UNITED STATES
OF AMERICA
BEFORE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION
___________________________________
)
In the Matter of )
)
THE BOEING COMPANY, ) File No. 971-0006
a corporation. )
___________________________________)
AGREEMENT CONTAINING CONSENT
ORDER
The Federal Trade Commission ("Commission"),
having initiated an investigation of the acquisition of
Rockwell International Corporation's Aerospace and
Defense business by The Boeing Company
("Boeing"), and it now appearing that Boeing,
hereinafter sometimes referred to as "proposed
respondent," is willing to enter into an agreement
containing an order to refrain from certain acts and to
deliver certain assets, and providing for certain other
relief:
IT IS HEREBY AGREED by and between
proposed respondent, by its duly authorized officers and
attorneys, and counsel for the Commission that:
1. Proposed respondent Boeing is a corporation
organized, existing, and doing business under and by
virtue of the laws of the state of Delaware, with its
office and principal place of business located at
7755 East Marginal Way South, Seattle, Washington
98108.
2. Proposed respondent admits all the
jurisdictional facts set forth in the draft of
complaint here attached.
3. Proposed respondent waives:
a. Any further procedural steps;
b. The requirement that the Commission's
decision contain a statement of findings of fact
and conclusions of law;
c. All rights to seek judicial review or
otherwise to challenge or contest the validity of
the order entered pursuant to this agreement; and
d. Any claim under the Equal Access to Justice
Act.
4. Proposed respondent shall submit within thirty
(30) days of the date this agreement is signed by
proposed respondent an initial report, pursuant to
Section 2.33 of the Commission's Rules, signed by
proposed respondent setting forth in detail the
manner in which proposed respondent will comply with
Paragraphs II. through X. of the order when and if
entered. Proposed respondent shall include in such
report a detailed description and explanation of the
procedures it has implemented or will implement to
comply with Paragraphs II. through X. of the order.
Such report will not become part of the public record
unless and until the accompanying agreement and order
are accepted by the Commission.
5. This agreement shall not become a part of the
public record of the proceeding unless and until it
is accepted by the Commission. If this agreement is
accepted by the Commission it, together with the
draft of complaint contemplated thereby, will be
placed on the public record for a period of sixty
(60) days and information in respect thereto publicly
released. The Commission thereafter may either
withdraw its acceptance of this agreement and so
notify proposed respondent, in which event it will
take such action as it may consider appropriate, or
issue and serve its complaint (in such form as the
circumstances may require) and decision, in
disposition of the proceeding.
6. This agreement is for settlement purposes only
and does not constitute an admission by proposed
respondent that the law has been violated as alleged
in the draft of complaint here attached, or that the
facts as alleged in the draft complaint, other than
jurisdictional facts, are true.
7. This agreement contemplates that, if it is
accepted by the Commission, and if such acceptance is
not subsequently withdrawn by the Commission pursuant
to the provisions of Section 2.34 of the Commission's
Rules, the Commission may, without further notice to
the proposed respondent, (1) issue its complaint
corresponding in form and substance with the draft of
complaint here attached and its decision containing
the following order to refrain from certain acts and
to deliver certain assets, and providing for certain
other relief in disposition of the proceeding, and
(2) make information public with respect thereto.
When so entered, the order shall have the same force
and effect and may be altered, modified, or set aside
in the same manner and within the same time provided
by statute for other orders. The order shall become
final upon service. Delivery by the U.S. Postal
Service of the complaint and decision containing the
agreed-to order to proposed respondent's address as
stated in this agreement shall constitute service.
Proposed respondent waives any right it may have to
any other manner of service. The complaint may be
used in construing the terms of the order, and no
agreement, understanding, representation or
interpretation not contained in the order or the
agreement may be used to vary or contradict the terms
of the order.
8. Proposed respondent has read the draft of
complaint and order contemplated hereby. Proposed
respondent understands that once the order has been
issued, it will be required to file one or more
compliance reports showing that it has fully complied
with the order. Proposed respondent further
understands that it may be liable for civil penalties
in the amount provided by law for each violation of
the order after it becomes final.
ORDER
I.
IT IS ORDERED that, as used in this
order, the following definitions shall apply:
A. "Respondent" or "Boeing"
means The Boeing Company, its directors, officers,
employees, agents, representatives, predecessors,
successors and assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions,
groups, affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by The Boeing Company, and the respective
directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, successors and assigns of each.
Boeing also includes Rockwell Aerospace and Defense.
B. "Rockwell" means Rockwell
International Corporation, a corporation organized,
existing and doing business under the laws of the
state of Delaware, with its office and principal
place of business located at 2201 Seal Beach
Boulevard, Seal Beach, California 90740, its
directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, predecessors, successors and
assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions, groups,
affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by Rockwell International Corporation, and
the respective directors, officers, employees,
agents, representatives, successors and assigns of
each.
C. "Rockwell Aerospace and Defense"
means Rockwell's Aerospace and Defense businesses,
including the Autonetics and Missiles Systems
Division, North American Aircraft Division, North
American Aircraft Modification Division, Rocketdyne
Division, Space Systems Division and Rockwell's
interest in United Space Alliance, its directors,
officers, employees, agents, representatives,
predecessors, successors and assigns; its
subsidiaries, divisions, groups, affiliates,
partnerships and joint ventures controlled by
Rockwell Aerospace and Defense, and the respective
directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, successors and assigns of each.
Rockwell Aerospace and Defense does not include any
of the assets that are not included in the
Acquisition and that will remain part of Rockwell
after the Acquisition.
D. "Acquisition" means the acquisition
of Rockwell Aerospace and Defense by Boeing.
