- ART for
adults and adolescents
- ART for
pediatric HIV
- Perinatal
screening, prevention, and care
- Healthcare
worker exposure
- Nonoccupational
exposure
- Prevention
of opportunistic infections
- Management
of tuberculosis
- Incorporation
of HIV prevention into care
- Nutrition
New York State
has sponsored an HIV Guidelines Program since 1985 through which
independent guidelines are developed that specifically target frontline
providers and contain concise recommendations for primary care physicians,
nurse practitioners, and physician assistants. In addition to guidelines
for adults and children, other guidelines specifically address mental
health and oral health for persons with HIV. These guidelines, along
with information about implementation strategies, including best
practices, quality improvement methods, and success stories, can
be found online.
Electronic
and Web-Based Resources
TOP
Which web-based
resources are most useful?
Numerous websites
provide useful information about HIV. While it is beyond the scope
of this chapter to provide a comprehensive listing of all HIV-related
websites, Table 18-3 is a partial listing of some particularly useful
ones. Websites in the Search Engines category allow the user to
enter a topic of interest and obtain a list of other websites or
resources from which to choose. There are search engines that are
general as well as medical. Websites in the Resource Listings category
provide lists of HIV resources, including agencies, other websites,
and informational materials. The General HIV Resources category
contains some of the websites that are most useful when specific
HIV information is being sought. One important example is the database
of antiretroviral drug interactions that is part of the HIV InSite
website. The HIV CME websites provide continuing medical education
and award CME credits, usually at no cost. The Specific HIV Topics
category lists some of the websites addressing focused issues related
to HIV care, such as drug dependency and treatment adherence.
Websites targeting
consumers enable them to directly access scientific and clinical
information and to pose questions to experts. These websites empower
patients by helping them to better understand their disease and
its manifestations and by enabling them to advocate for their own
health and to more fully participate in decisionmaking about their
care. See Table 2-1, Information Resources for Patients, in Chapter
2.
Thinking
ahead: can personal digital assistants (PDAs) help you keep up?
A revolution
in healthcare information technology has begun that brings information
resources directly to the provider at the point of care, whether
at the bedside or during the clinic visit. Mobile computing through
handheld devices, such as personal digital assistants (PDAs), are
now available and have begun to change the practice of medicine
by facilitating capture of data and retrieval of information. PDAs
(eg, Palm, Pocket PC, Visor) are now used as clinical tools for
reference, prescribing, coding and patient education (see Table
18-4).
Table
18-4. Useful PDA References
(Websites accessed 01/04)
Drug
prescribing databases, including drug interaction data (available
at no cost) |
|
Antibiotic
prescribing guides (available at no cost) |
|
Prescriptions |
|
Compiled
abstracts and CMEs |
|
Currently,
the greatest advantage of carrying a PDA is having medical resources
at your fingertips. Through a function that uses a cradle to connect
with a website via a personal computer, the provider's PDA can "synch"
with a master database that is maintained and updated regularly.
Transfer of
information is easily accomplished with PDAs through "beaming."
By pointing the PDA at another PDA and tapping on the appropriate
prompts, data are quickly transported into the other PDA database.
Similarly, information can be beamed to a printer, which is a particularly
useful feature for quickly printing patient information or prescriptions.
As PDA technology
rapidly evolves, the utility and efficacy of handheld computing
will similarly expand. Potential new uses of PDA technology include
portable access to MEDLINE, full text journal articles, information
searches, comprehensive information storage, and point-of-care access
to guidelines, algorithms, and other decisionmaking tools to enhance
the quality of care.
PDA versions
of patient
tracking systems and coding references have also been developed.
Ultimately, PDAs will be used in conjunction with electronic medical
record systems, with information being "beamed" between
the two systems. This powerful application of PDA technology will
permit comprehensive individualized patient data files that can
include current and past medical information, laboratory data, and
even reminders for providers to perform periodic preventive health
or monitoring tests. Providers who have not already taken the first
step, purchasing and using a PDA, should become acquainted with
this important new technology as an important source of clinical
information and aid to patient management (see Table 18-5).
