Underdog Anti-Frackers Struggle for Denton's Vote, But Fight Could Swing Either Way

VotingUS.jpg
Tom Arthur
Dentonites are turning out more than ever for early voting, many in response to the proposition to ban fracking in the city.

As early voting wraps up this week, Denton County has seen a surge in voters, as well as campaign spending. Much of that has to do with the fracking debate, which has also incurred more spending than any other campaign in Denton's history.

See also: Frackers Have Launched an Aggressive Campaign to Kill Denton's Drilling Ban

"It's pretty fair to assume that given how much money is poured into this, that's why so many people are out," says Dr. Adam Briggle, a leader with Frack Free Denton and a bioethics professor at UNT. "Everything now is focused on communicating with voters, especially at the polls, and making sure that they're not confused when they're going in to vote. The language is definitely written by a lawyer. So we want to make sure that folks know that they're voting what they want to vote for."

As of Tuesday night, Denton County election officials report, there was a 16 percent increase in early voting from the 2010 election: 47,035 in-person votes were cast, up from 40,529 on the same early-voting day in 2010.

"I have noticed since I came here that there is great activity," says Lannie Noble, Denton County elections administrator. "We've had people at a lot of early-voting locations trying to get information out to the voters. Most especially here in Denton we've had the fracking parties, for and against, well-represented."

And the fight is reaching astronomical levels -- by Denton standards -- for money spent. To date, campaign finance documents indicate that nearly $800,000 has been spent by both anti-fracking and responsible drilling advocates; $700,000 of that has been spent by XTO Energy, Devon Energy and EnerVest to halt the ban.

"It's definitely a David versus Goliath. We knew that going in, but it's just very obvious now," Briggle says. "They're outspending us 10-to-1." Still, anti-frackers had been feeling confident, until recently, that their underdog fight would pull through in the election. Now, many are feeling that the vote could swing either way.

"I felt last week that we were going to pull it out of the water," says Cathy McMullen, an activist with Frack Free Denton. "Now this week I feel it's tightening. It's going to be a very close race."

What anti-frackers lack in funds to produce the same volume of mail campaigns, billboards, television and radio ads as drilling advocates, they have made up in volunteerism. "We are keeping the pedal to the metal. Our volunteers are going to be just exhausted by the fourth," Briggle says.

"We feel strong and confident about our chances," he says. "We're doing great, but we need everybody to vote. That's what we're telling our volunteers and supporters: Your vote has more power than all their dollars. You can win it with your vote. That's what we're telling people."

From what he's seen around town, working with voting stations and administrators, Noble agrees that the fight is heating up. "I can tell you that here, the fracking issue does have people out in front of the buildings trying to get voters in support. We have had both sides of the proposition out in front since early voting started on the 20th," he says. "I must admit this is my first experience with nonstop electioneering. These people are dedicated to their cause, that's for sure."


Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
20 comments
riconnel8
riconnel8

When the CEO of Exxon (who won't allow a water tower used for fracking near his home)  allows fracking within 300 feet from his house....then maybe we can talk.

Beenjamman
Beenjamman

This whole thing is similar to the vote by UNT students on the new football stadium. They didn't have to worry about the costs because they weren't paying for it! At least the companies involved pay taxes to the City of Denton.

ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul
ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul topcommenter

@riconnel8 

Nice misdirection.  The objection to the water tower was based upon zoning for the area not the potential use for the water.  The land in question has a height restriction for structures and the water utility was asking for a variance.  Additionally, Tillerson had it in writing that the water utility stated that they would not be constructing an elevated water storage at that site.

Just remember, if you spread half truths and misdirection, your credibility goes down.

cody.benton
cody.benton

@Beenjamman not similar at all. Denton residents have to pay for toxic spills, blow outs and pollution. The industry doesn't pay a dime its left on the citizens tab. Please respond when you know more about the nuances of this situation.Taxes related to natural gas development account for only 1% of the City’s property tax revenues (see Denton Central Appraisal District).Gas well royalties account for less than 1% of the City’s budget.

riconnel8
riconnel8

@ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul I'm sorry???  Where did I misdirect?  The CEO of Exxon did NOT want the water tower built close to his home...period.  The reasons for not wanting it doesn't negate his not wanting it.  Now like I was saying....when he has drilling 300 feet from his home....then we'll talk. 