E. "Commission" means the Federal Trade
Commission.
F. "Allegheny Teledyne" means Allegheny
Teledyne Incorporated, a corporation organized,
existing and doing business under and by virtue of
the laws of the state of Massachusetts, with its
office and principal place of business located at
1000 Six PPG Place, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15222,
its directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, predecessors, successors and
assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions, groups,
affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by Allegheny Teledyne Incorporated, and
the respective directors, officers, employees,
agents, representatives, successors and assigns of
each.
G. "Teledyne Ryan" means Teledyne Ryan
Aeronautical, a division of Allegheny Teledyne, with
its office and principal place of business located at
2701 Harbor Drive, San Diego, California 92101-1085,
its directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, predecessors, successors and
assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions, groups,
affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by Teledyne Ryan Aeronautical, and the
respective directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, successors and assigns of each.
H. "Person" means any natural person,
corporate entity, partnership, association, joint
venture, government entity, trust or other business
or legal entity.
I. "Tier II Plus" or "Global
Hawk" means the Tier II Plus high altitude
endurance unmanned air vehicle currently being
developed for the United States Advanced Research
Projects Agency.
J. "Tier II Plus Wings" means the
completed and integrated wing assemblies used for
Tier II Plus.
K. "Tier II Plus Wings Special Tooling and
Special Test Equipment" means all of the special
tooling and special test equipment, as the terms
special tooling and special test equipment are
defined in Federal Acquisition Regulations, 48 C.F.R.
("FAR") § 45.101, used in the design,
development and manufacture of Tier II Plus Wings.
L. "Tier II Plus Wings Engineering and Design
Data" means all of the engineering and design
data, in both electronic and hard copy, used in the
design, development and manufacture of Tier II Plus
Wings.
M. "Tier II Plus Prime Agreement" means
Agreement No. MDA972-95-3-0013 between Teledyne Ryan
and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency and
any amendments to such agreement.
N. "Phase II Flight & System Performance
Test" means all of the flights and tests of Tier
II Plus associated with Phase II of the United States
Advanced Research Projects Agency's Tier II Plus
program.
O. "Tier III Minus" or
"DarkStar" means the Tier III Minus high
altitude endurance unmanned air vehicle currently
being developed for the United States Advanced
Research Projects Agency.
P. "Space Launch Vehicle" means any
vehicle designed to launch satellites or persons into
space.
Q. "Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion
System" means any device designed, developed,
manufactured or sold by Rocketdyne that is used to
provide propulsion to a Space Launch Vehicle.
R. "Rockwell NAAD" means Rockwell
International Corporation's North American Aircraft
Division, an entity included within Rockwell
Aerospace and Defense and as part of the Acquisition,
with its principal place of business at 2201 Seal
Beach Boulevard, Seal Beach, California 90740, or any
other entity within or controlled by Boeing engaged
in, among other things, the research, development,
manufacture or sale of Tier II Plus Wings, and its
directors, officers, employees, agents and
representatives, predecessors, successors and
assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions, groups,
affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by Rockwell NAAD, and the respective
directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, successors and assigns of each.
S. "Rocketdyne" means Rockwell
International Corporation's Rocketdyne Division, an
entity included within Rockwell Aerospace and Defense
and as part of the Acquisition, with its principal
place of business at 6633 Canoga Avenue, Canoga Park,
California 91304, or any other entity within or
controlled by Boeing engaged in, among other things,
the research, development, manufacture or sale of
Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion Systems, and its
directors, officers, employees, agents and
representatives, predecessors, successors, and
assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions, groups,
affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by Rocketdyne, and the respective
directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, successors and assigns of each.
T. "Boeing Tier III Minus Business"
means any entity within or controlled by Boeing that
is engaged in, among other things, the research,
development, manufacture or sale of Tier III Minus,
and its directors, officers, employees, agents and
representatives, predecessors, successors and
assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions, groups,
affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by Boeing Tier III Minus Business, and the
respective directors, officers, employees, agents,
representatives, successors and assigns of each.
U. "Boeing Space Launch Vehicle
Business" means any entity within or controlled
by Boeing that is engaged in, among other things, the
research, development, manufacture or sale of Space
Launch Vehicles, and its directors, officers,
employees, agents and representatives, predecessors,
successors and assigns; its subsidiaries, divisions,
groups, affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures
controlled by Boeing Space Launch Vehicle Business,
and the respective directors, officers, employees,
agents, representatives, successors and assigns of
each.
V. "Non-Public Tier II Plus Information"
means any information not in the public domain
received or developed by Rockwell in its capacity as
a provider of Tier II Plus Wings. Non-Public Tier II
Plus Information shall not include: (1) information
known or disclosed to Respondent, excluding
Rockwell Aerospace and Defense, at the time
Respondent signs the Agreement Containing Consent
Order in this matter, (2) information that,
subsequent to the time Respondent signs the Agreement
Containing Consent Order in this matter, falls within
the public domain through no violation of this order
by Respondent, (3) information that, subsequent to
the time Respondent signs the Agreement Containing
Consent Order in this matter, becomes known to
Respondent from a third party not in breach of a
confidential disclosure agreement (information
obtained from Rockwell or otherwise obtained as a
result of the Acquisition shall not be considered
information known to Respondent from a third party),
or (4) information after six (6) years from the date
of disclosure of such Non-Public Tier II Plus
Information to Respondent, or such other period as
agreed to in writing by Respondent and the provider
of the information.
