Dallas' Five Best Italian Restaurants

Categories: Best Of Dallas

carbones-lasagna.jpg
Spinach lasagna at Carbone's
Any restaurant that turns out a lasagna like the one pictured above has got to be jockeying to be the Best Italian Restaurant in Dallas. And it turns out Carbone's, the Italian restaurant responsible for that plate up above, won just that award in our recent Best Of Dallas feature that celebrates exemplary everything around the city and beyond.

There's plenty of red sauce to be found, but none of it ever seems to be plated this prettily. The tomatoes in that sauce pop with flavor, and beneath those sheets of tender pasta are layer after layer of soft melted cheese and plenty of spinach. Prefer meat? There's a bolognese version, and then there are sandwiches, salads and loads of other pasta dishes, too.

But don't think Carbone's is the only Italian restaurant that's welcome in The Family. Here are four more that could have made the cut.

*****

Thumbnail image for Lucia Agnolotti.jpg
Agnolotti from Lucia
Lucia
The only thing that keeps Lucia from winning Best Italian year after year is the size of you bill when you're done eating there. Not every meal can be this extravagant an expense, but when you're flush and craving some hand-rolled pasta, this is the place to order it. No reservation? Show up early and try to grab one of the stools at the back of the dining room. They're always open, first come first served.

*****

Thumbnail image for Nonna Clam Pizza.JPG
The white clam pizza at Nonna

Nonna
Think of Nonna as Lucia's younger, rebellious sibling. The cooking is a little less authentic, but then it's also a little more inventive; it's a fair trade. Whatever you do, don't skip the dessert. Some of the best happy endings in the city can be had here.

*****

Thumbnail image for Urbano Cafe Bolognese.jpg
Catherine Downes
And then there was bolognese.
Urbano Cafe
Urbano doesn't present itself as a distinctly Italian restaurant, but if you look at the menu, it's all there. Just look at that bowl of pasta drenched in meat sauce. All you can say is Mamma Mia.

*****

maggianos.jpg
Maggiano's
I'm going to catch hell for this one but I'm not alone in my opinion. If you want the stick-to-your-bones kind of Italian cookery that made Tony Soprano round-shaped, this is one of your better options in Dallas. Yes, I'm talking to you! Most of the red sauce joints in DFW fall well short, and I don't care if I end up sleeping with the fishes for saying so. Stack Maggiano's up against something like Patrizio in Highland Park and ... oh, wait. That place closed.


Location Info

Maggiano's Little Italy

8687 N. Central Expressway, Dallas, TX

Category: Restaurant

Urbano Cafe

1410 N. Fitzhugh Ave., Dallas, TX

Category: Restaurant

Nonna

4115 Lomo Alto Drive, Dallas, TX

Category: Restaurant

Lucia

408 W. Eighth St., Dallas, TX

Category: Restaurant

Il Cane Rosso

2612 Commerce St., Dallas, TX

Category: Restaurant


Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
36 comments
tgtg999
tgtg999

2 Guys From Italy is better and more reasonable priced than any of these places. 

txturquoise
txturquoise

Glad to see Maggiano's made the list. 

txturquoise
txturquoise

Maggiano's is our go to celebration station. Birthdays, anniversaries, promotions.

Always delightful and delicious and their take out is a ++++

laygo3
laygo3

If you're ever in Denton, a visit to my good friends at Bagheri's is in order. I've personally witnessed people go up to the owner/chef & say:
"I've eaten Chicken Marsala all over the world & this is hands down the best I've ever had."

The owner has told me someone else has said that about his Chicken Parmesean too.

amber.newsom83
amber.newsom83

You REALLY need to check out Roman Cucina in Richardson, off of Beltline and Coit.  Dallas definitely isn't the place to find amazing Italian, but this restaurant is the closest you'll find, IMO.  

p_mallett
p_mallett

As much as I'd like to argue with this list I can't because ALL Italian food in Dallas is so disappointing it really doesn't matter who you put up there. 

iloveNOLA
iloveNOLA

If Mario says its so,it must be true. A typical "foodie" comment. Now lets wait for an original thought. 

blankcur1
blankcur1

Kennys in Addison is always good. 

