Thomas Eric Duncan's Fever Was in Range for Ebola During His First Hospital Visit, AP Says

Categories: News

tericduncan-thumb-565x393.jpg
Fort Worth Star-Telegram via Twitter
Thomas Eric Duncan.
Thomas Eric Duncan, the first person to be diagnosed with Ebola in the U.S., had a fever of 103 degrees during his first visit to Presbyterian Hospital, The Associated Press reports. The Centers for Disease Control lists a fever of greater than 101.5 degrees as one of the potential signs that someone has contracted the virus.

Despite his high fever, a physician noted that Duncan was "negative for fever and chills," according to the AP. Duncan also complained of abdominal pain, which is another potential sign of the virus. He was released from the hospital after his initial check-up.

After his health began to deteriorate, Duncan was hospitalized. He died Wednesday morning.

See also: Ebola Fear and Misinformation Is Still Weighing on the People of Vickery Meadow

Presbyterian has issued a few versions of how its staff handled Duncan. First it said Duncan didn't share that he had traveled to Dallas from West Africa, the front lines of the fight against Ebola. Then it said a nurse knew but didn't share that information with doctors. Then it said that information was available to all hospital staff.


Send your story tips to the author, Sky Chadde.



Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
48 comments
hugh.farnham
hugh.farnham

Ms. Troh wallowed in bed with sweaty Mr. Ebola for over a week, inhaled his atomized barf and viruses, yet is healthy as a horse!

A nurse in full containment suit attends to him briefly and comes down with Ebola.

DOES NOT COMPUTE.

Anonamouse
Anonamouse

All us damn racists fearmongers, only trying to make hay out of one isolated case from a disease that is nearly IMPOSSIBLE to catch, we're just uneducated hick red-neck haters who.....

http://www.wfaa.com/story/news/health/2014/10/12/presbyterian-hospital-worker-ebola/17147507/

....oh. Right. Thankfully she was wearing full protective gear... but, almost impossible... ummm.... RACISTS!!!

It's SO HARD to get this disease that the hospital has STOPPED ACCEPTING NEW ER PATIENTS.... but... hey, stop saying shit like that, you RACIST FEARMONGER!1!1!!! They're only stopping accepting ER paitents to weed out the poor, misunderstood, beleaguered minorities so their lily-white private funders don't lose money. RACEEEEEEEEEEEEEE trumps all, in all matters!!!!

Clay looks a bit nervous in that pic, doesn't he?

hugh.farnham
hugh.farnham

PLEASE do a followup story on what really happened to Duncan's close associates, many of whom stayed days in that Ebola infested apartment.  

That they have not come down with Ebola, officially, is very very strange.

LIVING IN THE APARTMENT:
-Girlfriend and mother of his son: Louise Troh, lived in apt

-Timothy Wayne 13 years old, Troh's son, lived in apt

-2 men in their 20's, lived in apt

-Oliver Smallwood a relative, lived in apt

-Jeffrey Cole a friend, lived in apt

Thanks!

Hugh

Sotiredofitall
Sotiredofitall topcommenter

Yep - bureaucratic incompetence has to be the result of racism (or one political party or the other).   Maybe Mr Duncan's disregard for everyone but himself is to blame somewhere in all of this. 

 

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

Mumps, measles and chicken pox

So its now fruitless to send kids home from school - quarantine them at home.  Why, we would merely exacerbate the problem.

It is this kind of moronic ad hoc false reality construction which kills ambassadors, Baghdad falls and genocide ensues, voter integrity is lost (the honor system instead of Voter ID),  Humanitarian Crises and human kid waves (Dreamers), and the list just keeps on keeping on.  One pratfall after the other.

Of course, none of it even has a ring of truth when it is explained by an over-serious, self-absorbed 12-year old girl (ha!), you just have to laugh.  And she's a stubborn one all right.  Just the opposite.  Joe and Jane may not be paying attention but just a couple of seconds of this blather and they know, something ain't right.  Nothing these nitwits say makes any sense, on the face of it.  It doesn't even pass the smell test.