W. "Non-Public Tier III Minus
Information" means any information not in the
public domain received or developed by Boeing in its
capacity as a designer, developer or manufacturer of
Tier III Minus. Non-Public Tier III Minus Information
shall not include: (1) information known or disclosed
to Rockwell NAAD at the time Respondent signs the
Agreement Containing Consent Order in this matter,
(2) information that, subsequent to the time
Respondent signs the Agreement Containing Consent
Order in this matter, falls within the public domain
through no violation of this order by Respondent, (3)
information that, subsequent to the time Respondent
signs the Agreement Containing Consent Order in this
matter, becomes known to Rockwell NAAD from a third
party not in breach of a confidential disclosure
agreement, or (4) information after six (6) years
from the date of disclosure of such Non-Public Tier
III Minus Information to Respondent, or such other
period as agreed to in writing by Respondent and the
provider of the information.
X. "Non-Public Space Launch Vehicle
Information" means (1) any information not in
the public domain disclosed by any Space Launch
Vehicle manufacturer, other than Boeing, to
Rocketdyne in its capacity as a provider of Space
Launch Vehicle Propulsion Systems and (a) if written
information, designated in writing by the Space
Launch Vehicle manufacturer as proprietary
information by an appropriate legend, marking, stamp
or positive written identification on the face
thereof, or (b) if oral, visual or other information,
identified as proprietary information in writing by
the Space Launch Vehicle manufacturer prior to the
disclosure or within thirty (30) days after such
disclosure; or (2) any information not in the public
domain disclosed by any Space Launch Vehicle
manufacturer to Rocketdyne in its capacity as a
provider of Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion Systems
prior to the Acquisition. Non-Public Space Launch
Vehicle Information shall not include: (1)
information known or disclosed to Respondent, excluding
Rockwell Aerospace and Defense, at the time
Respondent signed the Agreement Containing Consent
Order in this matter, (2) information that,
subsequent to the time Respondent signs the Agreement
Containing Consent Order in this matter, falls within
the public domain through no violation of this order
by Respondent, (3) information that, subsequent to
the time Respondent signs the Agreement Containing
Consent Order in this matter, becomes known to
Respondent from a third party not in breach of a
confidential disclosure agreement (information
obtained from Rockwell or otherwise obtained as a
result of the Acquisition shall not be considered
information known to Respondent from a third party),
or (4) information after six (6) years from the date
of disclosure of such Non-Public Space Launch Vehicle
Information to Respondent, or such other period as
agreed to in writing by Respondent and the provider
of the information.
II.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent
shall not hold Teledyne Ryan liable for any damages or
costs resulting from the replacement of Respondent as the
supplier of Tier II Plus Wings.
III.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
A. At any time prior to six (6) months of the date
this order becomes final, and if Respondent and
Teledyne Ryan have not reached an agreement on a new
contract for Respondent to provide Tier II Plus Wings
to Teledyne Ryan, Respondent shall, upon request from
Teledyne Ryan, deliver to business locations in the
United States designated by Teledyne Ryan, and
assemble, the Tier II Plus Wings Special Tooling and
Special Test Equipment. Respondent shall perform its
obligations under this Paragraph III.A. as soon as
practicable after receiving such request from
Teledyne Ryan, but in a timeframe not to exceed
ninety (90) days from the receipt of such request, or
such other time period as agreed to in writing by
Teledyne Ryan. Respondent shall not charge Teledyne
Ryan for any costs associated with carrying out
Respondent's obligations under this Paragraph III.A.
that would not be considered allowable, as the term
allowable is defined in FAR § 52.216-7, under the
Tier II Plus Prime Agreement. Nothing in this
Paragraph shall alter Respondent's or Teledyne Ryan's
rights and obligations pursuant to FAR § 52.249-6,
as incorporated in any current or future Tier II Plus
Wings contract between Respondent and Teledyne Ryan.
B. At any time prior to six (6) months of the date
this order becomes final, and if Respondent and
Teledyne Ryan have not reached an agreement on a new
contract for Respondent to provide Tier II Plus Wings
to Teledyne Ryan, Respondent shall, upon request from
Teledyne Ryan, deliver to business locations in the
United States designated by Teledyne Ryan the Tier II
Plus Wings Engineering and Design Data. Respondent
shall perform its obligations under this Paragraph
III.B. as soon as practicable after receiving such
request from Teledyne Ryan, but in a timeframe not to
exceed fifteen (15) days from the receipt of such
request, or such other time period as agreed to in
writing by Teledyne Ryan. Respondent shall not charge
Teledyne Ryan for any costs associated with carrying
out Respondent's obligations under this Paragraph
III.B. that would not be considered allowable, as the
term allowable is defined in FAR § 52.216-7, under
the Tier II Plus Prime Agreement.
IV.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent
shall not assert or enforce any proprietary rights in any
Tier II Plus Wings Special Tooling and Special Test
Equipment or Tier II Plus Wings Engineering and Design
Data delivered pursuant to Paragraph III. of this order.
V.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
A. At any time prior to six (6) months of the date
this order becomes final, and if Respondent and
Teledyne Ryan have not reached an agreement on a new
contract for Respondent to provide Tier II Plus Wings
to Teledyne Ryan, Respondent shall provide, upon
request from Teledyne Ryan, such assistance to
personnel designated by Teledyne Ryan as is
reasonably necessary to such personnel to design and
manufacture Tier II Plus Wings. Such assistance shall
include, but not be limited to, consultation with
employees of Respondent knowledgeable in the design
and manufacture of Tier II Plus Wings, and training
at facilities designated by Teledyne Ryan for a
period of time and in a manner sufficient to satisfy
Teledyne Ryan's management that the designated
personnel are appropriately trained in the design and
manufacture of Tier II Plus Wings. Respondent shall
convey to personnel designated by Teledyne Ryan all
know-how necessary to design and manufacture Tier II
Plus Wings. However, Respondent shall not be required
to continue providing such assistance for more than
one (1) year from the date Respondent begins
providing such assistance, and shall not be required
to provide personnel for more than the equivalent of
four (4) man-years during this one (1) year period.
