FDIC Home - Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
FDIC Home - Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation

 
Skip Site Summary Navigation   Home     Deposit Insurance     Consumer Protection     Industry Analysis     Regulations & Examinations     Asset Sales     News & Events     About FDIC  


Home > Industry Analysis > Bank Data & Statistics > Bank Rating Services




Bank Rating Services
The FDIC never releases its ratings on the safety and soundness of banks and thrift institutions to the public.

However, there are private companies that provide their own ratings of these institutions.

As a service to consumers, the staff of the FDIC Library has compiled a listing of several financial institution rating services.

Disclaimer:   This list should not be construed as an endorsement or confirmation by the FDIC of information provided by these companies.

Services

The bank rating services listed alphabetically below offer a variety of online, web-based, paper and CD-ROM based services that cover banks, bank holding companies, savings and loans and savings banks.

  • These services usually assign each institution a letter grade or numerical ranking which is meant to indicate the safety or soundness of the institution.
  • These rankings are determined through the use of proprietary formulas that are applied to data collected by the bank and thrift regulatory agencies. These formulas vary from service to service.
  • Most of the formulas use data based upon some variation of CAMELS rating factors – Capital, Asset quality, Management, Earnings, Liquidity and Sensitivity to market risk.
  • DeNovo institutions have unique characteristics that ratings formulas may not fully recognize.

Most of the rating services offer subscriptions to specific print and online publications. Several offer ratings over the telephone.

Please contact the companies listed to obtain further information about the full range of services and products offered.

  •  
A.M. Best Company
Website: http://www3.ambest.com/banks/default.asp
Oldwick, New Jersey 08858-0700
Phone: (908) 439-2200 x5633
Fax: (908) 439-2237
e-mail: banking.analysis@ambest.com

Product:

  1. Best’s Bank Deposit Rating (BDR) is an assessment of the operating bank’s ability to honor its ongoing obligations to depositors
     
  2. Best’s Issuer Credit Rating (ICR) is an assessment of the bank’s ability to honor its ongoing senior-most obligations.
     
  3. Best’s Bank Debt Rating is an assessment of the issuer’s ability to meet its ongoing financial obligations to security holders when due.

    Ratings on a scale from ‘aaa’ being the strongest to ‘d’ being the weakest, and may be enhanced with a ‘+’ or ‘-‘ to indicate whether credit quality is near the top or bottom of a category.

Institutions rated:

 U.S. banks and bank holding companies.

Rating method:

Primary Rating Principles:
  1. Quantitative as well as qualitative assessments of banking operations incorporating management meetings and discussions with the rated institution.
     
  2. Industry peer comparison.
     
  3. Long-term focus through industry cycles.
     
  4. Rating profile determined by both current and stressed conditions.
     
  5. Consideration of impacts of affiliates and parent companies within the group.
Key Rating Considerations:
  1. Long-term core earnings capability:
    • Historical earnings from core operations.
    • Development of additional viable business lines for future earnings generation.
       
  2. Business profile:
    • Franchise strength (brand recognition, defensible market leadership, niche stronghold, long-term client base).
    • Competitive dynamics within pertinent markets.
    • Profitability, stability and growth potential of primary lines of business.
    • Diversified mix of assets and revenue sources (interest vs. fee income).
       
  3. Balance sheet strength:
    • Liquidity profile (adequacy of funding to support existing business/future growth as well as diversification of short-/long-term sources of funding).
    • Core capitalization (quality/adequacy in providing protection and capital requirements for existing business/future growth).
    • Capital structure and financial flexibility (degree of leverage and short-/long-term access to various sources of financing).
    • Asset quality (reviewed against de facto measures of credit loss statistics/risk concentration, as well as on credit risk management and administration).
       
  4. Risk management:
    • Measurement and management of risk factors: interest rate, market, liquidity, currency, operational and other risks.
    • Organization and control systems.
    • Integrity of data and modeling techniques.
    • Back-end validation testing.
       
  5. Other factors:
    • Regulatory structure.
    • Management and corporate governance.
    • Parent company and affiliated operations.

