Hilary Mantel: Coalition government more brutal to poor and immigrants than Thomas Cromwell was

The award-winning historical author said the Middle Ages appeared positively enlightened compared to the “retreat into insularity” the UK had embraced

Hilary Mantel has claimed that the Coalition’s policies towards the poor and immigrants are more brutal than the measures introduced by Thomas Cromwell, during an interview in which she attacked a “mood of harshness” which has taken hold in Britain.

The award-winning historical author said the Middle Ages appeared a positively enlightened era compared to the “retreat into insularity” which the UK had currently embraced.

Speaking to German newspaper Der Spiegel, the Wolf Hall author said: “When people feel they're being mistreated, they lash out against people who are weaker than themselves, immigrants for example. What's happening here at the moment is really ugly.

“The government portrays poor and unfortunate people as being morally defective. This is a return to the thinking of the Victorians. Even in the 16th century, Thomas Cromwell was trying to tell people that a thriving economy has casualties and that something must be done by the state for people out of work.

“Even back then, you saw the tide turning against this idea that poverty was a moral weakness. Who could have predicted that it would come back into style? It's myth making on a grand scale, and it's poisonous.”

 

Mantel, twice awarded the Booker Prize for her Wolf Hall, which documented the rise of Cromwell, Henry VIII’s chief minister, and its sequel Bring Up the Bodies, said austerity had become a present-day dogma rather than a policy response.

The author said: “Many people are poorer than they were five or six years ago. The last few years of austerity after the banking crisis have opened up a wider gap between rich and poor.

“What’s put to the electorate is: You can't have this, you can't have that, because there's no money in the pot. But it's not really a question of resources. It's a question of ideology, which is moving to the right. It wishes to reduce the role of government and it strives for a small state.”

She also defended her controversial recent short story about an IRA assassin killing Margaret Thatcher which prompted outrage from allies of the former Prime Minister, including calls for a police investigation.

Mantel said: “I was prepared, but bringing in the police for an investigation was beyond anything I could have planned or hoped for, because it immediately exposes them to ridicule.

“These people don't know how to read fiction, they were professionally outraged. I don’t know if the reactions would have been the same if a male writer like Martin Amis or Ian McEwan had published this.

“I don’t need a defence, but what I would ask them is: Do you think Ms. Thatcher shied away from controversy? Do you think she cared overly much about public opinion?”

Mantel added: “Thatcher was the first woman in Downing Street, but imitated a man. When I say this, it seems like a joke, but I think Margaret Thatcher had a great deal of trouble understanding and coming to terms with her own femininity.”

Read More: MANTEL'S TUDOR TALES INSPIRE STAGE AND TV ADAPTATIONS
MANTEL ON 'PSYCHOLOGICAL TRANSVESTITE' MARGARET THATCHER
HILARY MANTEL DEFENDS CRITICISM OF THE DUCHESS OF CAMBRIDGE

Welfare state: Cromwell’s plans

As chief minister to Henry VIII, Thomas Cromwell tried to introduce a Poor Law in 1536 to provide financial aid to those unable to work, a move which reveals him to have been a progressive in medieval terms, Mantel claims.

This attempt to establish a national system of poor relief could be seen as a progenitor of the modern Welfare State. Cromwell proposed compelling the able-bodied to work on public projects, such as road and bridge building, for a basic wage. These works would be financed by taxes that would also pay for the care of the sick, old and disabled. Parliament rejected the scheme because of its tax provisions.

However, the Dissolution of the Monasteries in which Cromwell played a key role, and which brought the crown vast wealth, swept away the informal system of poor relief, care and education provided by the Church.

Cromwell also drew up an Act against Enclosure, to end rural depopulation by limiting the sheep any one person could own to 2,400.

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs People

Recruitment Genius: Management Trainer

£30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Exciting career opportunity to join East...

Recruitment Genius: Senior Scientist / Research Assistant

£18000 - £28000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An ambitious start-up company b...

Reach Volunteering: Chair of Trustees

VOLUNTARY ONLY - EXPENSES REIMBURSED: Reach Volunteering: Do you love the Engl...

Ashdown Group: Compensation and Benefits Manager - Brentwood - Circa £60,000

£60000 per annum: Ashdown Group: Compensation and Benefits Manager - Compensat...

Day In a Page

Isis in Syria: In the shadow of death, a few thousand Christians remain to defy the militants

In the shadow of death, a few thousand Syrian Christians remain to defy Isis

At a wedding in Qamishli, distraught priests tell Robert Fisk of the persecution that has brought their Church to its knees
Secret deal to tackle emissions ushers in a new era in the fight against global warming

Secret deal to tackle emissions ushers in a new era in the fight against global warming

Obama and Xi toast deal to bring Washington and Beijing in from the cold
Mecca under threat: Outrage at plan to destroy the ‘birthplace’ of the Prophet Mohamed and replace it with a new palace and luxury malls

Mecca under threat

Outrage at plan to destroy the ‘birthplace’ of the Prophet Mohamed and replace it with a new palace and luxury malls
With today's children having never known a world with no internet, should their parents be worried?

Screen and not heard

With today's children having never known a world with no internet, should their parents be worried?
Taking on the Trojan Horse: Sir Mike Tomlinson on dealing with the aftermath of Islamist extremism

Taking on the Trojan Horse

Sir Mike Tomlinson on dealing with the aftermath of Islamist extremism
Comic relief: Using picture books to warn about Ebola

Comic relief

Using picture books to warn about Ebola
11 best skin brighteners

Healthy glow: 11 best skin brighteners

The best products for creating a more even tone and reducing redness and pigmentation
World Cup 2018: FA braced for Fifa criticism over failed bid to host tournament

A case of handbags?

FA braced for Fifa criticism over failed bid to host 2018 World Cup
Chelsea finances: High-flying Blues set to announce record £20m profits

High-flying Chelsea set to announce record £20m profits

The sales of Luiz and Mata, plus TV deal income, also mean league leaders bring in biggest turnover in Abramovich era
England vs South Africa: Heyneke Meyer still trying to balance the Springboks

Meyer still trying to balance the Boks

Coach boasts South Africa have a squad ‘good enough to win every single game’ but after victory over All Blacks and defeat in Dublin they need to find consistency
Isis in Syria: The story of the martyred soldiers who fought 'to the last bullet' to avoid the fate of captured comrades beheaded by militants

Robert Fisk in Syria

The story of the martyred soldiers who fought 'to the last bullet' to avoid the fate of captured comrades beheaded by Isis
Quentin Tarantino opts for an inglourious farewell after 10 films

Quentin Tarantino opts for an inglourious farewell after 10 films

Cinema’s hip wunderkind has announced plans to retire after making his 10th film – but will his backers let him?
The Rolling Stones' tour insurance policy: Have they got Keith Richards coverage?

Sympathy for the insurers

The publication of The Rolling Stones’ tour insurance policy reveals some extraordinary fine print
Crowdfunding music: How to be an online busker

Crowdfunding music: How to be an online busker

A new book reveals what all of us could learn about the art of asking
Jane Smiley interview: Pulitzer Prize winner on her new trilogy set in the Iowa badlands

Jane Smiley interview

The Pulitzer Prize winner on her new trilogy set in the Iowa badlands