NTSB Seal/Home.News & Events.
SYMPOSIA
AGENDA, PAPERS, and PRESENTATIONS
PFD Forum logo. Personal Flotation Devices
in Recreational Boating

Forum
August 25, 2004
Ashburn, Virginia

 
9:00 - 9:30 OPENING REMARKS AND INTRODUCTIONS
Ellen Engleman Conners, Chairman
Mark V. Rosenker, Vice-Chairman - Remarks
Carol J. Carmody, Member
Richard F. Healing, Member
Deborah A. P. Hersman, Member
 
9:30 - 11:00 PANEL I: FACTS, FIGURES, AND STUDIES OF PFD USE

The purpose of this panel is to present the data and statistics describing the circumstances surrounding fatal accidents in recreational boating, the results of studies concerned with PFD use, and the policy and procedures for PFD certification.

Presentations:

Report on Personal Flotation Devices in Recreational Boating
   Capt Scott E. Evans
   United States Coast Guard, Office of Boating Safety
   Paper [PDF]
   Presentation: [ PDF | PPT ]

PFD Wear and New Technology, and PFD Approval Process
   Samuel Wehr
   United States Coast Guard, Lifesaving & Fire Safety Standards
   Presentation: [ PDF | PPT ]

Highlights from the 1998 - 2003 National PFD Wear Rate Observational Studies
   Dr. Thomas W. Mangione and Maria Rangel
   JSI Research and Training Institute, Inc.
   Paper [PDF]
   Presentation: [ PDF | PPT ]

Will it Float?
   Barbara Byers
   Canadian Safe Boating Council
   Paper [PDF]
   Presentation: [ PDF | PPT ]

Mandatory Wear of Personal Flotation Devices on Recreational Boats
   Susan Balistreri
   Balistreri Consulting, Inc.
   Paper [PDF]

 
11:00 - 11:15 BREAK
 
11:15 - 12:30 PANEL II: PUBLIC SAFETY PERSPECTIVE

The purpose of this panel is to present the State-level perspective on mandatory PFD wear requirements, the current status of PFD mandatory use requirements at the state level, what will be required to pass mandatory wear requirements and enforce them, and the issues of personal rights and freedoms.

Presentations:

A Position Paper from the National Association of State Boating Law Administrators (NASBLA)
   Fred Messman, John M. Johnson and Ed Carter
   National Association of State Boating Law Administrators
   Paper [PDF]

Personal Flotation Devices in Recreational Boating
   James P. Muldoon
   National Boating Safety Advisory Council (NBSAC)
   Paper [PDF]
   Presentation: [ PDF | PPT ]

Rethinking Mandatory PFD Wear
   William S. Griswold
   National Safe Boating Council
   Paper [PDF]

 
12:30 - 1:30 LUNCH
 
1:30 - 2:45 PANEL III: RECREATIONAL BOATER PERSPECTIVE

The purpose of this panel is to present the recreational boaters' perspective on PFD use, including discussion of the actions being taken by specific boating organizations to enhance PFD use, each organization's position on mandatory wear requirements, the potential effect of mandatory wear requirements on participant behavior, and possible alternatives to increasing PFD use.

Presentations:

Report to the National Transportation Safety Board on Mandatory Wear of Personal Flotation Devices on Recreational Boats
   Jim Ellis
   Boat Owners Association of the United States (BOAT/US)
   Paper [PDF]

The American Canoe Association Response to Mandatory Wear of PFDs on Recreational Boats
   Pamela Dillon
   American Canoe Association
   Paper [PDF]
   Presentation: [ PDF | PPT ]

PFD Usage with Personal Watercraft
   Fernando Garcia
   Personal Watercraft Industry Association
   Paper [PDF]

 
2:45 - 3:00 BREAK
 
3:00 - 4:15 PANEL IV: RECREATIONAL BOATING MANUFACTURER PERSPECTIVE

The purpose of this panel is to present the manufacturers' perspective, including current information on usage and what manufacturers are doing to enhance PFD usage, the anticipated effect on boat sales and recreational boating activity, and the current state of PFD technology.

Presentations:

PFD Technology and Wearability
   Bernice McArdle, Ralph Steger and Scott Swanby
   Personal Flotation Device Manufacturers Association
   Paper [PDF]
   Presentation: [ PDF | PPT ]

Mandatory Wear of Personal Flotation Devices on Recreational Boats
   Larry R. Innis
   Marine Retailers Association of America
   Paper [PDF]

An Assessment of Mandatory PFD Wear Requirements
   Monita W. Fontaine
   National Marine Manufacturers Association
   Paper [PDF]

NTSB Boating Accident Forum
   Charles B. Husick
   OWA, Inc.
   Paper [PDF]

 
4:15 - 4:30 CLOSING REMARKS AND ADJOURNMENT

 

NTSB Home Page | News & Events | Public Forums & Symposia | Personal Flotation Devices Forum


NTSB Home | Contact Us | Search | About the NTSB | Policies and Notices | Related Sites