King County Navigation Bar (text navigation at bottom)
Public Health - Seattle & King County
Site Directory

Public Health Webpage Directory

Public Health Center & Office Locations

For Care Providers

Health Advisories & Resources

For Educators

Health Educators Toolbox

About Us

History & Profile

Jobs

Employee Directory

Contact HIV/AIDS

Info on HIV/AIDS:

206-205-7837
TTY: 206-296-4843
Toll-free: 800-678-1595

Administration:

206-296-4649

HIV/STD Testing

HIV/STD Hotline:

206-205-7837 or
Toll-free: 800-678-1595
11:00 am to 4:00 pm
Monday - Friday for
testing information, resources and referrals

magnifying glass Advanced Search
Search Tips
Home » HIV/AIDS Program » Harm reduction and drug use » Ambivalence

HIV/AIDS Program
Ambivalence: Helping people change

Ambivalence

  • Ambivalence is normal
  • It is a "state of mind"--it is fluid
  • It is the "heart of the problem"
  • People need to be able to explore their ambivalence
  • Ambivalence is related to resistance

Assumptions about ambivalence

  • It is a personality problem
  • This person does not want to change
  • There is something wrong with this person
  • This person is in "denial" and does not see that they have a problem

"Most of us are about as eager to change as we are to be born, and go through changes in a similar state of shock."

-- James Baldwin

"Habit is habit, and not to be flung out the window by any man, but coaxed downstairs a step at a time."

-- Mark Twain

A. What is ambivalence?
1. What is motivation?
2. What do you expect to learn here?

B. Motivation
Favorite Teacher exercise: Think of a teacher or mentor from grade school or high school that motivated you. What was it about them that motivated you?

C. Exercise: Brainstorm
1. Take a couple of minutes to write down what you do or what you can do to help someone make a commitment to change.
2. (List on board)
3. Ask group to keep these in mind as we go along

D. Exercise: Used car salesperson
1. Break into pairs
2. One is a used car salesperson--other is needing to buy a car
3. Do exercise
4. Come back as group: Start with salesperson: What worked? What didn't work? Then to client: What worked for you? What didn't work?

E. Didactic - Stages of Change

F. Create conditions for change: The Process:
Recognize that ambivalence is normal
Be aware that people are in different places and any given time. They are not in "an exact stage".
Provide opportunities for clients to explore their ambivalence:
>
Listen
>
Resistance is a signal that you have to do something different.

G. Exercise: Good vs. Less good things: A Strategy
1. Break into pairs.
2. Ask client to have something they feel two ways about
3. Counselor is to ask them what they like about the situation and what they LIKE LESS about the situation.
4. Then you are to listen, reflect and eventually summarize.

Step 1: Ask open-ended question:

"What do you like about..."

"What are some of the advantages of..."

"What are some of the good things about..."

Step 2: Listen, Listen, Listen...:

*Listen without interruption

*Listen without judgement

*Be attentive, but silent

Step 3: After listening, summarize:

"So lets see if I understand you. You said that the good things are... (list them).

Step 4: Ask the reverse open-ended question:

"On the other hand, what do you dislike about..."

"What are some of the less-good things about..."

"What are some of the disadvantages of..."

Step 5: Listen, Listen, Listen...:

*Listen without interruption

*Listen without judgement

*Be attentive, but silent

Step 6: After listening, summarize both sides of the ambivalence. Start with the reasons for not changing, followed by reasons for changing:

"So some of the good things are...(list them)

"On the other hand, the less good things are...(list them)."

"Some of the advantages are (list)...The disadvantages are...(list).

Step 7: Ask if you "got it all"

Step 8: Ask about the next step:

"Where does that leave you now?"

"Where does ______fit into your future?"

"Where would you like to see yourself go from here?"

H. Exercise: The Ruler
1. Ask the client to choose a number between 0 and 12 which indicates how "ready" they are to consider________.
2. Explore why they chose that number. (read exercise)

Ask client to answer the following:

"On a scale from 0 to 12, how ready are you to consider______?"

("to consider" can mean many things. It can mean considering stopping use of a substance; consider using condoms, considering getting a job etc.)

gray bullet You can also use a ruler, if available and it "fits" for your client and situation.
gray bullet Encourage elaboration: "Why a (6, 4, 10, etc.) (LISTEN!)
gray bullet Ask strategic open-ended "scaling" questions to encourage "change talk"
gray bullet Backwards questions: "Why did you pick a 4 and not a 1?"
gray bullet Forwards question: "What would it take for you to move from a 6 to an 8?"
gray bullet Future questions: "Lets suppose you were an 11 sometime in the future. Why might you be interested in _______?" "How do you think your life would be different if you were an 8 instead of a 3?"
gray bullet Summarize
gray bullet Ask if you "got it all"
gray bullet End encounter by asking: "Where does this leave you now?"
I. Exercise: Giving Advice
gray bullet Ask them if they would like to hear about things that have worked for others. Always ASK if they want to hear what you have to say.
gray bullet List them...as many options as possible
gray bullet Ask them if any of these are things they could or would be willing to try. Which ones: Always provide choices

Exercise:
gray bullet Break down into pairs
gray bullet Demonstrate: How to give information that is not pushing, threatening
For example: One person is not eating well and is quite overweight. The other is a health worker who provides education and information on how to reduce risk, lose weight etc.

Updated: Tuesday, July 25, 2006 at 02:23 PM

All information is general in nature and is not intended to be used as a substitute for appropriate professional advice. For more information please call (206) 296-4600 (voice) or TTY: 206-296-4843. Mailing address: ATTN: Communications Team, Public Health - Seattle & King County, 401 5th Ave., Suite 1300, Seattle, WA 98104 or click here to email us.

King County | News | Services | Comments | Search

Links to external sites do not constitute endorsements by King County.
By visiting this and other King County web pages, you expressly agree to be bound by terms
and conditions of the site. The details.