King County Navigation Bar (text navigation at bottom)
Public Health - Seattle & King County
Site Directory

Public Health Webpage Directory

Public Health Center & Office Locations

For Care Providers

Health Advisories & Resources

For Educators

Health Educators Toolbox

About Us

History & Profile

Jobs

Employee Directory

Contact Us

Public Health
Seattle & King County
401 5th Ave., Suite 1300
Seattle, WA 98104

Click here to email us

Phone: 206-296-4600
TTY Relay: 711

magnifying glass Advanced Search
Search Tips
Home » Family Planning » Managing controversy in sexuality education

Family Planning Program
Managing controversy in sexuality education

green square bullet
Rules for preventing controversy
green square bullet
Remember why you do this work
green square bullet Tips for working with a concerned supervisor
green square bullet
Tips for working with concerned parents

Rules for preventing controversy


A.
Learn law and policy and follow them:

Begin by finding out your own state's relevant laws (for Washington's laws, click here).

Then, call your district's administration office and ask for copies of its policies and procedures (written and unwritten) regarding:  

  • controversial issues and answering students' questions (Are there topics you wouldn't be allowed to address, even in response to a question?),
  • the teaching of abstinence (Is there particular wording you are obligated to use? A philosophy you are expected to convey?)
  • guest speakers (Is there a preferred or approved list of presenters you may call upon? Is there a procedure for having someone approved?)
  • the reporting of child abuse (Who must you inform –- in addition to CPS -- when a child self discloses or when you have reasonable cause to believe a child is being abused?)
  • parent preview/notification/permission for sexuality education (Are you responsible for making these arrangements or is it done on a building or district level? Must you have positive permission from parents, or is it considered sufficient to allow parents to excuse their children?),
  • explaining/showing condoms and other birth control methods (Is it permissible to show your class each method or just a photo or drawing of it? Does your district frown on the use of fruits and vegetables in demonstrations of condoms? Are you permitted to have your students practice the skill of proper condom use on their fingers?)
  • making referrals for health and social services (Is there a pre-approved list of community resources to which you may refer students? Is there a procedure for approving new resources?)
  • teaching in single gender or co-ed groups (Does your district have a preference or is it a building-level, or classroom-level decision?)
  • curriculum and supplementary written and aydui-visual resources (Which curricula and videos are approved? Is it permissible to supplement them with newspaper and magazine stories and television clips? Is there a procedure for approving new resources?). 

Suppose the policies are, in your opinion, not in the best interest of your students. It is perfectly permissible to lobby the administration and the board to change the policies. It is also permissible  to poll your students' parents and to encourage them to express their opinions to the administration and the board.

It is dangerous and unprofessional to defy the policies. Don't. Any short-term benefit to your students would be totally outweighed by your being sanctioned, so that you couldn't teach sexuality in the future.

B. Be transparent:

As long as you have followed Rule A, you have nothing to hide.

Start by sharing with your principal the district's sexuality curriculum and any supplementary materials you anticipate using. Take a few minutes to explain to him or her your goals and objectives, your philosophy, and the way in which you plan to address values.

Next, inform parents that your unit is coming up. This can be done, in some districts, as an ordinary part of back-to-school night in the fall. Or, in other districts, requires specific notification by mail. In Washington State, whatever system is used, parents are entitled to at least a 30 days' notice, at least for the HIV/AIDS sessions, and a chance to preview the materials.

However you inform them, invite parents to talk with you about any concerns they may have. You are legally entitled to decline their observing (because parents' presence on such a sensitive topic can clearly "disrupt the...learning activity") but we don't recommend turning parents away. Allowing parents to visit is the most straightforward way to say, "I have nothing to hide." And it almost inevitably allays their fears, especially once they see your climate-setting lesson. That's the lesson in which you establish such things as the purpose and agenda of your unit, ground rules, and a tone of seriousness and honesty.

Finally, never, never, never, tell students not to tell their families what you have said. If you wouldn't want parents to hear it, don't say it in the first place. One way to remind yourself of this caveat is to always imagine an invisible parent or principal in the back of the room. No secrets!

C. Shock your students the right way:

So, you want to shock them into paying attention and behaving with uncharacteristic maturity? That's fine, but do it the right way. Do it by showing them more respect than they are used to at school.

Shock them by using sophisticated medical language they don't yet understand and promising that you'll translate as you go, so that, by the end of the unit they will be conversant in it. Do it by admitting to the lousy things our generation has done to theirs, such as trying to sell them cosmetics and body-fixing products they don't need, in order to make a buck. Do it by admitting that the same self-destructive decision-making folks often accuse adolescents of engaging in also plagues an awful lot of adults. Do it by having high academic expectations and avoiding "busy-work."

Don't shock your students by making crude jokes at the expense of some group of people (women, gays, teens, men, etc.). Don't shock them by using slang yourself, except when you read a question verbatim or translate from the familiar to the unfamiliar. And then, do it with a serious facial expression, not a smirk. Don't shock them by suddenly changing the standards from academic to recreational. Those tactics are counterproductive.

D. Handle controversial issues professionally:

Some controversial issues are essential components of sexuality education. You would have to do a really skeletal, inadequate and unprofessional job to avoid those issues. But how you address them will make all the difference in whether you help families communicate and support students? character development. We recommend using the Values Question Protocol from the Family Life And Sexual Health curriculum.