Table
18-5. Websites for Learning More about PDAs
or Obtaining Software
(Websites accessed 01/04)
Websites
that categorize resources/libraries
Websites
for downloading of software (often at no cost)
|
Integrating
HIV Specialty into Practice
TOP
Making it
stick: how can you integrate new information into clinical practice?
Numerous resources
at the fingertips of providers enable them to obtain up-to-the-minute
information about new developments or management strategies for
HIV care. However, even the best-educated provider cannot assure
that quality of care will be achieved through access to the most
recent standards and current information unless the system in which
care is provided has been adapted to integrate that information.
Strategies for developing and sustaining systems to support information
can be implemented at the local level through individual actions
and through quality improvement programs.
A variety of
resources provide assistance in successfully integrating current
information into HIV care. Most notably, the decision support framework
of the chronic care model developed by the University of Washington
has been used to improve care delivered by Ryan White CARE Act-funded
clinics (see Figure 1-1 in Chapter 1). Quality improvement strategies
based on this model include the following principles:
- Embed current
guidelines in the care delivery system.
- Establish
linkages with key specialists to ensure that primary care providers
have access to expert support.
- Provide
continuous skill-oriented interactive training programs for all
staff to update knowledge of current guidelines.
- Provide
feedback to providers on their use of guidelines.
- Incorporate
community-based staff (social workers and case managers) into
decision support.
- Educate
patients about guidelines.
One example
of the application of these strategies is conducting chart audits
in order to benchmark practices and feed the information back to
providers. Other examples are using flow sheets or checklists to
embed guidelines into practice and developing simplified versions
of guidelines for providers and patients. The most successful strategies
to incorporate guidelines into systems of care are those that include
reminders at the point of care or decisionmaking. An important rule
of thumb is that multiple interventions work better than just one.
For more information on quality improvement, see Chapter 17.
How do you
develop the experience needed to qualify as an HIV specialist?
Multiple studies
show better outcomes when providers managing patients have expertise
in HIV (see Table 18-6). In the absence of a formally recognized
subspecialty society devoted to HIV medicine, government agencies,
professional societies, and academic institutions have developed
definitions of HIV specialization in order to develop policies,
standards, and regulations, and to monitor the quality of care provided
to persons with HIV (see Table 18-7). Definitions of HIV specialists
generally focus on two major areas, experience and HIV CME credits,
and also require that experience be current and that knowledge be
updated annually. Generally, requirements for experience in the
care of patients with HIV range from 10 to 20 patient-years of experience.
All definitions emphasize currency of experience and education,
given the rapid pace at which HIV clinical management standards
change.
Table
18-6. Resources on HIV Expertise
and Patient Outcomes
Gerbert
B, Moe JC, Saag MS, et al. "Toward a definition of
HIV expertise: a survey of experienced HIV physicians."
AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2001;15:321-330.
Keitz
SA, Box TL, Homan RK, Bartlett JA, Oddone EZ. "Primary
care for patients infected with human immunodeficiency virus:
a randomized controlled trial." J Gen Intern Med.
2001;16:573-582.
Kitahata
MM, Koepsell TD, Deyo RA, Maxwell CL, Dodge WT, Wagner EH.
"Physicians' experience with the acquired immunodeficiency
syndrome as a factor in patients' survival." N Engl
J Med. 1996;334:701-706.
Kitahata
MM, Van Rompaey SE, Shields A. "Physician experience
in the care of persons with HIV infection is associated
with earlier adoption of new antiretroviral therapy."
J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2000;24:106-114.
Stone
VE, Mansourati FF, Poses RM,
Mayer KH. "Relation of physician specialty and HIV/AIDS
experience to choice of guideline-recommended antiretroviral
therapy." J Gen Intern Med. 2001;16:360-368.
Willard
CL, Liljestrand P, Goldschmidt RH, Grumbach K. "Is
experience with human immunodeficiency virus disease related
to clinical practice? A survey of rural primary care physicians."
