How Some Illegal Taxi Drivers Are Fighting Back Against the Green Cab Program

Categories: Longform

40-flock2.jpg
All illustrations by Greg Houston
It was a busy night, two days before Christmas, and the streets of Bedford-Stuyvesant were packed with shoppers. So Emmanuel* was out later than usual. He had just picked up one last fare from his corner in Bed-Stuy, which was usually a safe zone, but moments later he was pulled over by a Ford Econoline van. Emmanuel knew the model. It was what New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission officers used when they did undercover sweeps for illegal cab drivers.

He also knew what came next: Two TLC officers would approach his car; he'd roll his window down; one of them would reach in and take his key. He would be booked for driving without TLC plates, his car would be impounded, and he'd have to pay a big fine to get it back. The TLC had recently begun cracking down on illegal, or "gypsy," cab drivers, more than ever before, and this was its modus operandi. So, as the van idled behind him, and as the TLC officers appeared to call for backup, Emmanuel quietly shifted into drive, stepped hard on the gas, and peeled off. The officers, caught flat-footed, didn't even try to chase him.

"If they're young and they're new, they might want to chase you," Emmanuel says later, from inside his black Crown Victoria, a car the Ford Motor Company produced from 1992 until 2011, mainly for law enforcement and taxi drivers. His is a 2008 model, and the inside is pristine, with deep leather seats and a steering wheel wrapped in a black leather cover. The car has never given him a problem in the two and a half years he's been driving it, he brags, adding that it's much faster than the TLC agents' undercover vehicles — typically a Ford Focus or an Econoline. "The cars that they drive could never compete with this car," he says. "This car holds about 320 horses in the engine." The fastest he's ever driven it, he says, is 140 mph.

Emmanuel and about a dozen other drivers share a busy corner in Bed-Stuy, just more than a mile from the Barclays Center. From there they can pick up a steady stream of passengers returning from work. Some of the drivers on the corner are not licensed to operate cabs, and although some do have the required TLC plates, all of them operate illegally in one way or another. To protect themselves against the increasing TLC enforcement, they have formed a crew.

Emmanuel, 29, has been on the corner the longest, since 2011. He is the de facto leader of the group. A native of Flatbush, he's an imposing figure, at almost 300 pounds, with a shaved head and a fuzzy chinstrap beard. He has worked various jobs — most recently at a Starbucks and then a Lowe's — but he became an unlicensed cab driver after realizing he didn't like working under somebody else. Now he's the boss of a whole crew. A single father, Emmanuel is always willing to give advice to the younger drivers, mostly about how to protect one another from the emerging threats to their enterprise.

On some days, "protection" means popping the tires of one of the city's growing number of "green cabs," some of which have started trying to pick up passengers on Emmanuel's corner, the exact cross streets of which he disclosed to the Voice on the condition that it not be shared for publication. On other days it means doing the same to the TLC officers' vehicles. On occasion, Emmanuel says, he and his crew will give a TLC car what they call an "oil change." This entails waiting until the officers are out of the vehicle, then pouring motor oil over the windshield, making the car almost undrivable. Some of the drivers have also started to carry Mace, which doubles as a safeguard against dangerous passengers and a potential weapon to use on TLC officers.

But most of the time, Emmanuel's job means coordinating evasions of the authorities. His efforts initially earned him the nickname "The Enforcer," a sobriquet he now uses to describe a younger driver named Alex*, another member of the crew. Alex, who wears dreads and is half Emmanuel's size, does all the tire-popping and "oil changing" these days. "You know what I do to TLC?" says Alex, letting out a high-pitched laugh. "I give them a hard time."

Emmanuel says having Alex do the dirty work only makes sense. "You can't have a 6-foot-1, 270-pound dude flatten a tire; you're going to see him as soon as he goes down," he says. Emmanuel is big, but looks even bigger in his oversized gray sweatshirt, baggy jeans, and skullcap. "I tell them what to do. But I never get my hands dirty." Alex, he adds, "gets a thrill out of doing it."

With the green cabs — cheaper, city-licensed taxis that serve only the outer boroughs — starting to encroach on their turf, protection seems needed on the corner more than ever. The neighborhood has also begun to change, bringing withit more enforcement. "At one point it was so easy...TLC wasn't enforcing at all," Emmanuel says. "But then they added the Barclays Center, they added major attractions that they know people will use taxis to get to....Then they started coming out like crazy."

* We spoke to many drivers who requested that we not use their real names. All such drivers are referred to by pseudonyms.