Respondent shall not charge Teledyne Ryan for any
costs associated with carrying out Respondent's
obligations under this Paragraph V.A. that would not
be considered allowable, as the term allowable is
defined in FAR § 52.216-7, under the Tier II Plus
Prime Agreement.
B. Upon reasonable request from Teledyne Ryan,
Respondent shall provide such additional technical
assistance relating to the Tier II Plus Wings to
personnel designated by Teledyne Ryan as is
reasonably necessary to enable personnel designated
by Teledyne Ryan to complete the Phase II Flight
& System Performance Test. Such assistance shall
include, but not be limited to, consultation with
employees of Respondent knowledgeable in the design
and manufacture of Tier II Plus Wings, and training
at facilities designated by Teledyne Ryan for a
period of time and in a manner sufficient to satisfy
Teledyne Ryan's management that the designated
personnel have sufficient knowledge relating to Tier
II Plus Wings to be able to support fully Teledyne
Ryan's efforts to complete the Phase II Flight &
System Performance Test requirements. However,
Respondent shall not be required to continue
providing such assistance after the completion of the
Phase II Flight & System Performance Test.
Respondent shall charge Teledyne Ryan at a rate of no
more than $90 per hour for providing such technical
assistance.
VI.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
A. Respondent shall not provide, disclose or
otherwise make available to the Boeing Tier III Minus
Business any Non-Public Tier II Plus Information.
B. Respondent shall use any Non-Public Tier II
Plus Information only in Respondent's capacity as a
provider of Tier II Plus Wings or technical
assistance, pursuant to Paragraph V. of this order.
VII.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
A. Respondent shall not provide, disclose or
otherwise make available to Rockwell NAAD any
Non-Public Tier III Minus Information.
B. Respondent shall use any Non-Public Tier III
Minus Information only in its capacity as a designer,
developer or manufacturer of Tier III Minus.
VIII.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
A. Rocketdyne shall not, absent the prior written
consent of the proprietor of Non-Public Space Launch
Vehicle Information, provide, disclose or otherwise
make available to Boeing Space Launch Vehicle
Business any Non-Public Space Launch Vehicle
Information.
B. Rocketdyne shall use any Non-Public Space
Launch Vehicle Information only in its capacity as a
provider of Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion Systems,
absent the prior written consent of the proprietor of
the Non-Public Space Launch Vehicle Information.
IX.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent
shall deliver a copy of this order to any Space Launch
Vehicle manufacturer prior to obtaining, either from the
Space Launch Vehicle manufacturer or through the
Acquisition, any information outside the public domain
relating to that manufacturer's Space Launch Vehicle.
X.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent
shall comply with all terms of the Interim Agreement,
attached to this order and made a part hereof as Appendix
I.
XI.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that within
sixty (60) days of the date this order becomes final and
annually for the next ten (10) years on the anniversary
of the date this order becomes final, and at such other
times as the Commission may require, Respondent shall
file a verified written report with the Commission
setting forth in detail the manner and form in which it
has complied and is complying with Paragraphs II. through
X. of this order. Respondent shall include in its reports
information sufficient to identify all Space Launch
Vehicle Manufacturers with whom Respondent has entered
into an agreement for the research, development,
manufacture or sale of Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion
Systems.
XII.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent
shall notify the Commission at least thirty (30) days
prior to any proposed change in Respondent, such as
dissolution, assignment, sale resulting in the emergence
of a successor corporation, or the creation or
dissolution of subsidiaries or sale of any division or
any other change in Respondent that may affect compliance
obligations arising out of the order.
XIII.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, for the
purpose of determining or securing compliance with this
order, subject to any legally recognized privilege and
applicable United States Government national security
requirements, upon written request, and on reasonable
notice, Respondent shall permit any duly authorized
representative of the Commission:
A. Access, during office hours and in the presence
of counsel, to inspect and copy all books, ledgers,
accounts, correspondence, memoranda and other records
and documents in the possession or under the control
of Respondent relating to any matters contained in
this order; and
B. Upon five (5) days' notice to Respondent and
without restraint or interference from it, to
interview officers, directors, or employees of
Respondent, who may have counsel present, regarding
such matters.
XIV.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that this order
shall terminate twenty (20) years from the date this
order becomes final, except as otherwise provided in this
order.
Signed this _____ day of _____________, 1996.
APPENDIX I
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION
____________________________________
)
In the Matter of )
)
THE BOEING COMPANY, ) File No. 971-0006
a corporation. )
____________________________________)
INTERIM AGREEMENT
This Interim Agreement is by and between The Boeing
Company ("Boeing"), a corporation organized and
existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, and the
Federal Trade Commission ("Commission"), an
independent agency of the United States Government,
established under the Federal Trade Commission Act of
1914, 15 U.S.C. § 41, et seq.