Cost:

Bank Credit Reports are available to the public at a cost of $75.00 for each company report. (Separately, banks that are rated by A.M. Best are charged a rating fee, based on asset size and other criteria.)
 
For further information regarding A.M. Best Ratings, visit A.M. Best’s website at: www.ambest.com.
 
  •  
Bankrate, Inc.
Website: http://www.bankrate.com/
11760 US Highway One
North Palm Beach, FL 33408
(561) 630-2400
e-mail: customerservice@bankrate.com
 
  Product: Bankrate.com's Safe & Sound® service measures and rates the strength of financial institutions. Safe & Sound is a proprietary, analytical product that assesses the financial condition of 17,000 banks, thrifts and credit unions. Bankrate.com evaluates the health of institutions and assigns a 1-to-5 rating, with five stars representing the highest rating. Institutions with satisfactory performance will generally receive a rating of three or better stars, with the majority of banks falling into the three- to four-star range. The Bankrate.com Safe & Sound rating feature provides comprehensive information to depositors, borrowers, creditors, industry professionals, and regulators needing information regarding financial conditions of banks, thrifts and credit unions. The Star Rating, CAEL Rating, and Memorandum, detailing an institution's financial standing, are all FREE and available on our website at: http://www.bankrate.com/brm/safesound/ss_home.asp
 
  Institutions Rated: All U.S. Federally Insured Banks, Thrifts, and Credit Unions.
  Primary Rating Method: Bankrate.com's Safe & Sound considers four components, represented by CAEL® (Capitalization, Asset quality, Earnings and Liquidity). Using publicly available, quarterly data from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., Office of Thrift Supervision and the National Credit Union Administration, our systems assign values to each of the Safe & Sound CAEL categories and calculate composite ratings for individual institutions. The Safe & Sound CAEL ratings listed here should not be confused with ratings used by the FDIC or any other third party.
  Other Contents: Financial Summaries for each institution listed
  •  
BauerFinancial, Inc.  
Website: http://www.bauerfinancial.com/
P.O. Box 143520
Penthouse 1-A, Gables International Plaza
2655 LeJeune Road
Coral Gables, Florida 33134
Phone: (800) 388-6686
Fax: (800) 230-9569
e-mail: customerservice@bauerfinancial.com
  Product:

All U.S. banks and federally insured credit unions are rated by BauerFinancial Inc. No bank pays for this service, nor can they elect to avoid it. BauerFinancial is an unbiased third party that has been rating banks from a depositor’s perspective since 1983.


Ratings on website: visit www.bauerfinancial.com to look up the ratings of all U.S. banks or credit unions: unlimited number, FREE.


Ratings by phone: Verbal ratings are offered by a live customer service representative for a nominal fee: $4 for the first one, $2 each additional on the same phone call, 9-5 eastern time.

 
The nation’s top consumer and corporate CD rates, as surveyed by BauerFinancial each week, are available on our website at no charge.

  Institutions rated:  All federally-insured banks and credit unions
  Rating method: Ratings are based on a 5-star scale (5-stars being the highest and 0-stars the lowest)
  Other contents:
  1. One page Highlights Report with 5 quarters of financial highlights on a specific institution ($10 for the first report, $4 for each additional report)
  2. One page Summary Report (Highlights Report plus additional data on delinquencies and profitability) on a specific institution ($20)
  3. Your Hometown Bank Ratings allows the consumer to define a city(s) or county(s) and receive a comprehensive list of all the banks in the defined area including: each branch address, the current star-rating, year established, website, telephone number and the number of branches nationwide. ($28/city, $38/county, $10 for each adjacent city or county)
  4. Six page Analytical Report that includes peer group comparisons on a specific institution ($40)
  5. Statewide Bank Report ($55) – Star ratings and financial highlights for all banks operating in any given state
  6. Troubled and Problematic Bank Report ($99) – All U.S. banks rated 2-stars or below by BauerFinancial
  7. Recommended Bank Report ($195) – All U.S. banks and thrifts rated 5-stars or 4-stars by BauerFinancial
  8. Jumbo Rate News – Weekly Newsletter tracking the national Jumbo CD market (available: weekly, monthly, customized and on request) – Visit website for a downloadable single issue and for prices: www.jumboratenews.com.
  9. Customized Data: BauerFinancial has an extensive database and can customize reports, lists, spreadsheets, mailing lists or files based on any number of criteria. Simply call our research department at 1.800.388.6686 and explain what you are looking for. Not only will you get exactly what you need, you will find our prices to be very competitive.
  •  