And racism is attached to every one of these silly proclamations, adding a whole new meaning to how lame a duck is this guy?  His approval rating is now the lowest in 40 years, his party is running from him like he's showing Ebola symptoms, and even the bigtime Press is taking him apart (when it no longer matters).

At this point, America is just laughing the guy off.  

He's been dismissed.

ColonelAngus
ColonelAngus

Dateline Dallas (UP)


The cloud is no more.  Servers have melted down worldwide following a blog exchange on the Dallas Observer's "Unfair Park."  The trouble began when Top Commenter and libtard Mavdog cited Fox News to support his position, sending shock waves across the web.  Two hours later, noted conservatard ColonelAngus cited the Washington Post in his rebuttal.  The resulting conundrum was too much for the Blogosphere to handle, quickly leading to the destruction of the Interweb.  Film at 11.

ColonelAngus
ColonelAngus

Dr. Frieden is playing it safe, covering both sides of the issue just in case.  One more import would be one too many.


http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/the-ominous-math-of-the-ebola-epidemic/2014/10/09/3cad9e76-4fb2-11e4-8c24-487e92bc997b_story.html


A second scenario is more dire: The conventional methods come too late, the epidemic keeps spreading, and the virus is beaten back only when vaccines can be developed and scaled up to the point where they can be widely distributed.

As the number of infections increases, so does the possibility that a person with Ebola will carry it to another country. This is known as an export.


“So we had two exports in the first 2,000 patients,” Frieden said in a recent interview. “Now we’re going to have 20,000 cases, how many exports are we going to have?”



ColonelAngus
ColonelAngus

Still Obama refuses to restrict travel from the affected countries, because that would just make it worse, according to him and his lackeys.  God help us.

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

The line for prospective attorney's starts over there >>>>>>

please do not cut in line, we know it will be rather long.

TheRuddSki
TheRuddSki topcommenter

Let slip the dogs of law...

"CNN) -- Thomas Eric Duncan's nephew released a statement Thursday renewing criticism of the care Duncan received as he battled Ebola in a Texas hospital. "Eric Duncan was treated unfairly. Eric walked into the hospital, the other patients were carried in after an 18 hour flight," Josephus Weeks said in a written statement. "It is suspicious to us that all the white patients survived and this one black patient passed away. It took 8 days to get him medicine. He didn't begin treatment in Africa, he began treatment here, but he wasn't given a chance."

Flabbergasted
Flabbergasted

@hugh.farnham  "Wallowed in bed?"

"Sweaty?"

"For over a week?"


Not only are your facts in accurate, your word choices sound like you have some real issues.

What doesn't compute is your attitude.

Oh, and as for wanting to protect the children, as stated earlier when you printed the name of a MINOR, you obviously do not care about HIS safety.

I suggest you leave Dallas. Get up, pack up and go. We would be much better off without you, and you would be happier somewhere else.

TheRuddSki
TheRuddSki topcommenter

@bvckvs

I'm guessing Mercedes C Class, a secreted fondness for Hall & Oates, recently divorced but still carries a torch, hates dogs.

Flabbergasted
Flabbergasted

@hugh.farnham  Why are you broadcasting a minor's name?

It is NOT your place to label anybody....

And D O should delete this comment from you.

riconnel8
riconnel8

@holmantx By saying "lame duck guy" you are talking about President Obama?  The same President Obama who 11 months ago wanted to appoint Dr. Vivek H. Murthy to the empty Surgeon General position that the GOTP have opposed all these months because he wants gun restrictions?


I suggest you go talk to your GOTP and ask them if their "small gubermint" includes no protection for the American citizens of the U.S. against epidemics.  Then talk to the NRA and ask them if they are willing to pay for all the carnage their money grubbing gun lobby supports.

JimSX
JimSX topcommenter

@bvckvs So, Sanders, you have kind of switched horses here, which I think is a good thing. I assume now you agree with my initial view, that the official versions of what happened to Duncan were incomplete, at the very least. 