PREMISES
WHEREAS, Boeing has proposed to
acquire Rockwell International Corporation's Aerospace
and Defense business; and
WHEREAS, the Commission is now
investigating the proposed Acquisition to determine if it
would violate any of the statutes the Commission
enforces; and
WHEREAS, if the Commission accepts
the Agreement Containing Consent Order ("Consent
Agreement"), the Commission will place it on the
public record for a period of at least sixty (60) days
and subsequently may either withdraw such acceptance or
issue and serve its Complaint and decision in disposition
of the proceeding pursuant to the provisions of Section
2.34 of the Commission's Rules; and
WHEREAS, the Commission is concerned
that if an understanding is not reached preserving
competition during the period prior to the final issuance
of the Consent Agreement by the Commission (after the
60-day public notice period), there may be interim
competitive harm and divestiture or other relief
resulting from a proceeding challenging the legality of
the proposed Acquisition might not be possible, or might
be less than an effective remedy; and
WHEREAS, Boeing entering into this
Interim Agreement shall in no way be construed as an
admission by Boeing that the proposed Acquisition
constitutes a violation of any statute; and
WHEREAS, Boeing understands that no
act or transaction contemplated by this Interim Agreement
shall be deemed immune or exempt from the provisions of
the antitrust laws or the Federal Trade Commission Act by
reason of anything contained in this Interim Agreement,
NOW, THEREFORE, Boeing agrees, upon
the understanding that the Commission has not yet
determined whether the proposed Acquisition will be
challenged, and in consideration of the Commission's
agreement that, at the time it accepts the Consent
Agreement for public comment, it will grant early
termination of the Hart-Scott-Rodino waiting period, as
follows:
1. Boeing agrees to execute and be bound by the
terms of the Order contained in the Consent
Agreement, as if it were final, from the date Boeing
signs the Consent Agreement.
2. Boeing agrees to deliver, within three (3) days
of the date the Consent Agreement is accepted for
public comment by the Commission, a copy of the
Consent Agreement and a copy of this Interim
Agreement to the United States Department of Defense,
Teledyne Ryan Aeronautical, McDonnell Douglas
Corporation and Lockheed Martin Corporation.
3. Boeing agrees to submit, within thirty (30)
days of the date the Consent Agreement is signed by
Boeing, an initial report, pursuant to Section 2.33
of the Commission's Rules, signed by Boeing setting
forth in detail the manner in which Boeing will
comply with Paragraphs II. through X. of the Consent
Agreement. Boeing agrees to include in such report a
detailed description and explanation of the
procedures it has implemented or will implement to
comply with Paragraphs II. through X. of the Order.
4. Boeing agrees that, from the date Boeing signs
the Consent Agreement until the first of the dates
listed in subparagraphs 4.a. and 4.b., it will comply
with the provisions of this Interim Agreement:
a. ten (10) business days after the Commission
withdraws its acceptance of the Consent Agreement
pursuant to the provisions of Section 2.34 of the
Commission's Rules; or
b. the date the Commission finally issues its
Complaint and its Decision and Order.
5. Boeing waives all rights to contest the
validity of this Interim Agreement.
6. For the purpose of determining or securing
compliance with this Interim Agreement, subject to
any legally recognized privilege and applicable
United States Government national security
requirements, upon written request, and on reasonable
notice, to Boeing made to its principal office,
Boeing shall permit any duly authorized
representative or representatives of the Commission:
a. access, during office hours and in the
presence of counsel, to inspect and copy all
books, ledgers, accounts, correspondence,
memoranda, and other records and documents in the
possession or under the control of Boeing
relating to compliance with this Interim
Agreement; and
b. upon five (5) days' notice to Boeing and
without restraint or interference from it, to
interview officers, directors, or employees of
Boeing, who may have counsel present, regarding
such matters.
7. This Interim Agreement shall not be binding
until accepted by the Commission.
Dated: Accepted for public comment by the Commission
on
December 5, 1996.
Donald S. Clark
Secretary of the Commission
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION
______________________________
)
)
In the Matter of )
) Docket No.
THE BOEING COMPANY, )
a corporation. )
)
______________________________)
COMPLAINT
The Federal Trade Commission ("Commission"),
having reason to believe that Respondent, The Boeing
Company ("Boeing"), a corporation subject to
the jurisdiction of the Commission, has agreed to acquire
the Aerospace and Defense Business of Rockwell
International Corporation ("Rockwell"), a
corporation subject to the jurisdiction of the
Commission, in violation of Section 5 of the Federal
Trade Commission Act ("FTC Act"), as amended,
15 U.S.C. § 45, and that such an acquisition, if
consummated, would violate Section 7 of the Clayton Act,
as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 18 and Section 5 of the FTC
Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 45; and it appearing
to the Commission that a proceeding in respect thereof
would be in the public interest, hereby issues its
Complaint, stating its charges as follows:
I. DEFINITIONS
1. "High Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air
Vehicle" means any unmanned aircraft designed to
perform high-altitude, broad-area reconnaissance missions
and manufactured for sale to the United States Department
of Defense.
2. "Tier II Plus" or "Global Hawk"
means the Tier II Plus High Altitude Endurance Unmanned
Air Vehicle currently being developed for the Department
of Defense's Advanced Research Projects Agency.
3. "Tier III Minus" or "DarkStar"
means the Tier III Minus High Altitude Endurance Unmanned
Air Vehicle currently being developed for the Department
of Defense's Advanced Research Projects Agency.
4. "Tier II Plus Team" means Teledyne Ryan
Aeronautical and the group of subcontractors, including
Rockwell Aerospace and Defense, which are currently
developing Tier II Plus.
5. "Tier III Minus Team" means the team
comprised of Boeing and Lockheed Martin Corporation which
is currently developing Tier III Minus.
6. "Space Launch Vehicle" means any vehicle
designed to launch satellites or persons into space.
7. "Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion System"
means any device that is used to provide propulsion to a
Space Launch Vehicle.
8. "Respondent" means Boeing.
