-
Jack Hills Zircons: New Information About Earth's Earliest Crust
August 27, 2008 / Posted by: Daniella Scalice
Members of NAI’s University of Wisconsin, Madison team have a new paper in Earth and Planetary Science Letters presenting their analyses of 4.35 – 3.36 billion year old detrital zircons from the Jack Hills, Western Australia. Their data reveal relatively high lithium abundances compared to other zircons, as well as lithium isotope ratios that are similar to continental crust weathering products rather than ocean floor basalts. The results support the hypothesis that continental-type crust and oceans existed by 4.3 billion years ago, and suggest that weathering was extensive in the early Archean.
- NAI Launches FAR Seminar Series on October 6th
- Early Earth Primed for Later RNA and DNA Production
- Molecules in the Atmospheres of Extrasolar Planets - A Workshop in Paris
- Cyanobacterial Biomarkers in Ancient Rocks
- Evolution of the Gut
- Jill Tarter and Will Wright Talk Gaming, Education, and Evolution in Seed Magazine's Video 'Salon'
- NASA Chooses MAVEN as the Next Mars Scout Mission
- NASA's Carl Sagan Fellows to Study Extraterrestrial Worlds
- Looking for Life on Mars in a Canadian Lake
- Mars Research in Polar Bear Country
Wandering Geologist said:
I read this paper and it made no sense to me. When I asked my geochemist friends to explain what structural/chemical role lithium has in zircon, they said: “What? It doesn’t have any. It’s a contaminant.” After I pointed this paper out to them, ALL said that the study was deeply flawed.
So, what does this mean for this work? My impression is that it their lithium values don’t tell us anything about the early earth. Hey, what happened to the peer-review process on this one!??
curious said:
if lithium can move in and out of this mineral then what does it tell us about anything