Arch Fam Med. 1999;8:502-508.
|
Table
18-7. HIV Specialist Definitions
(Websites
accessed 02/04)
American
Academy of HIV Medicine (AAHIVM) |
Current
and valid state licensure (MD, DO, PA, NP).
Experience:
Direct, continuous, ongoing care to at least 20 patients within
the past 2 years.
CME:
30 hours within the past 2 years.
Exam:
AAHIVM exam at application.
|
Association
of Nurses in AIDS Care (ANAC) and HIV/AIDS Nursing
Certification Board (HANCB)
Certification
as an Advanced HIV/AIDS Certified Registered Nurse (AACRN);
there is also the HIV/AIDS Certified Registered Nurse (ACRN)
for nurses not functioning in advanced practice roles. |
Current
Registered Nurse licensure with master's degree or higher
in nursing.
Experience:
At least 2,000 hours of HIV/AIDS nursing experience and 3
years experience as an RN within 5 years prior to application.
CME:
70 hours every 4 years.
Exam:
HANCB exam at application.
|
California
(State law, effective January, 2004) |
Demonstrated
expertise in treating a condition or disease involving a complicated
treatment regimen that requires ongoing monitoring of the patient's
adherence to the regimen. |
Department
of Health and Human Services Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services (CMS)
Factsheet
on Experienced HIV/AIDS Providers |
Experience:
active caseload of 25 patients (rural) or 50 patients (urban)
within the past 24 months, with a minimum of 12 patients within
the past year. |
HIV
Medicine Association (HIVMA)
[HIVMA is part of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.
Click on HIVMA at IDSA's
Website; Accessed 3/04.] |
Experience:
Direct, continuous medical care to at least 20 patients within
the past 2 years.
CME:
30 hours within the past 2 years; Category I in the areas of
diagnosis and treatment of HIV OR Board certification
or recertification in infectious diseases within the past 36
months. |
Johns
Hopkins University Moore Clinic |
Experience:
50 patients a year.
CME:
50 HIV-related credits a yearChart Audits.
Examination
(not required). |
New
York State Department of Health AIDS Institute
(Click on Policy at the Institute's
Website for HIV Specialist Policy) |
New York
State licensure.
Experience:
Ambulatory care management of at least 20 patients a year
who are receiving ART.
CME: 10 hours per year; AAHIVM or HIVMA qualification
plus ambulatory care requirements.
|
TennCare
Tennesse |
Experience:
active caseload of 50 patients each seen at least twice
a year.
CME:
20 AIDS-related category I credits annually. |
- While rapid
change characterizes the field of clinical HIV medicine, opportunities
to stay current are available through a variety of human, written,
and electronic resources.
- The most
important step in obtaining current information is to identify
local resources, including local HIV specialists and regional
AIDS Education and Training Centers (AETCs). The regional AETCs
offer continuing education programs, distance learning for remote
geographic areas, and clinical consultation for providers in the
area. The National HIV Clinical Consultation Center also provides
telephone consultation to providers.
- A basic
textbook of HIV/AIDS medicine can provide core knowledge, but
it quickly becomes outdated. Books can be supplemented with newsletters,
journals, and frequently updated pocket guides. Websites post
summaries of newly published journal articles as well as noteworthy
information. Clinical guidelines for various aspects of care and
prevention are updated regularly and are available on internet
websites.
- The personal
digital assistant (PDA) is a new healthcare information technology
that enables providers to have a wealth of clinical information
at the point of care. PDAs can be used in conjunction with electronic
medical records for patient management.
- Numerous
websites provide access to information about HIV through search
engines, sites that provide listings of resources including other
websites, sites that provide HIV-specific information for providers
and consumers, and sites that offer CME credits for providers.
- Several
government agencies and professional societies have developed
definitions for the HIV specialist. Two major areas of qualification
are experience in clinical management of patients with HIV and
completion of HIV CME credits.
- New clinical
information must be continuously integrated into the system in
which care is provided. Strategies for developing and sustaining
systems to support information can be implemented through individual
actions and through quality improvement programs.
|