II. RESPONDENT
9. Respondent is a corporation organized and existing
under and by virtue of the laws of the state of Delaware,
with its office and principal place of business located
at 7755 East Marginal Way South, Seattle, Washington
98108.
10. Respondent is engaged in, among other things, the
research, development, manufacture and sale of High
Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles and Space Launch
Vehicles.
11. For purposes of this proceeding, Respondent is,
and at all times relevant herein has been, engaged in
commerce as "commerce" is defined in Section 1
of the Clayton Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 12, and
is a corporation whose business is in or affecting
commerce as "commerce" is defined in Section 4
of the FTC Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 44.
III. ACQUIRED COMPANY
12. Rockwell Aerospace and Defense Business
("Rockwell Aerospace and Defense") is a
division of Rockwell, a corporation organized and
existing under and by virtue of the laws of the state of
Delaware, with its principal office and place of business
located at 2201 Seal Beach Boulevard, Seal Beach,
California 90740.
13. Rockwell Aerospace and Defense is engaged in,
among other things, the research, development,
manufacture and sale of wings for High Altitude Endurance
Unmanned Air Vehicles, and Space Launch Vehicle
Propulsion Systems.
14. Rockwell Aerospace and Defense is, and at all
times relevant herein has been, engaged in commerce as
"commerce" is defined in Section 1 of the
Clayton Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 12, and is a
corporation whose business is in or affecting commerce as
"commerce" is defined in Section 4 of the FTC
Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 44.
IV. THE ACQUISITION
15. On or about July 31, 1996, Boeing entered into an
Agreement and Plan of Merger, whereby Boeing would
acquire Rockwell Aerospace and Defense for approximately
$3.025 billion ("Acquisition").
V. THE RELEVANT MARKETS
16. For purposes of this Complaint, the relevant lines
of commerce in which to analyze the effects of the
Acquisition are:
a. the research, development, manufacture and sale
of High Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles;
b. the research, development, manufacture and sale
of Space Launch Vehicles; and
c. the research, development, manufacture and sale
of Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion Systems.
17. For purposes of this Complaint, the United States
is the relevant geographic area in which to analyze the
effects of the Acquisition in all relevant lines of
commerce.
VI. STRUCTURE OF THE MARKETS
18. The market for the research, development,
manufacture and sale of High Altitude Endurance Unmanned
Air Vehicles is highly concentrated as measured by the
Herfindahl-Hirschman Index ("HHI") or the
two-firm and four-firm concentration ratios
("concentration ratios"). Respondent and
Rockwell are members of the only two teams which produce
High Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles.
19. Respondent, through the Acquisition, would be a
member of both the Tier II Plus Team and the Tier III
Minus Team.
20. The market for Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion
Systems is highly concentrated as measured by the HHI or
concentration ratios.
21. Respondent, through the proposed Acquisition,
would be engaged in the research, development,
manufacture and sale of a wide range of Space Launch
Vehicles and Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion Systems.
VII. BARRIERS TO ENTRY
22. Entry into the market for the research,
development, manufacture and sale of High Altitude
Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles would not occur in a
timely manner to deter or counteract the adverse
competitive effects described in Paragraph 26 because of,
among other things, the difficulty involved in developing
the technology and expertise necessary to produce High
Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles.
23. Entry into the market for the research,
development, manufacture and sale of High Altitude
Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles is not likely to occur to
deter or counteract the adverse competitive effects
described in Paragraph 26 because of, among other things,
the expense required to develop the technology and
expertise necessary to produce High Altitude Endurance
Unmanned Air Vehicles.
24. Entry into the market for the research,
development, manufacture and sale of Space Launch Vehicle
Propulsion Systems would not occur in a timely manner to
deter or counteract the adverse competitive effects
described in Paragraph 26 because of, among other things,
the difficulty involved in developing the technology and
expertise necessary to produce Space Launch Vehicle
Propulsion Systems.
25. Entry into the market for the research,
development, manufacture and sale of Space Launch Vehicle
Propulsion Systems is not likely to occur to deter or
counteract the adverse competitive effects described in
Paragraph 26 because of, among other things, the expense
required to develop the technology and expertise
necessary to produce Space Launch Vehicle Propulsion
Systems.
VIII. EFFECTS OF THE
ACQUISITION
26. The effects of the Acquisition may be
substantially to lessen competition and to tend to create
a monopoly in the United States markets for High Altitude
Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles and Space Launch Vehicles
in violation of Section 7 of the Clayton Act, 15 U.S.C.
§ 18, and Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act,
15 U.S.C. § 45, in the following ways, among others:
a. by reducing actual, direct and substantial
competition between the Tier II Plus Team and the
Tier III Minus Team in the research, development,
manufacture and sale of High Altitude Endurance
Unmanned Air Vehicles;
b. by increasing the likelihood that the
Department of Defense would be forced to pay higher
prices for High Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air
Vehicles;
c. by increasing the likelihood that quality and
technological innovation in the High Altitude
Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicle market would be
reduced;
d. by allowing Respondent to gain access to
competitively sensitive non-public information
concerning the Tier II Plus team, whereby:
(1) actual, direct and substantial competition
between the Tier II Plus Team and the Tier III
Minus Team in the High Altitude Endurance
Unmanned Air Vehicle market would be reduced;
(2) the likelihood that the Department of
Defense would be forced to pay higher prices for
High Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicles
would be increased; and
(3) quality and technical innovation in the
High Altitude Endurance Unmanned Air Vehicle
market would be reduced; and
e. by allowing Respondent to gain access to
competitively sensitive non-public information
concerning other Space Launch Vehicle manufacturers,
whereby:
(1) actual competition between Respondent and
other Space Launch Vehicle manufacturers would be
reduced; and
(2) quality and technical innovation in the
Space Launch Vehicle market would be reduced.