Citizenkane
Citizenkane

It's a good list;  not all decent italian restaurants have to be upscale, so balancing out the list with the more affordable (and accessible) Maggiano's was a good call.  Try getting a table for four on short notice at Lucia.



Bellabear
Bellabear

Maggiano's?  This list just lost all credibility.  Try Roman Cucina off Coit and Beltline.  Incredible.  Some of the best Italian we have had since moving to Dallas.

Myrna.Minkoff-Katz
Myrna.Minkoff-Katz topcommenter

Myrna is in total agreement with Mario Batali on this:


Mario says:

  • "What you want to eat when you eat a bowl of pasta ... is pasta."

  • "The way that they refer to their sauce in Italy is condimento—condiment—and when you think about a hot dog or hamburger, the condiment is something that kind of greases it up, but it never overtakes the main event of the hot dog or the hamburger."

  • "Americans overdress their pasta 99.9 percent of the time. It should never be a bowl of soup. It should be noodles, with a little stuff."

MattL11
MattL11

The fact that Maggiano's and Lucia are somehow on the same list tells me that "Italian" is too broad of a category.

kergo1spaceship
kergo1spaceship

Best Italian place is yer closest Italian neighbor....otherwise, I'm NOT paying good money for it.  What place is it that call S+G meatballs and gravy......sacrilege. 

ChangingF8
ChangingF8

People act as if including a chain is a sin. If they have good food, does it matter if there is only one of 5 million of them? 

Citizenkane
Citizenkane

Wanna make your tomato sauce "pop" with flavor.....add a little fish sauce (or muddled anchovies).


All good picks.

tb00
tb00

I'd kick Nonna to the top of the list and Carbone's to the bottom. I just haven't had a memorable meal at Carbone's -- surprising, given it's Nonna's sibling. And kudos for including Maggiano's. It's not sophisticated. But the food there is truly satisfying.

Myrna.Minkoff-Katz
Myrna.Minkoff-Katz topcommenter

Bitchola Myrna has to add a comment here.  Those pasta dishes are WAY over-sauced.  Is that a preference of diners in these parts? 

Twinwillow
Twinwillow

@Bellabear Or for that matter, try Cafe Amore' on Coit Road in Richardson. A great Italian style red sauce restaurant owned and run by an Albanian family.

And, they're BYOB! 

Myrna.Minkoff-Katz
Myrna.Minkoff-Katz topcommenter

@kergo1spaceship Sono d'accordo con te.  La famiglia italiana di un dei miei mariti non andrebbe mai ad un ristorante per la pasta.  Sempre in casa cucinare la pasta.  Sempre.

Twinwillow
Twinwillow

@Citizenkane Personally, I always add a few good quality anchovies to the pan when starting my marinara sauce.

Twinwillow
Twinwillow

@Myrna.Minkoff-Katz I love ya Myrna but we're not in Italy anymore. And truth be known, in NYC, they're not sauced any differently than those pictured above.  

Bellabear
Bellabear

@Twinwillow @Bellabear Have never been there, but will check it out.  And Roman Cucina is by no means "upscale."  It is super family oriented - they are great with my kids.  Just great food and the nicest people.  We have taken 3 sets of friends there any everyone loves it.  Has only been opened for a year.  

ScottsMerkin
ScottsMerkin topcommenter

@Myrna.Minkoff-Katz @MikeD Ill dress my pasta however the fuck I please.  Sometimes Im in a saucy mood, and sometimes Im not.  Also, if its too much sauce, then remove it from the plate yourself.  I need a good meat sauce now.  Im starving

Myrna.Minkoff-Katz
Myrna.Minkoff-Katz topcommenter

@Citizenkane I've been to Villa di Roma near the Italian Market.  It's okay for "Medigons".  For Myrna, heartburn-a-rama.

Twinwillow
Twinwillow

@Citizenkane That's the kind of great "mom 'n pop" Italian food I grew up eating in NY. And Carbone's (as good as it is for Dallas) doesn't even come close.

Citizenkane
Citizenkane

@Myrna.Minkoff-Katz


It may be as you describe. I have never been.  The point being that lost of sauce isn't just in these here parts !



Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Loading...