The Imitation Game, film review: Benedict Cumberbatch's Alan Turing is superb, but the film is evasive about the character's sexuality
The mathematician's homosexuality is dealt with in a strangely evasive fashion and some facts don't quite stack up
Thursday 13 November 2014
"Did he really deserve a place in here?" a mourner at St. Paul’s Cathedral asks of T.E. Lawrence at the beginning of Lawrence Of Arabia. David Lean's epic argued the case that Lawrence, for all his foibles, was worthy of being celebrated alongside other great British heroes. The Imitation Game, does something similar for Alan Turing, the brilliant cryptanalyst and mathematician credited with cracking the codes of the Nazis’ Enigma machine.
Turing, superbly played by Benedict Cumberbatch, is every bit as odd and ornery a figure as the Lawrence portrayed by Peter O’Toole in Lean’s film. “Give you a quid if you can name a more insufferable sod,” one of his fellow codebreakers remarks. Turing (an enthusiastic long-distance runner) shares Lawrence’s self-obsession and aloofness as well as his drive. The obvious difference is that Turing isn’t leading Arab forces across the desert. He is in charge of a group of “crossword enthusiasts in a tiny village in England.”
American screenwriter Graham Moore, who based his screenplay on Alan Turing: The Enigma by Andrew Hodges, combines biopic and thriller elements with an impassioned defence of his protagonist and a veiled love story.
“Are you paying attention? Good. You will listen closely and you will not judge me until you are finished,” Cumberbatch’s Turing is heard in a voice-over early in the film. (We learn later that he is addressing the detective who has arrested him.) The film starts in Manchester in 1951, not long after his flat has been broken into. The police are baffled by the incident and even more startled by Turing himself, who is arrogant but furtive. From here, we are taken in flashback to the war years at Bletchley Park and fleetingly to his school days at Sherborne in the late 1920s.
Benedict Cumberbatch and Alan Turing Norwegian director Morten Tyldum (who came to international attention for his 2011 screen version of Jo Nesbø’s thriller Headhunters) strikes a very brisk narrative pace as we are whisked from early 50s Manchester to London in 1939 andf from there to “Bletchley Radio Manufacturing.” There is a wonderful early scene in which naval commander Alastair Denniston (Charles Dance) interrogates Turing to see if he might be suitable to join Bletchley’s top secret team of codebreakers. The two men talk at cross purposes. Denniston’s withering sarcasm and attempts at humour are entirely lost on Turing. “Mother says I can be off putting sometimes,” Turing blandly parries the officer, who grows more and more exasperated.
The film is as contradictory as its lead character. If you lopped off the post-war Manchester scenes and those of Turing’s schooldays, this would be a conventional Second World War adventure thriller about the race against time to break the Enigma code. In the wartime scenes, Tyldum contrasts the bucolic world of Bletchley Park with footage of submarines and bombings. Britain is under siege and slowly starving. The 1940s are recreated in loving but fussy detail. We are in a world of tweed jackets, cardigans and sleeveless jumpers. All the male codebreakers wear the top buttons of their shirt undone. When we see footage of blitzed out London, there is the inevitable doughty housewife having a cup of tea on the rubble. The language is quaintly archiac. When Joan Clarke (Keira Knightley) turns up late at the crossword competition Turing organises to identify the best puzzle solvers, she apologises, saying “the bus ‘caught’ a flat tire.”
Hut 8 at Bletchley Park exists in its own version of Groundhog Day. At midnight, if the cryptanalysts have failed again to crack the code, they have to start all over again. They get hold of their first “intercepts” at 6am, which gives them 18 hours. There are 159 million million possible permutations.
The romance here isn’t between Turing and Joan, although he does propose to her. The real object of Turing’s affection is Christopher, a boy with whom he was very close at school and whose memory has haunted him ever since. When he builds his own machine, he christens it after Christopher. We see him looking longingly at it, as if this huge computer with its red wires, levers and rotors somehow possesses the spirit of his lost friend.