[Single Page]



Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
15 comments
seoexpert844
seoexpert844

You are share great information, thanks for share this types  of knowledge.we are giving services like Taxi Delmar offer you private boat excursion with skipper, night tours, Big game fishing, water taxi 0-24 – Hvar, midll dalmatia, Croatia. If you want to know more please click here
http://taxi-delmar.com/product-category/transfers/

Paul Gerard
Paul Gerard

They all suck. New York City needs to impose something similar to London's knowledge test for cab drivers. It's terrible. You can't go from Chelsea to Chinatown, or Williamsburg to Crown Heights without having to give directions. Or my favorite, when they hand me their phone to plug the address in their GPS. Yet we're encouraged to give them the same tip we give the F&B industry that busts their asses? Could you imagine giving 20% to a server that hands you his pad n says write down what you want, then point me to the kitchen? There was a time when you could name a bar or restaurant or theater, and get there with the only thing said is "ok pal". If I hear "how do you want to go", or another f'n cab driver bitch to me about traffic on the Manhattan bridge is an inconvenience I'm gonna lose my mind. Gypsy cabs are expensive, and city cabs are the worst "service" for the price. Car service is the best bet when possible.

skeetervt
skeetervt

As I read this article, one question kept popping up in my mind, over and over: Why hasn't the city forced the yellow-cab companies to serve the outer boroughs? It's clear to me that the yellow cabs' refusal to serve the outer boroughs is unfair, discriminatory -- and illegal under state and federal laws that bar discrimination in public accommodations.


I remember back in the '60s and '70s the controversy over the yellow cabs' refusal to pick up passengers bound for Harlem or Bedford-Stuyvesant. This was blatantly illegal discrimination against residents of these still-predominantly-African-American neighborhoods.


That neither the city nor the state cracked down against the yellow cabs' illegal discriminatory practices is a disgrace. If they had, then there would be no need for the green cabs -- let alone the illegal cabs that continue to operate.


The only way the city can effectively eliminate the problem of the illegal cabs is to strictly enforce state and federal anti-discrimination laws and force the yellow cabs to serve all neighborhoods in all five boroughs.

urbachmarina
urbachmarina

You are a good reporter, Elizabeth..I had to read the whole long article...could not stop...very engaging. I like the way you constructed the structure: starting and ending with the 'corner' people...Love the way you write! Many, many years ago, in a foreign country, when I announced to my parents, when I graduated from high school, that I wanted to be a journalist, my father, a lawyer, said: 'that is not a profession for a woman'...( I think I would have been a good lawyer, but being the profession of my father, did not even think about it...perhaps I would have been a good journalist...I write reviews of art exhibitions, but it is not the same, it is just for a relatively small group of people...) you touch many issues, bureaucracy, capricious regulations, corruption, immigrants working conditions and so on, also the history of the city going back to mayor Lindsay...I saw the whole process like a movie..Brava! 

Years ago, I took a taxi for a very short ride, because I was late...the driver was not interested in such a short ride and asked me to leave. At first I refused, but at the end I had to. I took his name and licence and complained. We had a hearing with the TLC. I gave my side of the story, when he gave his, he lied and said, that I had spoken to him with obscenities, like 'mother f....'and so on. Because English is not my first language, I do not use obscenities, as they tend to be slang...It was odd to hear the African driver repeat the obscenities someone advised him to say...The 'judge' gave him a fine of $200.00.  I asked the 'judge' to forgive the fine...I felt sorry for him...to my astonishment the judge said 'I am going to grant the wishes of this nice lady'...I was amazed and so was the driver and everybody else in the room...he did not make eye contact with me...but perhaps he felt ashamed for his lies and my reaction....


The only thing: 'The agency is seizing a record number of illegal cabs, taking more than 8,900 cars in financial year 2014....' perhaps you mean 'fiscal year' rather than financial?

Carol Lindenmuth
Carol Lindenmuth

That's disgusting. They need to change with the times or get out of the business.

Kevin Duval
Kevin Duval

Fuckin criminals, especially when he flees the scene at high speed. He should he locked up in jail

Caryn Macron
Caryn Macron

If you have ever experienced a Brooklyn car service, you will appreciate the green cabs.

nyctuber1
nyctuber1

@skeetervt As for the discrimination aspect of not picking up in bed stuy, it's tricky. You'd be amazed what can happen to cab drivers. Fares jumping out without paying is the least of it. It's happened to me, always by the same demographic. I don't consider myself racist, but there are hard realities of protecting yourself. 

nyctuber1
nyctuber1

@skeetervt Because yellow cabs can't make enough money in the outer boroughs to cover expenses and make a decent living. Fares are very intermittent, odds are you will not even cover expenses. The thing about the gypsy cabs is, their only expense is gas. 

skeetervt
skeetervt

Sorry for the duplicate posts. I had trouble with my login.


skeetervt
skeetervt

@nyctuber1 That's no excuse. Taxis are legally classified as "public accommodations" and therefore are subject to all state and federal anti-discrimination laws. The refusal of yellow-cab drivers pick up certain fares solely because of their race is illegal -- period, end of story. Unless and until the city or the state cracks down on the yellow-cab companies' illegal discrimination, the problem of the so-called "gypsy" cabs will continue to persist and persist. Only when the yellow cabbies are required to serve all five boroughs without discrimination will the problem be resolved.

skeetervt
skeetervt

@nyctuber1 That's no excuse. Taxis are legally classified as "public accommodations" and therefore are subject to all state and federal anti-discrimination laws. The refusal of yellow-cab drivers pick up certain fares solely because of their race is illegal -- period, end of story. Unless and until the city or the state cracks down on the yellow-cab companies' illegal discrimination, the problem of the so-called "gypsy" cabs will continue to persist and persist. Only when the yellow cabbies are required to serve all five boroughs without discrimination will the problem be resolved.

Now Trending

New York Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...