OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
MONTHLY DIGEST # 116
June 1994
A. United States Supreme Court
In Director, OWCP v. Maher Teminals, ___ U.S. ___,
Case No. 93-744 (June 20, 1994), the United States Supreme Court
decided that the "true doubt" rule violates §
556(d) of the Administrative Procedure Act because it places the
burden of persuasion on the party opposing a benefits award.
In Howlett v. Birkdale Shipping Co., ___ U.S. ___, Case
No. 93-670 (June 13, 1994), the United States Supreme Court held
that shipowners have only a narrow duty to warn stevedores of
latent defects in the cargo stow and cargo area during the
"turnover" period, which relates to the condition of
the ship upon commencement of stevedoring operations. The duty
attaches only to "latent hazards," which the Court
defined as "hazards that are not known to the stevedore and
that would be neither obvious to nor anticipated by a skilled
stevedore in the competent performance of its work." In so
holding, the Court rejected the injured worker's assertion that
shipowners have broad obligations to warn of latent hazards in
cargo stow and are liable if they fail to live up to these
obligations. The Court also concluded that the 1972 Amendments
to the LHWCA were designed to shift more responsibility for
compensating injured longshoremen to stevedores, who are best
able to avoid accidents during cargo operations.
B. Circuit court of appeals
In Baker v. Bethlehem Steel Corp., ___ F.3d ___, Case
No. 93-1695 (4th Cir. May 24, 1994), the Fourth Circuit held that
a longshoreman who sustains an occupational, noise-induced,
monaural hearing loss may be compensated for a monaural loss
under § 8(c)(13)(A). In reaching this holding, the court
reversed the Board's holding that the administrative law judge
should have converted the Claimant's monaural hearing loss to a
binaural loss, and adopted its earlier unpublished opinion in
Garner v. Newport News Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Co.,
955 F.2d 41 (4th Cir. 1992).