Creative Investment Research, Inc.
Website: http://www.creativeinvest.com/
P.O. Box 55793
Washington, DC 20040-5793
Phone: (866) 867-3795
Fax: (866) 867-3795
e-mail: info@creativeinvest.com

  Product: Minority Bank Monitor. Comprehensive data on women and minority-owned financial institutions. By Group: Asian, African-American, Hispanic, Native American, Women. Financial Information: Assets, Net Income, Total Loans, Real Estate Loans, C&I Loans, Return on Assets. Maps showing institution location. Total population in county. Minority population in county. County Income per capita. Number of banks and thrifts in county. Institution-level data for each bank and thrift. Management Information: President, Cashier, Operations Officer, Community Reinvestment Act data: CRA Rating, CRA Rating Date and other data. In all, over 300 pages. Report on all Women and Minority owned banks, savings banks & thrifts in the United States. $995.00

  Institutions rated: Banks and thrifts owned by women and minorities.
  Rating method: Fully adjusted return. Methodology combining financial and social data. Ratings are based on a 300-point scale (300-points being the highest and 0-points the lowest)
  Other contents:
  1. Minority Financial Institutions. Brokerage firms, banks, thrifts, community development financial institutions, money management firms, venture capital firms, insurance companies, mutual fund companies, and mortgage banking firms owned by minorities and women. Comprehensive data by Group: Asian, African-American, Hispanic, Native American, Women. Institution-level data. Management Information - President, Cashier, Operations Officer and other data. $ 2,500.00
     

  2. Minority Business Financing. Strategies for financing a woman or minority business. $1,250.00.
  •  
FIS - Financial Information Systems, LLC
Website: www.FEDFIS.com
250 West Southlake Blvd
Suite 204
Southlake, Texas 76092
Phone 512-858-0164 or 877-410-2424
Email www.info@fedfis.com
 
Product:
FIS enables research intensive financial services companies to analyze: Banks, Thrifts, Holding Companies, and Credit Unions. 40 consecutive quarters of historical Call Report data delivered in a Full Featured Online system. FIS also has specialty databases for Branches and Mergers & Acquisitions. Combined with the FIS ratings, it is the premier analytical tool on the market today.
 
 
Institutions Rated:
US Banks, Thrifts, Credit Unions, and Bank Holding Companies.
 
 
Primary Rating Method:
The bank ratings will include Liquidity, Asset Quality, Capital adequacy, and Earnings. The overall rating will be determined by weighting the individual ratings. The FIS ratings system is based on a combination of safety and performance factors. The best score that can be achieved is 1 and the worst score that can be achieved is 5.

Bank, thrift, and credit union ratings are weighted as follows: 10% from liquidity and 30% each from asset quality, capital adequacy, and earnings.

Holding company ratings are weighted as follows: 30% each from asset quality and capital adequacy and 40% from earnings.
 
 
Cost:
Free Rating Reports delivered by email.
 
  •  
Highline Financial LLC
Website: http://www.highlineinet.com
807 Las Cimas, Suite 320
Austin, Texas 78746
Phone: (877) 305-6656
Fax: (512) 314-7222
Email: BankSales@HighlineInet.com
 
Product:
The Bank and Savings and Loan Quarterly
Frequency & cost: Updated quarterly ($695/year)
Institutions rated: All FDIC-insured commercial banks, savings banks and savings & loans
 
Rating method: Rates banks on a scale of 99 (best) to 0. Ratings are based on financial statistics and comparisons to peer institutions.
 
Other contents:
Summary for each bank and thrift showing loan exposure in construction, commercial real estate, consumer, and agricultural loans; financial ratios; percentile rankings on key ratios comparing each bank to peer institutions; national and state averages; state and regional trends and maps; lists of largest banks by category.
 