IX. VIOLATIONS CHARGED
27. The Acquisition described in Paragraph 15
constitutes a violation of Section 5 of the FTC Act, as
amended, 15 U.S.C. § 45.
28. The Acquisition described in Paragraph 15, if
consummated, would constitute a violation of Section 7 of
the Clayton Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 18, and Section
5 of the FTC Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 45.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Federal Trade Commission has
caused this Complaint to be signed by the Secretary and
its official seal to be affixed, at Washington, D.C. this
_____ day of __________, A.D. 1996.
By the Commission.
Donald S. Clark
Secretary
SEAL
ANALYSIS OF PROPOSED CONSENT
ORDER
TO AID PUBLIC COMMENT
The Federal Trade Commission ("Commission")
has accepted, subject to final approval, an agreement
containing a proposed Consent Order from The Boeing
Company ("Boeing") designed to remedy the
anticompetitive effects likely to result from Boeing's
proposed acquisition of Rockwell International
Corporation's Aerospace and Defense business
("Rockwell Aerospace and Defense"). The
proposed Consent Order enables Teledyne Ryan, the prime
contractor for the Tier II Plus high altitude endurance
unmanned air vehicle ("HAE UAV"), to replace
Boeing as its teammate and wing supplier for Tier II
Plus, without incurring any significant cost or risk, by
requiring Boeing, at Teledyne Ryan's request, to deliver
to Teledyne Ryan all of the assets needed to manufacture
wings for the Tier II Plus and provide technical
assistance to Teledyne Ryan. In addition, the proposed
Consent Order prohibits Boeing's space launch vehicle
division from gaining access to any non-public
information that Boeing's space launch vehicle propulsion
system division will receive after the acquisition from
competing space launch vehicle providers.
The proposed Consent Order has been placed on the
public record for sixty (60) days for reception of
comments by interested persons. Comments received during
this period will become part of the public record. After
sixty (60) days, the Commission will again review the
agreement and any comments received and will decide
whether it should withdraw from the agreement or make
final the agreement's proposed Order.
On or about July 31, 1996, Boeing agreed to acquire
Rockwell Aerospace and Defense for approximately $3.025
billion. The proposed complaint alleges that the
acquisition, if consummated, would violate Section 7 of
the Clayton Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. § 18, and
Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act as amended,
15 U.S.C. § 45, in the markets for HAE UAVs and
space launch vehicles.
The proposed Consent Order would remedy the alleged
violations in each market. First, Boeing and Rockwell are
members of the only two teams currently competing in the
design and development of HAE UAVs. Boeing and its
teammate Lockheed Martin are currently developing the
Tier III Minus HAE UAV, and Teledyne Ryan and a team of
subcontractors, including Rockwell Aerospace and Defense,
are currently developing the Tier II Plus HAE UAV.
HAE UAVs are unmanned aircraft used to perform
high-altitude, broad area reconnaissance. These aircraft
are controlled from the ground and transmit
reconnaissance sensor data on a real time basis. HAE UAVs
are being designed to satisfy the Defense Airborne
Reconnaissance Office's goal of providing the U.S.
military with the ability to obtain responsive and
continuous reconnaissance data from anywhere within enemy
territory, day or night, as the needs of the warfighter
dictate. Under its teaming agreement with Lockheed
Martin, Boeing is responsible for providing, among other
things, the wings, launch station and avionics for Tier
III Minus. As a subcontractor to Teledyne Ryan for Tier
II Plus, Rockwell is responsible for providing only the
aircraft's wings. The proposed acquisition therefore
would position Boeing as a member of both competing HAE
UAV teams while Boeing would stand to earn a far greater
share of the revenue from its participation on the Tier
III Minus team than it could earn from its role as the
wing supplier for the Tier II Plus team.
The acquisition is likely to lead to anticompetitive
effects in the HAE UAV market. Because the proposed
acquisition would cause Boeing to be a member of the only
two competing HAE UAV teams, Boeing would be in a
position to raise price and/or reduce quality on one or
both teams. Boeing would not only have the opportunity to
diminish competition, but would also have the incentive
to cause the Tier II Plus team to become non-competitive
because Boeing stands to earn significantly more revenue
from its participation in the Tier III Minus program than
it would earn as a supplier of wings to the Tier II Plus
team. Moreover, if the Tier II Plus system became
non-competitive, or simply less competitive, Boeing would
then be in a position to also raise the price of the Tier
III Minus system.
The proposed consent agreement resolves the likely
anticompetitive effects of the acquisition in the HAE UAV
market by enabling Teledyne Ryan to replace Rockwell
Aerospace and Defense, which would be owned by Boeing
after the acquisition, as the Tier II Plus wing supplier
without incurring any significant costs or risk. As a
result, Boeing will either agree to supply Tier II Plus
wings in a competitive manner after the acquisition or be
replaced by Teledyne Ryan.
Specifically, under the terms of the Order, Boeing is
required to deliver, upon request from Teledyne Ryan, to
business locations in the United States designated by
Teledyne Ryan, at no cost to Teledyne Ryan, all of the
assets needed to produce Tier II Plus wings, including
the special tooling, special test equipment, engineering
data and design data. Teledyne Ryan can request that
Boeing deliver such assets at anytime prior to six months
from the date the Order becomes final, provided Teledyne
Ryan and Boeing have not agreed to a new contract for
Boeing to supply wings for Tier II Plus. This ensures
that Boeing will have the incentive to compete vigorously
to remain a supplier of wings for Tier II Plus. In
addition, Boeing is prohibited from asserting or
enforcing any proprietary rights in such equipment or
data, or holding Teledyne Ryan liable for any damages or
costs resulting from the replacement of Boeing as the
Tier II plus wing supplier.
