The summer flounder or fluke, Paralichthys
dentatus, is a demersal flatfish distributed from the southern
Gulf of Maine to South Carolina. Important commercial and recreational
fisheries exist from Cape Cod to Cape Hatteras. The resource is
managed as a unit stock from North Carolina to Maine (Figure
8.1). Summer flounder are concentrated in bays and estuaries
from late spring through early autumn, when an offshore migration
to the outer continental shelf is undertaken. Spawning occurs
during autumn and early winter, and the larvae are transported
toward coastal areas by prevailing water currents. Development
of post larvae and juveniles occurs primarily within bays and
estuarine areas, notably Pamlico Sound and Chesapeake Bay (Packer
et al. 1999). Most fish are sexually mature by age 2
(O’Brien et al. 1993). Female summer flounder may
live up to 20 years, but males rarely live for more than 10 years
(Bolz et al. 2000). Growth rates differ appreciably between
the sexes with females attaining weights up to 11.8 kg (26 lb).
U.S. commercial and recreational
fisheries for summer flounder are managed under the Summer Flounder,
Scup and Black Sea Bass Fishery Management Plan (FMP) administered
jointly by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC)
and the Mid-Atlantic Fishery Management Council (MAFMC). Amendment
2 to the Summer Flounder FMP implemented several major regulatory
provisions, including annual commercial quotas, recreational harvest
limits, a commercial vessel permit moratorium, minimum fish size
and gear restrictions, and a recreational fishery possession limit.
The target/threshold fishing mortality reference point of FMSY
is defined to be Fmax, currently at F = 0.28, and the
target and threshold spawning stock biomass (SSB) reference points
are currently estimated to be 89,411 mt and 44,706 mt, respectively.
The
Fishery
Total combined commercial and
recreational landings peaked at 26,100 mt in 1983, averaged 13,100
mt annually during 1986-1995, and have since ranged between 8,600
mt (in 1999) and 12,500 mt (in 2004) (Table 8.1).
The principal gear used in commercial fishing for summer flounder
is the otter trawl. After peaking at 17,900 mt in 1979, commercial
landings of summer flounder averaged 8,500 mt annually during 1986-1995,
and ranged between 4,000 mt and 7,800 mt during 1996-2005 (Figure
8.2[Fig
8.2 Data]). The recreational rod-and-reel fishery for summer
flounder harvests a significant proportion of the total catch, and
in some years recreational landings have exceeded commercial landings.
After peaking at 12,700 mt in 1983, recreational landings of summer
flounder averaged 4,600 mt annually during 1986-1995, and ranged
between 3,800 mt 7,100 mt during 1996-2005.
Summer flounder total catch
in numbers have generally been dominated by age 1 to age 3 fish
(Figure
8.3[Fig
8.3 Data]). The proportion of ages 0 and 1 summer flounder in
the commercial and recreational catch has been greatly reduced over
the last decade.
Research Vessel Survey
Indices
NEFSC spring and autumn biomass
indices for summer flounder have generally similar trends throughout
the survey time series (Figure
8.4[Fig
8.4 Data]). Biomass indices declined through the late 1970s
into the early 1990s, but increased during the early 1990s and are
currently at about the level of the mid-1970s. As stock biomass
declined in the 1980s, the age structure of the summer flounder
population became truncated, with a low proportion of fish at ages
3 and older (Figure
8.5[Fig
8.5 Data]). Since 1990, the age structure of the population
has expanded to approximate that observed in the mid-1970s.
Figure
8.2
Figure 8.3
Figure
8.4
Figure 8.5
Figure
8.6
Figure
8.7
Figure
8.8
Figure
8.9
Figure
8.10
Assessment
Results
Average fishing mortality (F, ages 3-5, unweighted)
ranged between 1.0 to 2.0 during the 1980s and mid 1990s, but
has steadily declined since 1997 and was F = 0.4 in 2005 (Figure
8.6[Fig
8.6 Data]). SSB declined from 24,400 mt in 1983 to 7,000 mt
in 1989, but with improved recruitment and decreased fishing mortality
increased to 47,500 mt by 2005 (Figure
8.7[Fig
8.7 Data]). Since 1982, recruitment at age 0 has ranged from
13 million fish (1988) to 80 million fish (1983 year class) (Figure
8.7[Fig
8.7 Data]). Average recruitment was 37 million fish during
1982-2005.
Biological
Reference Points
Biological reference points for summer flounder
(Figure
8.8[Fig
8.8 Data]) were updated in 2006 (Terceiro 2006) and are presented
in Table 8.2. The relationship between SSB
and recruitment for summer flounder during 1983-2005 is illustrated
in (Figure
8.9[Fig
8.9 Data]). The stock-recruitment trajectory indicates that
recent levels of SSB and recruitment are on the far-right side
of the plot. Survival ratios, recruits per unit of SSB (Figure
8.10
[Fig 8.10 Data]), illustrate the relatively low survival of
recent year classes despite the relatively high level of the spawning
stock.
Summary
Summer flounder SSB has increased substantially
from 7,025 mt in 1989 to 47,498 mt in 2005, about 6% above the
biomass threshold of ½ BMSY. Fully recruited
fishing mortality was estimated to be 0.41 in 2005, about 45%
above the fishing mortality threshold of Fmsy = Fmax
= 0.28. Thus, the stock is not in an overfished condition but
overfishing continues to occur.
Bolz, G.R., J.P. Monaghan
Jr., K.L. Land, R.W.Gregory, and J.M. Burnett, Proceedings
of the summer flounder aging workshop, 1-2 February 1999,
Woods Hole, Massachusetts. NOAA Tech. Mem. NMFS-NE-156, 15
p.
O’Brien, L., J. Burnett,
and R.K. Mayo. 1993. Maturation of nineteen species of finfish off
the northeast coast of the United States, 1985-1990. NOAA Tech.
Report. NMFS 113, 66 p.
Packer, D.B., S.J. Griesbach,
P.L.Berrien, C.A.Zetlin, D.L. Johnson, and W.W. Morse. Essential
fish habitat source document: summer flounder, (Paralichthys
dentatus), life history and habitat characteristics. NOAA Tech.
Mem. NMFS-NE-151, 88 p.