ORI Logo ORI Logo Promoting Integrity in Research
Individual | Institutional
 
Home About ORI Privacy FOIA Sitemap Contact ORI
. Search ORI
.
.
.
. Sections
.
.
.Assurance
.Conferences
.Handling Misconduct
.International
.Policies / Regulations
.Publications
.RCR Education
.Research
.RIOs

.
. Newsletter
.
.
Latest Newsletter (PDF)
June 2008


Past Issues...

.
.
. Annual Report
.
.
ORI Annual Report 2007
PDF format

Annual Report
Past Reports...

.
. Graduate RCR
.
.
Graduate Education for RCR
Annual Report
New CGS publication identifies best practices in RCR
.

 
 

 
.
. Forensic Tools Menu
.
.
. Introduction
. Forensic Tools
  . Droplets
  . Actions
  . Samples
  . Help

.
.

Tools - Data Imaging

ORI "Forensic Images Samples" for the quick examination of scientific images.
SAMPLES Some Important Principles to Remember:
  • Forensically, you can only "de-authenticate" an image (i.e., show that it has discrepancies).

  • Authentication of a scientific image requires access to the original data.

  • The identification of a discrepancy is only the allegation, and it does not by itself demonstrate an intentional falsification of data.

  • The interpretation as to whether any image manipulation is serious requires familiarity with the experiment(s) and imaging instruments.

  • Each Forensic Droplet or Forensic Action represents only a ‘‘first order' examination. They are not full-proof, but use of another may reveal something not shown by the first.

  • The quality of the results depends on the resolution of the image, and the degree to which it has (not) been compressed, a process that can add artifactual "blocks" to otherwise continuous features. (See Test Pattern)


Falsified Images from Closed ORI Cases

To save images to your computer:

1. Click thumbnail to load larger image.

2. Right click on larger image.

3. Select Save Picture As... option.

» Background - (Photograph)

- How can you show that three lanes are the same data?

 

Click for larger image.

 

» Band Detail - (Photograph)

- What evidence proves the 67 kDa band is the same data as the 32 kDa band?

 

Click for larger image.

 

» Background - Western

- Which data have been fabricated - and how?

- Hint, look at what's missing.

 

Click for larger image.

 

» Band Detail - JBC 2B

- Do some bands look strange?

- Are some the same?

 

Click for larger image.

 

» Dark Areas -Grant Figure

- Can you see what's really there?

 

Click for larger image.

 

» Overlap Fig A vs Fig B

- Are these images from the same section?

Fig A

Click for larger image.

 

Fig B

Click for larger image.

 

» PowerPoint Slide vs "Data"

- How are these "Southern blots" the same?

- How do they differ?

 

Slide

Click for larger image.

 

 

"Data"

Click for larger image.

 

» Erasures - Film

- What evidence indicates that this "mouse" had feathers?

- Hint, first separating by hue will improve quality of the enhanced results.

 

Click for larger image.

 

Forensic-Test Patterns

Test images with defined features are of use when trying a new processing routine, to explore whether the absence or presence of a feature (i.e., a false negative or a false positive) is not a possible artifact introduced by the routine, by the printer, or by photocopying.

The following are some trial versions.

» Radial Resolution & Aliasing Image

 

Click for larger image.

» Weak Background: Duplicated & Copied Regions with Edges

- Can you find the copied regions?

 

 

Click for larger image.

 

» Areas of Strong & Weak Contrast

 

 

Click for larger image.

 







 
.
This page last was updated on July 29, 2008
.
Legal Disclaimer / Accessibility

Adobe Reader icon
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
Office of Research Integrity • 1101 Wootton Parkway • Suite 750 • Rockville, MD 20852
  Directions to ORI Office
Questions/suggestions about this web page? Contact ORI
. .