THE SCIENCE CORNER
by Nigel Bunce and
Jim Hunt
College of Physical
Science
University of
Guelph
Thur. Apr. 19, 1984
TREE RINGS
AND VOLCANOS
Since the eruption of Mt. St. Helens
and El Chichon in Mexico in 1982, there has been a renewed interest
among scientists on a possible connection between large volcanic
eruptions and significant effects on the climate. Some volcanos
inject sufficient material into the stratosphere that the amount
of radiation received at the surface of the Earth from the Sun
is materially altered. Large volcanic explosions deposit fine
silicate ash and sulphur aerosols in the stratosphere, and these
may remain there for some time.
Models of this type of event suggest
that there would be an expansion of the region of circulating
arctic air over western North America in January and a July weather
pattern that would resemble those of a normal mid-May. One result
of such weather would be to produce frosts in the height of the
growing season in western North America.
Frost damage to mature trees is
rare but can occur during the growing season with two successive
nights at -5 C and days not above freezing. The freezing of
water outside the immature growing cells crushes them and leaves
a permanent record of frost in the tree ring for that year. In
fact, the type of damage observed in the ring is different for
the early part of the growing season and the late part. In a
given tree ring, the date of the frost can sometimes be determined
to within a week or two.
In several locations of the western
United States lives the oldest known living thing on Earth: this
is the Bristlecone pine (Pinus longaeva). In one location at
Campito Mountain in the White Mountains of California, living
trees and deadwood pieces provide an accurate year-by-year tree
ring sequence back to 3435 BC, a continuous record for five and
one-half thousand years!
V. C. LaMarche and Katherine Hirsckboeck
have recently reported, in the magazine Nature, on a study of
the frost damage in the rings of the Bristlecone pine. In the
recent tree-ring records, they find a remarkable correlation between
frost damage rings and the known date of large eruptions. For
example, in the past 100 years, there have been four climactically
important events: Krakatoa (1883), Pelee, Soufriere (1902), Katami
(1912), and Agung (1963). In each case, a ring of frost damage
was found and always in the same year if the eruption was early
in the year or, otherwise, the next year. The frost ring never
preceded the volcanic event, which seems to prove that the frost
rings are the result of the eruption.
When the tree ring record is examined
back in time, there are some interesting results. Seventeen events
are found in the rings between 2035 BC and 1884 AD. Some of these
are known from other paleontological or historical evidence.
For example, Mt. St. Helens erupted in 1500 AD and 2035 BC and
Mt. Etna in 42 BC.
Of particular interest is the explosion
of Santorini or Thera in the Agean Sea. This great explosion
has been suggested as the cause of the decline of the Cretan civilization
about 1450 BC. However, radio carbon dating of material found
on Thera has given 1688 BC within an uncertainty of 50 years.
Now the tree ring frost tells us that Santorini exploded in 1626
BC or, at most, one or two years earlier; i.e., about 275 years
before the sudden decline of Crete, which thus still remains a
mystery.