E. Maintain records:

It is even more important to keep lesson plans when you are teaching about sexual health than when you are teaching other topics. If you invite guest speakers, take notes on their presentations. If you have students generate written questions, hang on to them for a couple of months, in case you need to document that a particular conversation was student-initiated, not your personal "agenda." If you can arrange the luxury of a team teaching situation, that's not only preferable in terms of enhancing student learning, but it also provides another pair of ears, protecting you from students? misinterpretations of what you may have said.

Remember why you do this work

Do all these things to prevent controversy, but don't be paranoid. Your important work will speak for itself. Your students? beginning to treat one another with more consideration will speak for itself. Their families? increasing conversations about sexuality will speak for themselves, as will the increased knowldege and skills and the decreased anxiety about talking with health care providers and future partners.  If you are teaching sexuality in a professional, respectful way, the maintenance records will probably be a never-needed safety net. 

Always remember why you do this work. Maybe it's for some of these reasons: 

  • so your students will approach puberty with excitement rather than dread 
  • so they will appreciate their bodies and not engage in dangerous weight-management and cosmetic regimes
  • so they will be able to make and keep friends and communicate their needs and boundaries assertively 
  • so those who have been sexually abused will feel less alone, less to blame, and more inclined to report their abuse 
  • so your students will treat one another respectfully, regardless of their genders, sexual orientations, or any other personal characteristics? In class, between classes or on the playground, and when they date one another 
  • so your students will know how to reduce their risks of STDs (including HIV), unintended pregnancy, birth defects, infertility, dysfunction and other sexuality-related difficulties 
  • so they will recognize the symptoms and be inclined to seek health care for these kinds of difficulties 
  • so they will perform self breast- and testicular exams and seek routine preventive health care 
  • so they will know where to find accurate information about sexual health as they grow and change throughout their lives.

Tips for working with a concerned supervisor

Keep your supervisor informed. This includes forewarning him/her about your sexuality unit, letting him/her know when you have guest speakers coming (not just regarding sexuality, but all topics), and stopping by to update him/her when unanticipated, potentially controversial things come up in class. 

Listen. Ask your supervisor to explain his or her concerns. Consider finding compromises when you disagree, so that you can teach in ways that are in your students? best interest and still meet your supervisor's needs.

Do your homework. Know your district's policies and procedures; if you are new in a district, you may have to seek out experienced sexuality educators  with whom to consult.  Back up your requests to your supervisor with explanations of how these plans will (a) fall within those policies and (b) satisfy broader essential learning requirements (in reading, for instance, or oral communication).

Invite your supervisor to observe. Remember that observation is not only for the purpose of evaluation -- which may have a bad connotation for you. It is also a way to give him/her firsthand knowledge to support you if a concerned parent every goes directly to your supervisor.

Tips for working with concerned parents

Keep parents informed. We recommend using "family homework exercises" as the Family Life And Sexual Health Curriculum, F.L.A.S.H., does. They help parents and guardians to know what you are doing in class from day to day, and they foster communication within families.

Ask the parent to explain his or her concerns. Listen. Acknowledge his or her caring for the child and express your own caring. Explain your philosophy and attitude toward teaching sexuality and don't get defensive about your decisions.

Never claim that you do not teach values. This is not true. You do try to teach that it is wrong to exploit another person, that it is good to communicate assertively, etc. These are surely values. Besides, claiming not to teach any values -- even these non-controversial ones -- will alienate as many parents as it calms. It is better to think about, and explain, the values you do try to teach and to discuss how you will handle those that are controversial. Assure the parent or guardian, for instance, that you will not take sides with one family over another on controversial issues. Explain that you will try to make sure all points of view are described evenhandedly and with respect. Make clear -- if it is true -- that, on controversial issues, you try never to express your own opinion. Assure the parent that you refer children home to discuss controversial issues. 

Remember that a parent or guardian always has the legal right to excuse the child from planned sexuality lessons, although he or she has no right to restrict what other people's children are allowed to learn. Encourage the parent not to decide, however, without observing a lesson first. As we said above, it often allays a parent's or guardian's fears to see your relationship with the class and the professionalism with which you approach the unit.

If the parent does decide to excuse the child, make sure which lessons are intended; it is often not necessary for the child to miss the whole unit. And reassure the parent that you will do your best to be discreet about the child's absence from the classroom and that you will treat the child's leaving matter-of-factly and with respect. Offer to send home "family homework exercises" and other classwork from the unit with the parent, so that they can work on some or all of the unit at home together if they wish.

related sites

Youth Health ServicesYouth Health Services Youth Health Services works to ensure high-quality, coordinated, and comprehensive health services are available to youth and young adults throughout King County.

Health Providers homepage
Health provider and patient
Information for King County health providers including reportable disease conditions and latest case updates for selected diseases.

Health Educators homepage
Health educator
Information for health providers including continuing education, downloadable materials, posters, and more.

Updated: Friday, August 11, 2006 at 10:03 AM

All information is general in nature and is not intended to be used as a substitute for appropriate professional advice. For more information please call (206) 296-4600 (voice) or TTY Relay: 711. Mailing address: ATTN: Communications Team, Public Health - Seattle & King County, 401 5th Ave., Suite 1300, Seattle, WA 98104 or click here to email us.

King County | News | Services | Comments | Search

Links to external sites do not constitute endorsements by King County.
By visiting this and other King County web pages, you expressly agree to be bound by terms
and conditions of the site. The details.