TheRuddSki
TheRuddSki topcommenter

@bvckvs

Simpler minds have to distill complexity to a level of simplicity they can grasp, hence your assumption that patient zero died because he was black.

This is the same mindset we've seen exacerbate the problem in tribal Africa. The authorities are actually spreading ebola, it's a white man's plot, the Gods Must Be Crazy, and there's an army of anonymous racists marching around in your head.

Which is fine, not everyone can be sanely analytical, we need nutters like we need TV sitcoms and people with "kick me" tattooed on the forehead.

Where do you stand on Bush's bombing of the levees?

TheRuddSki
TheRuddSki topcommenter

@ColonelAngus

Obama says he will restrict travel if and when the UN tells him to, which is in keeping with the LFB governance philosophy.

everlastingphelps
everlastingphelps topcommenter

@bvckvs All I know is that the same people are taking the temps at the airport to block the new cases.


They are regularly reporting people boarding planes with temps of 32.0C.  Ruminate on that one for a while.  

TheRuddSki
TheRuddSki topcommenter

@bvckvs

Probably some doofus that flunked community college math.

JFPO
JFPO

Are they really lining up in this era "tort reform" and damage caps?

JSSS
JSSS

@TheRuddSki Course if Thomas Eric Duncan had told the truth in Liberia, he would never have been allowed to get on a plane and would have died in Liberia without ever receiving any medical treatment. Although the ER doc at Presby clearly screwed the pooch, the fact is that Presby donated between $500k-$1m in medical treatment to Mr. Duncan.

wcvemail
wcvemail

@TheRuddSki

Back on the "broken clock is right 2x day" theme, although I'm sure the nephew's phone was blowing up with attorney offers, perhaps it takes a lawsuit to get Presby on record as to what happened. The bad news is that it could be years before they're actually deposed. 

RTGolden1
RTGolden1 topcommenter

@riconnel8 @holmantx Since the majority of firearms used in the commission of crimes are obtained by illegal means, and the NRA (as much as I despise the group) advocates for legal and responsible firearms ownership, can you point to a factual, proven link that NRA supports carnage?

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

@riconnel8 @holmantx

By saying "lame duck guy" you are talking about President Obama? 

Yeah, that's the guy.

ColonelAngus
ColonelAngus

@mavdog  Fox News??? You must be kidding!  Sorry, couldn't help myself.


I read that one, and a couple of others prior to posting.  Not much of it makes sense to me.


As far as limiting aid to the affected areas, we presently have dedicated military flights transporting thousands of personnel there and back.  Adding a few more flights for medical and aid workers seems easy enough.


"There is no more effective way to protect the United States against additional Ebola cases than to address this outbreak at the source in West Africa. That’s what our international response—including the stepped-up measures the president announced last month—will do."


Obviously, but we can take this action while temporarily limiting air travel from the affected areas into our country - the notion that these tactics are mutually exclusive amounts to a straw man.


If one buys the administration's argument that ebola is difficult to transmit, then maybe their argument makes sense.  I do not.  While I am not accusing anyone of lying, top researchers have said recently that this may or may not be the case.  Furthermore viruses are constantly mutating.


The incubation period, at 2 - 21 days, is the most frightening aspect, along with the fact that initial symptoms are similar to cold and flu viruses.  Once the camel's nose is under the tent, we are in for the catastrophe of a lifetime.

andypandy
andypandy

@JSSS @TheRuddSki  Donated? I've heard nothing yet of his insurance and I'd be curious as to what you know about his coverage or lack thereof.  Further, from his death bed statements it appears he did not know, he was helping a neighbor with a miscarriage and not an Ebola patient.  Also with a 2-21 day incubation period there is a high likelihood he had no symptoms and had no reason to believe he was infected or exposed. 


Ignoring the Ebola crap my question is why was Presby so quick to give a guy with a virus antibiotics and send him home with no follow up after presenting a 103 degree fever? 