Beenjamman
Beenjamman

@cody.benton  So the entire Industry pays nothing? Where does the money from permitting fees go? Also, the "blowout" well generates over $800,000 in taxable mineral values every year!   I bet agricultural zoned land doesn't generate that much money for the city.

riconnel8
riconnel8

@ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul 


"Tillerson, former Republican heavyweight Dick Armey and other residents of a ranch-filled suburb of Bartonville north of Dallas filed suit in 2012 seeking to block construction of the 160-foot-tall (49-meter-tall) water tower, arguing it would be an eyesore.


The suit, filed in Denton County District Court, also noted that the tower could encourage the town of Bartonville to sell "water to oil and gas explorers for fracking shale formations leading to traffic with heavy trucks... creating a noise nuisance and traffic hazards."


So while everyone else is worried about toxic chemicals he has the money to worry about something being an eyesore.  And here's a clue to Mr. Tillerson....his fracking brings noise nuisance and traffic hazards wherever people aren't protected by big bucks to fight it. 


cody.benton
cody.benton

@Beenjamman @cody.benton the issue is that the industry is being sloppy and irresponsible in Denton and does not want to work with city ordinances or the citizens to solve this issues. they continue to thumb their noses at the citizens. citizens have being trying to work with them since 2009 to no avail. So the citizens last approach is a frack ban to save property values, air quality and health for their future. left unfixed the industry will continue turning Denton into an industrial zone. again less that 0.2% of gas extraction goes to the Denton economy. most of the money from gas extraction lines the pockets of the industry execs. if the industry sat down and tried to find solution with the citizens in the first place we would not be in this situation. Denton land is being exploited and the citizens are having to pick up the tab. not cool at all. 


riconnel8
riconnel8

@ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul Well that's an absolute nonsense reply. 

It amuses me that when the GOP/Tea Baggers are backed against a wall and have no facts to support their stance they all of a sudden want to quit the conversation and try to discredit their opponent as an excuse. 

Carry on...nothing new here...... 

riconnel8
riconnel8

@Beenjamman so you're saying you'd buy a home next door to an obvious fracking site?  Give us your address Beenjamman so we can be sure next door to you is the next site drilled.

Most people are learning to contact city planning to see exactly where fracking can and can not be done.  I know that's my plan for my next home and if I can't find one in my little corner of the state?  I'll move out of state and take my dollars with me.

Beenjamman
Beenjamman

@riconnel8 @Beenjamman  Not unless I was included in the well! It's not that hard to figure out & people that buy next to empty fields or existing wells should bear some responsibility. Again, show me where this supposed property devaluation is happening in Denton.

riconnel8
riconnel8

@Beenjamman the property devaluation happens when you want to sell your home sitting next to a fracking site....you can't sell it.  That's called devaluation.


As you may or may not know, depending on how long you've lived in the area, many new developments have been happening in this general area for the past 10 to 15 years.  At that time fracking wasn't something we thought about so no one thought to ask.  I don't know if the developers knew or not....probably, but they didn't tell us. 


My understanding of these wells is that there are many site areas registered/licensed for possible fracking in the future.  They may or may not be drilled and there doesn't seem to be any kind of a timetable or timeline.  I don't know if it's possible to buy in this area and be protected.  Now that's something for future residents to know about and think about.  Do you think anyone is mentioning this to them? 


Maybe we need to start warning all future homebuyers to not buy from far North Fort Worth on in to Denton and further north.  When people have been warned and still choose to buy...then they bear the responsibility. 

Beenjamman
Beenjamman

@riconnel8 @Beenjamman  You are welcome to try & get your home's taxable value reduced, so no it doesn't happen only at the time of sale. Tim Ruggiero successfully reduced his in Wise County. Problems that Denton is experiencing are caused by EXISTING wells, that are clearly marked.

riconnel8
riconnel8

@Beenjamman @riconnel8  lol....so by your reasoning someone buying and paying for a 350k home can have their taxes reduced to let's say 200k and then when they try to sell their home and take 150k loss (if they can even sell it) it's all good?


Those EXISTING wells weren't there when people bought their homes.  And now they can't sell their homes to move and get away from the toxicity emitted from those wells.


Like I said Beenjamman, let us know where you live so one can be drilled next door to you. 

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...