Parts of The Imitation Game don’t stack up. Turing is portrayed as apolitical and without emotional intelligence but, at several key moments of the film, he is the only one who sees the bigger picture. His homosexuality is dealt with in strangely evasive fashion. In the war scenes that make up the bulk of the movie, his sexuality is skirted over. Tyldum is more interested in portraying the camarderie and tensions between the codebreakers (among them Matthew Goode’s dashing Hugh Alexander and Allen Leech’s cheery John Cairncross) than in exploring Turing’s emotional anxieties. Turing is referred to as “a fragile narcissist,” but he is so busy with his machine that he has little time for introspection. Given that Turing was criminally prosecuted for homosexuality after the Second World War, chemically castrated and died of cyanide poisoning aged only 41, the tone is disconcertingly cheery. Two or three times in the film, we hear the same line, “it’s the people no-one imagines anything of who do the things no-one can imagine.” This implies that Turing has somehow been underrated but his brilliance, like his eccentricity, is recognised by everyone.
Cumberbatch must be in the frame for major awards. His Turing has the same mix of vulnerability and irascibility that Colin Firth brought to the stuttering Bertie in The King’s Speech. He captures the character’s intellectual drive while also bringing subtle comic touches to the role (for example, his attempts to ingratiate himself with his colleagues by bringing them apples or when he misreads social signals in the pub or when he climbs through Joan’s window like a clumsy suitor, bringing her puzzles instead of roses.) For all the ingenuity of its structure, the film itself is sometimes sketchy and superficial. What it does do emphatically, though, is make the case for Turing as a very British kind of hero.
Comedy...to show her mastectomy scars
TV review A moving film showing kids too busy to enjoy their youth
Books Not even a Man Booker prize could save Richard Flanagan from a nomination
TV Make a Heisen-Batten-Burg and become a Kingpin cook like Walter Wheat
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Vogue responds to 'plus size' backlash with lingerie 'for all shapes and sizes' shoot
- 2 Dollar store toy wand has hidden picture of demonic child cutting herself with a kitchen knife
- 3 Jessica Ennis-Hill 'will remove her name from Sheffield United stand' if Ched Evans is re-signed
- 4 Sainsbury's Christmas advert is like a 4-minute 'f*** you' to John Lewis and Monty the penguin
- 5 Boris Johnson's elaborate ruse to persuade News Of The World he was a cocaine dealer
-
The Imitation Game, film review: Benedict Cumberbatch's Alan Turing is superb, but the film is evasive about the character's sexuality
-
Dapper Laughs is dead – and ITV didn’t even turn up to his funeral
-
Quentin Tarantino to retire after tenth film The Hateful Eight
-
Tig Notaro performs stand-up set topless to show her mastectomy scars
-
Apprentice 2014: Contestant James Hill outed as convicted criminal
-
In-your-face racism has returned and few are fighting against it
-
Labour funding crisis: Jewish donors drop 'toxic' Ed Miliband
-
Virus that 'makes humans more stupid' discovered
-
Jesus 'married Mary Magdalene and had children', according to ancient manuscript
-
Nigel Farage caught on video suggesting NHS should be run privately
-
Man banned from entering park on his own because of paedophile fears
Follow Simon Calder's journey in Cuba
As winter takes hold in Britain, sunny days and warm nights await in the Cuba.
Rainbow list 2014: The LBGT people who make a real difference
Introducing our annual celebration of the lesbian, bisexual, gay, and transgender people who make a real difference
2014 WISE Summit
For the past four years, Qatar Foundation has been awarding an international prize for education each year, the first award of its kind in the world. Find out more...
Playing a strong hand
How mobile technology has changed the instant trading game
Why HD audio will lead to smarter calling
Telecom giant Vodafone is looking to improve voice quality, becoming the latest company to introduce new HD technology.
i100: A single mother on benefits who became one of the world's most successful authors
11 rags-to-riches underdog success stories
Made of London Series
From Britpop royalty to champion cheesemaker. Alex James has said that he would like to make more music with Blur.
From medieval to ultramodern
Mons is embracing the future as it prepares for its role as next year’s European Capital of Culture, but it’s also steeped in intriguing history. Philip Sweeney explores its two sides
Winter sparkle
Winter is the time for two things: tactile textures and tonnes of sparkle. Ensure you have bucket loads of both with these embellished buys.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.