In order to ensure a smooth transition of the wing
manufacturing to a new supplier and to offset any lost
learning curve efficiencies, the proposed Order requires
Boeing to provide technical assistance, not to exceed
four man years over a one year period, at no cost to
Teledyne Ryan. Because Teledyne Ryan may need Boeing's
assistance in resolving any technical issues that arise
during the upcoming Tier II Plus flight tests, the Order
requires Boeing to provide additional technical
assistance through the duration of such tests. Finally,
in order to prevent the anticompetitive flow of
competitively sensitive information, the order
establishes a "firewall" between Boeing's Tier
III Minus business and the Rockwell North American
Aircraft Division that is currently providing Tier II
Plus wings.
Boeing is also a significant competitor in the
research, development, manufacture and sale of space
launch vehicles, and is expected to bid for the upcoming
Department of Defense ("DoD") Evolved
Expendable Launch Vehicle ("EELV") program. The
EELV competition is expected to produce the next
generation of launch vehicles to replace all current
medium to heavy launchers -- Lockheed Martin's Atlas,
Titan II and Titan IV series, and McDonnell Douglas's
Delta series -- with a single family of vehicles capable
of launching medium and heavy payloads into orbit at a
significantly lower cost. The EELV will handle the bulk
of the U.S. government's launch requirements after the
year 2000 and is also expected to be used for commercial
applications. Boeing, McDonnell Douglas, Lockheed Martin
and Alliant Techsystems are currently facing a
down-selection from four to two contractors in the next
phase of the EELV program.
Rockwell, through its Rocketdyne Division
("Rocketdyne"), is one of the world's leading
manufacturers of space launch vehicle propulsion systems.
Currently, Boeing and McDonnell Douglas are planning to
use Rocketdyne propulsion systems as part of their EELV
proposals. Thus, the proposed acquisition would
vertically integrate Boeing as an EELV bidder and a
launch vehicle propulsion systems provider.
Because an EELV manufacturer that is using a Rockwell
propulsion system must work very closely with Rockwell in
order to integrate that system into its EELV, Boeing and
McDonnell Douglas have provided, and will continue to
provide, a wide range of competitively sensitive
proprietary design, performance, cost-related, marketing
and business strategy information to Rockwell. If DoD
selects the Boeing and McDonnell Douglas teams as the
finalists for the EELV competition, Boeing's launch
vehicle division could gain access to the proprietary
information that McDonnell Douglas has provided to
Rockwell's launch vehicle propulsion business, which
could affect the prices and services that Boeing would
offer. Thus, the proposed acquisition increases the
likelihood that competition between the participants in
the EELV program would decrease.
In addition, Boeing also competes in the commercial
market for space launch vehicles and Rockwell also
supplies space launch propulsion systems to Boeing's
commercial space launch vehicle competitors. As a result,
the proposed acquisition may result in similar
anticompetitive effects in future commercial space launch
vehicle procurements. In addition to causing higher
prices, the proposed acquisition may also reduce
innovation in the commercial space launch vehicle market,
as Boeing's competitors who use Rockwell propulsion
systems will be less willing to invest in new space
launch vehicle developments for fear that Boeing will be
able to "free-ride" off their technological
developments.
To remedy the proposed acquisition's likely
anticompetitive effects in the space launch vehicle
market, the proposed Consent Order preserves the
confidentiality of space launch vehicle suppliers'
proprietary information by prohibiting Boeing's division
that provides space launch vehicle propulsion systems
from making any proprietary information from competing
space launch vehicle manufacturers available to Boeing's
space launch vehicle division. Under the proposed Consent
Order, Boeing may only use such information in its
capacity as a provider of space launch vehicle propulsion
systems. Non-public information in this context includes
any information not in the public domain that is
designated as proprietary information by any space launch
vehicle manufacturer that provides such information to
Boeing as well as information not in the public domain
provided by any space launch vehicle manufacturer to
Rockwell prior to the acquisition. The purpose of the
proposed Consent Order is to preserve the opportunity for
full competition in the market for the research,
development, manufacture and sale of space launch
vehicles. The Commission has issued similar orders
limiting potentially anticompetitive information
transfers following mergers or acquisitions, including Lockheed
Martin, (C-3685)(September 20, 1996); Raytheon
Company, (C-3681)(September 10, 1996); Lockheed
Corporation/Martin Marietta Corporation, (C-3576)(May
9, 1995); Alliant Techsystems Inc., (C-3567)(April
7, 1995); Martin Marietta, (C-3500)(June 28,
1994).
Under the provisions of the proposed Consent Order,
Boeing is required to deliver a copy of the Order to any
space launch vehicle manufacturer prior to obtaining any
information from such manufacturer that is outside of the
public domain. The Order also requires Boeing to provide
the Commission a report of compliance with the provisions
of the Order within (60) days of the date the Order
becomes final, and annually for the next (10) years on
the anniversary of the date the Order becomes final.
In order to preserve competition in the relevant
markets during the period prior to the final acceptance
of the proposed
Consent Order (after the 60-day public notice period),
Boeing has entered into an Interim Agreement with the
Commission in which it has agreed to be bound by the
proposed Consent Order as of the date the Commission
accepts the proposed Consent Order subject to final
approval.
The purpose of this analysis is to facilitate public
comment on the proposed Consent Order, and it is not
intended to constitute an official interpretation of the
agreement and proposed Consent Order or to modify in any
way their terms.
|