Small Business
Research Summary
United States Small Business Administration
Office of Advocacy
RS 134
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
Myths and Realities of Working at Home:
Characteristics of Homebased Business Owners and Telecommuters
by Joanne H. Pratt
1993. 112p. Joanne H. Pratt Associates, Dallas, Texas
under contract no. SBA-6647-OA-91
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
Purpose
Working out of the home has become a significant and growing
phenomenon in the United States. "Homebased business owners"
are self-employed individuals who operate a business or profession
primarily from or in a home office. "Telecommuters"
are employees who do office work at home during normal business
hours. The 1987 Characteristics of Business Owners survey found
that more than 7 million businesses - including the majority of
women-owned businesses (54.6 percent) and nearly half of all non-minority
male-owned businesses (49.8 percent) - were homebased. The May
1991 Current Population Survey identified 5.6 million primary
homebased businesses. A 1990 proprietary survey estimated 7.4
million home business owners - including those with a side business
- and 7.2 million freelance workers, totaling 14.6 million "homebased
business" persons out of a work force of 122.7 million.
Owning a homebased business and working at home for wages are
both labor market options that offer flexibility to potential
entrepreneurs and employees. Understanding why people choose these
options, how homebased businesses benefit the larger economy,
and whether homebased business ownership and work should be encouraged
are relevant to current policy discussions.
Scope and Methodology
Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics' National Longitudinal
Survey (NLS) were used for this research. The NLS provides detailed
information that allows for comparisons between homebased and
non-homebased business owners and between workers who work at
home and those who do not. Nearly the full range of variables
believed to be critical to choice of homebased work are reported
in the NLS: labor market experience, socioeconomic variables and
environmental factors.
Three cohorts from the NLS, encompassing 17,068 individuals, were
selected for this study: 1988 surveys of men and women ages 23
to 30 (the NLS of Youth), the 1988 survey of women ages 34 to
44 (the NLS of Young Women) and the 1989 survey of women ages
52 to 66 (the NLS of Mature Women).
In each cohort, four labor market categories were examined: among
the self-employed, homebased business owners and non-homebased
business owners were compared; among wage-and-salary workers,
telecommuters were compared with non-telecommuters.
Three types of analysis were used: (1) comparative profiles of
individuals who pursue each of the four labor market outcomes;
(2) logistic regression models to explain the demographic and
human capital variables associated with each of the labor market
categories; and (3) regression models to examine the consequences
of working at home as opposed to earning income on-site.
Highlights
Homebased Business Owners
- Employment characteristics are key determinants of the mode
of work and certain cohorts are associated with certain industries.
For young men, having a homebased business is associated with
a professional occupation such as engineering or computer science.
For men in their 20s, it is associated with employment in the
construction industry, agriculture and business services industries.
For women in their 20s, homebased businesses are most strongly
associated with private household occupations and employment in
the personal services industry. For women in their 30s, it is
associated with service, sales, professional specialties and clerical
occupations. For mature women, the personal services industry
is the only determinant of self-employment (there was only one
homebased business in this cohort).
- There is little difference in the profile characteristics
of business owners who work at home and those who do not. While
age is not a limitation for men entering business, the likelihood
of a woman becoming a homebased business owner increases with
age. Also, non-minorities are more likely to be self-employed
and own homebased businesses than members of minority groups.
Education and work experience do not influence the likelihood
of homebased business operation for women and only increase it
slightly for young men.
- There are interesting differences in the incomes of homebased
businesses. Homebased businesswomen in their 20s earn substantially
less than self-employed women who work outside the home. Businessmen
of the same age make almost the same income, regardless of the
location of their business. Women over 30 earn about the same
net income working at home in a homebased business or in a non-homebased
business.
- The mean number of employees for homebased businessmen in
their 20s is 5.9 employees; for non-homebased businessmen it is
10.6 employees. For women the corresponding numbers are 1.5 and
5.2.
- Homebased businesses have greater net worth than non-homebased
businesses. Young men homebased business owners have mean family
assets of $10,014 compared with $4,801 for non-homebased business-men.
Women in their 20s have $9,378 and $6,004, respectively. Homebased
business women in their 30s and 40s have family assets of $137,796
compared with $112,617 for those women who do not work at home.
These findings belie the notion that homebased businesses lack
assets against which they can borrow to raise capital.
- There is little difference between the hours worked in a homebased
versus a non-homebased business. Self-employed male youth work
52.1 hours at home versus 49 hours for non-homebased, with a mean
number of 21.9 home hours. Self-employed women in their 20s work
a mean number of 36 hours regardless of work location. Businesswomen
work 21.6 hours at home when they are homebased, and 41.6 if employed
outside the home. Self-employed women in their 50s average 42.7
hours per week working for their firm. (There was only one homebased
businesswoman in the older cohort.)
Telecommuters
- Work patterns of telecommuters and non-telecommuters are very
similar. Men and women spend about the same amount of time - about
one hour - on lunch, coffee breaks and personal relaxing.
- Homebased work is not associated with employees who have a
young child. Employees do not care for their children on telecommuting
days.
- Telecommuters do not smoke, drink or use drugs as much as
people who do not work at home. Telecommuters receive promotions
at a greater rate than non-telecommuters.
- Telecommuters have positive attitudes toward their work. They
like the kind of work, they do not feel isolated from their peers,
and they enjoy considerable job stability.
Ordering Information
The complete report is available from:
National Technical Information Service
U.S. Department of Commerce
5285 Port Royal Road
Springfield, VA 22161
(703) 487-4650
(703) 487-4639 (TDD)
Order Number: PB93-192862
Cost: A06; A02 Microf.
*Last Modified 6-11-01