GasEx 2001: The Equatorial Pacific Air-Sea CO2 Exchange Experiment


Science Plan   May 28, 2000
Richard Feely   Wade McGillis   Rik Wanninkhof

Final Project Instructions (PDF file).
Updates and Pictures From the Cruise
Cruise report and access to data files from cruise


Figure 1: Schematic of surface ocean processes controlling the air-sea exchange of carbon dioxide.
Click on the above to (slowly) see a larger image. Very large file. 12,627 Kb TIF file. (2520x1710 vs. above 737x500)

Introduction
The world's oceans take up more than 40% of the annual release of fossil fuel carbon. To pinpoint the locations of oceanic uptake, and more importantly, to assess if this uptake will change in the future it is imperative to understand the processes responsible for this uptake. In addition to the value of knowing the CO2 sequestration by the oceans for predicting future atmospheric CO2 levels, the oceanic uptake together with the atmospheric growth rate and fuel emissions offer a robust constraint on terrestrial fluxes. Due to the spatial and temporal variability of terrestrial fluxes they are particularly difficult to quantify.

The air-sea flux of CO2, Fco2 can be expressed as:

Fco2 = k s DpCO2                         (1)

where k is the gas transfer velocity, s is the solubility of CO2 that is well quantified as a function of temperature and salinity, and DpCO2 is the difference in partial pressure of CO2 between the ocean, pCO2w and the atmosphere, pCO2a. The gas transfer velocity is referred to as the kinetic term and is controlled by sub-surface turbulence. It is often parameterized with wind speed but it is widely recognized that wind is not the only factor controlling k. The DpCO2 is the thermodynamic term and is controlled by an intricate interplay between physics, chemistry and biology in the upper water column. The pCO2a follows a distinct seasonal pattern that can be estimated over the ocean. The pCO2w variability on local scale is critical to interpret the CO2 flux on a mesoscale and to estimate global variability of CO2 fluxes. A long-term goal of the GasEx projects will incorporate the findings on local scale to determine gobal fluxes on seasonal time scales by modeling, extrapolation algorithms, and remote sensing.

In 1998, The Ocean-Atmosphere Carbon Exchange Study (OACES) of the NOAA Office of Global Programs (OGP) initiated a program of process studies to improve quantification of air-sea CO2 fluxes and gas transfer velocity. The ultimate goal of this effort is to be able to quantify transfer velocities on a regional scale from remote sensing such that, combined with regional DpCO2, global air-sea fluxes can be determined. To accomplish this goal, fluxes have to be determined at the same (hourly) time scale as the variability in environmental forcing. The mechanisms controlling DpCO2 on short time and space scales have to be determined, and the forcing functions have to related to parameters measured by remote sensing.

The approach has been to improve and validate methods to measure gas transfer (the kinetic term) on a hourly time scale in order to facilitate relating the transfer to environmental forcing. The surface boundary forcing will be quantified and related to near field (from ship or buoy) remote sensing. Once these relationships have been established and verified for the full spectrum of environments and conditions, the remote sensing will be expanded to far field (i.e. satellite) sensing such that global estimates of gas transfer can be determined. Simultaneous studies relating gas transfer to physical, chemical and biological controls on CO2 concentrations in surface water is necessary to construct predictive models.

Both the gas transfer velocities and the surface water pCO2, are likely to be controlled by regionally distinct processes. It is thus envisioned that a series of field studies will be executed to reach our ultimate goal of quantifying CO2 fluxes on seasonal timescales over the world's oceans. The first study, Gas Ex-98 in the N.Atlantic, was a feasibility study to test if airside direct flux measurements could be reconciled with geochemical mass balance approaches on the waterside. Direct flux measurements, co-variance, gradient, and eddy accumulation, potentially offer the advantage of measuring fluxes over 30-minute time scales but are singularly difficult to execute for trace gases with relatively small fluxes.

The proposed GasEx 2001 study is slated to take place in 2001 in the Eastern Equatorial Pacific south of the Equator. The first objective will be to continue with the recent progress and use direct gas flux measurements to improve our understanding of the forcing functions of the kinetics of air-sea gas exchange. A second focus will be on the physical, chemical, and biological factors controlling pCO2 in the surface water. This will be done at two scales: local variability on time and space scales of the direct flux measurements (hour and km scale) as it affects the CO2 fluxes, and mesoscale variability and its effect on regional flux estimates. The region is a CO2 source with relatively low wind speeds, offering a strong contrast with the first study that occurred in the North Atlantic with high winds and a large CO2 sink.