Other products:
  1. Online Bank Rating Report http://www.bankreport.highlineinet.com ($70/quarter,$195/yr) Detailed report for a single institution displaying all factors affecting the institutions rating.
     
  2. Banking Organization Quarterly http://www.highlineinet.com/prodservices/boqbk.html ($300/quarter,$630/yr) Organizational Rating and individual ratings for each institution in an organization for the entire industry.
     
  3. Bank or S&L Report http://www.bankreport.highlineinet.com ($175/quarter,$580/yr) Detailed performance information and peer group comparisons on one institution.
  •  

IDC Financial Publishing  
Website: http://www.idcfp.com
P.O. Box 140
700 Walnut Ridge Drive
Suite 201
Hartland, Wisconsin, 53029
Phone: (800) 525-5457
Fax: (262) 367-6497
email: idcfp@execpc.com

  Product: Bank Financial Quarterly
  Frequency & cost: Updated quarterly ($475)
  Institutions rated: All FDIC-insured commercial banks and U.S. bank holding companies
  Rating method: Rates institutions on a scale of 300 (best) to 1, based on financial statistics, CAMEL factors, and ratios.
  Other contents: IDC calculates over 35 key financial ratios and provides a one number summary rating. Reports also include one line summaries of financial statistics and ratios for each institution; peer group distributions; special lists including banks and bank holding companies (BHCs) with high loan delinquency by type, largest lower ranked BHCs, largest higher ranked BHCs, banks and BHCs with large investment portfolios, and banks and BHCs with large non-interest income.
  Product: S&L - Savings Bank Financial Quarterly
  Frequency & cost: Updated quarterly ($475)
  Institutions rated: Thrifts reporting to the Office of Thrift Supervision and savings banks reporting to the FDIC
  Rating method: See above
  Other contents: One line summary of financial statistics and ratios for each institution; peer group distributions; state totals; special lists of institutions with delinquent loans and nonperforming assets.
 
  •  
Institutional Risk Analytics
Website: http://www.institutionalriskanalytics.com
14352 Yukon Avenue
Hawthorne, California 90250
Phone: (310) 676-3300
Fax: (310) 943-1570
e-mail: info@institutionalriskanalytics.com
 

Product:   

IRA Bank Monitor is granular performance and risk model covering all FDIC insured depository institutions and holding companies. We deliver distilled analytics for use in counterparty, insurance, acquisition and other “safety and soundness” business applications. Specific warnings are generated for instances where bank business practices generate potential “moral hazard” conditions with respect to regulatory policies.
 
 

Rating Method:   

 

IRA generates detailed metrics designed to illustrate bank business performance and test safety and soundness practices. IRA generates proprietary Basel II Benchmarks for P(d), LGD, EAM and EAD. We also generate risk management estimates for Economic Capital and RAROC. IRA tests are uniformly computed across the entire bank universe and are particularly useful for comparison testing.
 
 

Coverage:   

 

All U.S. federally-insured banks, thrifts and credit unions. Results displayed for both the subsidiary banks and “bank only” holding company roll-up. Time period coverage is quarterly beginning in 1995 plus year end annual data back to 1989.
  Subscription:  Unlimited internal use subscriptions to the IRA Bank Monitor start at $30,000 per user per year. Subscribers have full access a web based research terminal application that delivers a range of summary reports, multi-period data matrices and graphs. The system supports Excel downloading for exporting data to desktop applications. Subscribers also have access to data mining tools that perform algorithmic test battery screening and peer comparison analytics.
 

Shopping Cart:    

Individual reports on bank units and holding companies are also available from IRA’s online shopping cart system.
  • A single unit quarterly summary report is $50 per institution certificate (CERT).
     
  • A holding company roll-up quarterly summary report is $80 per holding company record (HCR).
     
  • An XML (MSFT SpreadsheetML format) download of analysis metrics for a ten (10) quarter look back period is $250 per CERT and $275 per HCR.

Cart users may purchase reports online and remit funds using common internet payment methods such as PayPal and/or credit cards
 .

