SATURDAY PUZZLE – We continue our tour of defeat — sorry, I mean our tour of very hard puzzles — with a grid by Josh Knapp. Solving this one felt like I jammed my foot in a door just as it was being slammed in my face.
Maybe that’s too dramatic. I got my toehold by exhaling: We sometimes ASPIRATE when we pronounce the letter H (Yes, I know. Sometimes the H can be silent.), which is hinted at in the clue “What Eliza didn’t do for ‘enry ‘iggins?” Then I dropped in EGGWASH.
I started to feel confident. Big mistake. I just wasn’t on Mr. Knapp’s wavelength.
That does not mean that there is anything wrong with the puzzle. In fact, it’s a very good puzzle: clean, open, and filled with some really nice entries, KIM JONG IL and Michael VICK notwithstanding. In particular, I liked EYE OF NEWT (which also wins Clue of the Day for “Classic brewing ingredient”; bet you didn’t see that one coming), ZOOLANDER (because I love Ben Stiller and it’s such a crunchy entry), LINKEDIN (for its relative modernity and the fact that it is making its debut today), GODSEND, THE X FILES, OSCAR BAIT, the sweetness of MY LOVE, the slangy POPO and SALT TAX.
What got me, though, was the cluing. It’s Saturday, so it’s not unexpected, but there are Saturday puzzles that are difficult because of their entries and there are Saturday puzzles that are difficult because the clues whizz by tangentially before your brain even has a chance to think about them.
Some of them are gettable. If you know about dogs, for example, you might suss out that a “Newfoundland cry” that has three letters might be ARF, instead of an expletive coming from someone living in St. John’s.
But hands up if you were fooled by the homophonic cluing of 20 Across: “Cloth with tears in it?” Me, too. But it’s not “tears” as in ripping, is it? It’s “tears” as in crying. That’s why the answer to that one is HANKIE. Even with the question mark, a clue like that is like a slap upside the back of the head. And I’m totally jealous that I didn’t think of it.
That is more than enough to get you started. Hang in there, those of you who haven’t finished. Mr. Knapp’s puzzle is worth the labor.
Your thoughts?