The Equatorial Pacific has been a focal point for chemical and physical studies such as JGOFS and TOGA since it has a major influence on climate variability through the ENSO cycle. The questions about mesoscale CO2 dynamics in this region relate to biological versus physical control, and remote versus local influences. Near the upwelling center it appears that the patterns in pCO2 are dominated by physics while further off-axis biological control becomes more important. The pCO2 in the surface water relates directly to upwelling strength but regional fluxes are strongly influenced by remote factors such as the capping off of the upwelling system by the low salinity water advecting from the West. Diurnal heating, tropical instability waves, variations in biological productivity, and trace metal limitations on productivity may also be important.

The region is thought to play a major role in interannual variability of CO2 fluxes and atmospheric CO2 levels. A long-term observational effort is in place to measure pCO2w levels that clearly show large depressions in D pCO2 during El Niños and pCO2w values during La Niña conditions. Although our understanding of the large-scale patterns of pCO2w in the region is improving, we must also increase our understanding on a phenomenological level in order to make accurate predictions and extrapolations. Surface water variability is evident over short temporal (hours) and spatial (km) scales. Chemical enhancement of CO2 exchange might play a role in the exchange process and surfactants are an important mechanism for retarding the gas transfer process. Surfactants produced by marine phytoplankton modulate gas exchange rates across the air-sea interface. Laboratory studies have examined the links between gas transfer velocity and wind stress, detailed small-scale wave spectra, surface viscoelastic modulus and turbulence in order to improve the parameterization of the gas transfer velocity in the presence of surfactants.

The physics of the air boundary layer is different as well in the Equatorial Pacific. Cool upwelled water will cause a stable air boundary layer, invalidating the neutral boundary assumption used in simple interpretation of the air gradient work. The boundary layer stability will also affect the friction velocity and drag coefficients. Water vapor interference will be greater as the water vapor content will be almost three times as high as during the Gas Ex-98 experiment.

The questions that will be addressed for Gas Ex-2001 are a progression of recent studies:

The low wind speed in the Equatorial Pacific and high DpCO2 offers a unique opportunity to directly determine the fluxes in a low turbulence environment and to elucidate the factors controlling the flux. Also of interest is the influence of surfactants controlling the CO2 flux. Several studies have strongly implicated that surfactants have a major effect on air-sea gas exchange but evidence of CO2 flux measurements simultaneously with varying surfactant concentrations on the open ocean needs to be explored. Based on previous studies it is not unreasonable to assume that gas transfer velocities could be inhibited by 50% or more by surfactants which would drastically change our estimates of equatorial CO2 outgassing. This is also the case for parameterizations with windspeed, windstress, waves and surface roughness. This effort will provide the progress in these directions.

Implementation Plan

In order to reach the overall goal, we first have to improve our understanding of the processes controlling the CO2 fluxes over short time and space scales. Once we have improved our mechanistic understanding of the processes, our ability to scale to global fluxes will be greatly improved. As outlined above, significant advances have been made over the past decade to quantitatively measure fluxes and to determine gas transfer velocities, and the factors controlling gas transfer such that meaningful advances can be made in the field. Of particular interest is the ability to relate these measurements to remotely sensed parameters for global extrapolations.

Table 1. 2001 Equatorial Pacific Air-Sea CO2 Flux Experiment Participants
  Project Affiliation Source Research Component # on Ship
1 Biological Measurements
Francisco Chavez
MBARI NOAA Primary production
New production
2
2 Surface pCO2 Variability
Mike DeGrandpre
Rik Wanninkhof
Wade McGillis
University of Montana
NOAA/AOML
WHOI
NOAA Surface CO2 and O2 variability; carbon modeling; SAMI; CARIOCA; free rising temperature profiler 2
3 Core CO2 & Hydrographic Measurements
Dick Feely
Greg Johnson
Chris Sabine
NOAA/PMEL
NOAA/PMEL
JISAO/UW
NOAA DIC; pCO2; CTD;
Overall project Coordination
5
4 Surface Films and SS Roughness
Nelson Frew
WHOI NOAA Surface films; surface roughness; LADAS; zodiac operations 8
5 Bulk Meteorology and Turbulent Fluxes
Jeff Hare
Chris Fairall
University of Colorado
NOAA/ETL
NOAA Bulk meteorology; turbulent fluxes 2