  •  
LACE Financial Corp.  
Website: http://www.lacefinancial.com/
118 North Court Street
Frederick, Maryland, 21701
Phone: (301) 662-1011
Fax: (301) 662-1458

  Product: Quarterly Financial Institutions Rating Service (QFIRS)
  Frequency & cost: Updated quarterly ($595.95)
  Institutions rated: Commercial and state-chartered savings banks, savings and loans, credit unions, and the 100 largest bank holding companies in the U.S. (approximately 18,000 institutions).
  Rating method: Institutions are assigned ratings from A+ (best) to E, based on ratios representing liquidity, asset quality, capital, and earnings.
  Other contents:
  • Bankmonitor.net - An Online Inquiry System for Financial Institutions 
  • U.S. Corporate Bank Ratings (All regulated Banks and Savings Banks in one volume)
  • LACE International Bank Ratings
  • LACE Savings & Loan Ratings
  • Bank Holding Company Ratings
  • Credit Unions (All CU’s on CD. 2,500 Largest in print version)
  • Bank Alert Service – E-mail Releases and Bank Customer Letter.
  • Watch List (banks with relatively poor financial conditions)
  • New Issue Ratings for Securities
  •  

Veribanc 
Website: http://www.veribanc.com
P.O. Box 1610
One Social Street
Woonsocket, Rhode Island 02895
Phone: (800) 837-4226
email: service@veribanc.com

  Product: Plain English Reports - since 1981. Instant Ratings by phone, ($10 for the first rating, $5 for each additional one) followed up with written confirmation. No bank pays us ("Sponsored Bank") to rate them.
  Institutions rated: All U.S. Federally Insured Banks, Savings Banks, Savings and Loans, and Credit Unions
  Frequency & cost: Ratings are updated MONTHLY (No additional charge).
  Rating method: Ratings consist of a green, yellow, or red code and three (high) to zero stars. Blue Ribbon (Oldest National Accolade Presented to Banks) represents a special commendation for excellence. Ratings are based on ACTUARIAL STUDIES of 100s of bank failures - NOT peer group comparisons. Please visit our web site for both our METHODOLOGY and TRACK RECORD.
  Other products: Ratings by phone with in-depth follow up known as VERIFAX (Bank's Only) are available for $57.50. Other products available are:
  1. Short Form Report ($25) Overview of an institution or bank holding company designed for people without a financial background.
     
  2. Blue Ribbon Bank Report ($35) Highest rated banks in a selected region.
     
  3. Bank, S&L, or Credit Union Research Reports ($45) - In depth report designed for investors.
     
  4. Holding Company Research Report ($95) - In-depth report which contains a breakout of data and ratings for each of the commercial bank members of a bank holding company.
     
  5. Bank and Thrift State Ratings Report ($110) Key financial measures and ratings for all banks and S&Ls in a state.
     
  6. Watchlist Report ($110) Tracks any 50 institutions selected.
  •  
Weiss Ratings Inc.  
Website: http://www.weissratings.com
4176 Burns Road
Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33410
Phone: (800) 289-9222
Fax: (561) 625-6685

  Product: Guide to Banks and Thrifts
  Frequency & cost: Updated quarterly ($219 for single quarter, $438, full year)
  Institutions rated: Financial safety ratings on over 11,100 US banks and thrifts.
  Rating method: Rates institutions on a scale of A+ (Excellent) to E -(Very Weak)
  Other contents: Provides a summary analysis for all institutions and identifies the safest institutions within each state.
  Other products:
  1. Ratings Online ($7.95) Billed to a credit card
     
  2. Verbal ratings ($15) Available via telephone
     
  3. Watchdog service ($48) Provides immediate notification of a ratings change, plus a quarterly ratings affirmation notice.
     
  4. Personal Safety Report ($45) 12 page detailed analysis of an individual bank or thrift.
     
  5. Consumer Safety Update ($25) Summary report covering a company's rating and factors contributing to the rating.
     
  6. Weiss Recommend Companies ($55) Lists those companies receiving the highest Weiss Safety Rating.

Last Updated 08/15/2008 library@fdic.gov

Home    Contact Us    Search    Help    SiteMap    Forms
Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Service Center    Website Policies    USA.gov
FDIC Office of Inspector General