6

IR Remote Sensing
Andy Jessup
Bill Asher
University of Washington
University of Washington
NSF IR heat flux; SST; microbreaking; ship bow tower 4
7 Shipboard CO2 Fluxes
Wade McGillis
Jim Edson
WHOI
WHOI
NSF CO2 flux; atmospheric CO2 gradients; ship boom and mast 4
8 ASIS Surface Processes and CO2 Fluxes
Wade McGillis
Jim Edson
Gene Terray
Mark Donelan
Will Drennan
WHOI
WHOI
WHOI
University of Miami
University of Miami
NOAA Directional wave field; ocean surface turbulence; currents; CO2 flux; ASIS 4
9 Nutrients
Jia-Zhong Zhang
Calvin W. Mordy
NOAA/AOML
NOAA/PMEL
NOAA Nutrients and oxygen 3
10-13 Additional Measurements        

GasEx 2001 is designed to be a multi-disciplinary study focusing on enhancing our knowledge of air-sea CO2 fluxes. The primary goal is to measure air-sea CO2 fluxes, the surface physical processes, and the surface biogeochemical processes controlling CO2fluxes over short (< hour) time scales. This effort will provide necessary understanding for remote sensing and modeling efforts by understanding how gas transfer could be parameterized at small time and space scales. This avoids inherent biases that arise in the cross-correlation terms when values for k estimated from longer-time averages are compared to environmental parameters with much shorter temporal scales. Of the available techniques for measuring air-sea CO2 fluxes, atmospheric boundary layer direct CO2 flux methods (i.e., eddy direct covariance and gradient (or profile) methods) are best suited for measuring fluxes over short time scales. In these methods, the gas flux is measured directly with averaging times on the order of 0.5 hrs to 3 hrs.

The ocean-atmospheric CO2 flux is governed by surface physical processes and the air-sea pCO2 difference. In Figure 1 we represent the physical processes in the lower atmosphere and surface ocean influencing gas exchange with a schematic. There are many processes that control the exchange of gas across the aqueous mass boundary layer and these processes may interact. Figure 2 shows the interaction of the physical process controlling the gas transfer velocity and the processes controlling the air-sea concentration difference.

Table 1 shows the list of investigators proposed to participate as an interdisciplinary team to achieve the goals of this research program. A wide range of intensive measurements will be performed during the field component of this study. These measurements require the Ship Ronald H. Brown atmospheric/ocean measurement operations, the ASIS platform, the LADAS catamaran, the CARIOCA/SAMI buoy, the FSTP buoy, zodiac SMS/SPIP operations, CTD operations, and FRR/SPMR biological profiler operations. A description of each component is linked via the above Table 1.

Table 2. Division of Responsibilities
# Measurements and Analyses Responsible Parties Target Date
1 Comparison of different flux estimates McGillis, Edson, Hare, Fairall, Donelan, Drennan  
2 Determine the effect of waves, surface films, surface currents, and boundary layer stability on k Donelan, Drennan, Terray, Hare, Fairall, Frew, Jessup, Asher  
3 Parameterize gas flux with surface forcing and remote sensing products Donelan, Drennan, Terray, Frew, Jessup, Asher, Hare, Fairall, Feely  
4 Reconciliation of water column budgets with surface fluxes Feely, Chavez, Wanninkhof, DeGrandpre  
5 Maintaining the data sets Feely, McGillis, Wanninkhof  
6 Display of the results on the WWW site Feely  


Figure 3: Proposed GasEx 2001 cruise tracks.

Click on above for larger image: 201,383 kb. (1020x610 vs. above 700x420)

14. Operational Plan

The GasEx 2001 Cruise shown in Figure 3 and 4 will be conducted on the NOAA Ship Ronald H. Brown departing Panama 1/29/01, arriving Honolulu 3/8/01.

The URL for the Ron Brown is: http://www.moc.noaa.gov/rb/index.htm

PMEL will set up a website for the cruise in which the PIs will be able to obtain updates on the cruise schedule, fill out medical forms (PDF), and look for information about the layout on the ship. Dick Feely's group will be responsible for writing the cruise instructions and coordinating cruise logistics before and after the cruise. We will load the ship in Charleston, SC between the 8th and 19th of January. Each group is responsible for getting their equipment to and from the ship and will also be expected to participate in the loading and unloading process.

Shipping agent in Charleston is:
NOAA Ship RONALD H. Brown
c/o Superior Transportation
1255 Necessary Street
North Charleston, SC 29405
Office Phone: (843) 740-1840
Fax: (843) 740-1942
Contact Person: Pat Barber.

15. GasEx 2001 Program Schedule

Ship/Cruise Planning Meeting: August 8, 2000.

Equatorial Pacific Experiment: January 29, 2001 - March 08, 2001.

GasEx 2001 Preliminary Data Workshop: September 18-19, 2001.

Informal GasEx 2001 Meeting AGU: December2001/January2002.

Conference GasEx 2001 Special Session: 2002-2003.


Last updated April 18, 2001