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

@JSSS 

The question of Duncan being truthful or untruthful has been discussed on this board already, suffice it to say there is no way to be certain on the question.

Presby may have mishandled the initial visit, but they did all they could to give Mr. Duncan the best care possible on the second chance.

ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul
ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul topcommenter

@JSSS @TheRuddSki 

I would take Presby's cost claims with a huge lick of salt.  There is retail and then what their reimbursement rates are.

I once had to go to their ER for a minor injury.  The "bill" was just shy of $2,000, but they were more than happy with the $750 from my health care provider.


I am not saying that Presby's efforts with Mr. Duncan's care were not substantial, I am sure that actual costs do easily reach into the mid 6 figures.

TheRuddSki
TheRuddSki topcommenter

@wcvemail

I think this is Presby's cue to clam up.

Flabbergasted
Flabbergasted

@bvckvs  If anything happens to that kid by "medical" vigilantes, the D O will be the first ones sued....

Highly disappointed at how far down  and low the D O is now.

11 hours---and it is still posted.

You used to be the alternative to the Dallas Morning Snooze. Now, you are just the cheaper, whorier sister of D Magazine. You act like you care, but you don't. You used to have journalistic standards, but no more.

riconnel8
riconnel8

@RTGolden1 Glad you asked.  This should make it clear:

The post of the surgeon general has been vacant since July (2013) and it looks likely to remain that way for some time thanks to a strident campaign led by the National Rifle Association and libertarian Senator Rand Paul against President Obama’s nominee, Dr. Vivek Murthy.


This isn’t the first time the NRA has held up a nominee: the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives went without a director for seven years because of opposition from the gun lobby. But never before has the group set itself so strongly against a surgeon general nominee. So why now? The NRA said Murthy’s “blatant activism on behalf of gun control” attracted their attention.

http://www.thenation.com/blog/178888/why-nra-blocking-obamas-surgeon-general-nominee#

                                 ***************

According to statistics slowly, painstakingly assembled by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention from death certificates, about 32,000 people are killed by guns in America each year. (In the most recent year for which preliminary data is available, 2011, the exact number was 32,163.)

 The CDC has a complicated history when it comes to gun-related research. Since 1997, it has been prohibited by Congress from research that may “advocate or promote gun control.” That vague language had a chilling effect on all gun-related research funded by the CDC. “Nothing was explicitly prohibited,” said David Hemenway, director of the Harvard Injury Control Research Center. “But CDC knew if they ever did anything about firearms they’d be brought before House oversight committees and berated. There were all these shots across the bow, saying, Do whatever you want, but if you do the wrong thing, we’ll blow you up.

But last winter, in the wake of Newtown, Obama signed an executive order instructing the CDC to once again support research on firearms.

And private money is crucial, because despite the warming at the CDC, the federal government’s spending on firearms research is still surprisingly low. The president’s $10 million pledge to the CDC was a vast improvement over the near-nothing the government devoted to firearms research before.

Why should we have to wait years for the CDC to issue a list of numbers, with very little additional data attached? Why can’t we test the programs and ideas that might save lives now?


http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2013/12/newtown_anniversary_what_slate_learned_from_trying_and_failing_to_record.single.html


DonkeyHotay
DonkeyHotay topcommenter

@RTGolden1 @riconnel8 @holmantx


James Holmes and Jared Lee Laughner were the quintessential poster boys for the NRA's mythical "Law Abiding Gun Owner" ...


... right up to the moment they pulled the trigger.



RTGolden1
RTGolden1 topcommenter

@ColonelAngus @mavdog The came's nose has been under the tent for years, and we've been picking at it.  the BSL-4 lab facility in Galveston houses Ebola, along with other icky stuff.

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

There's our government's aid, and there's the aid from the private sector. People and equipment that needs transport to the area.

Transport won't be feasible if it goes in with passengers and freight but leaves empty.

It is inaccurate to call this "the Administrations argument". It's the medical community. They are driving the bus. And they aren't saying it's difficult to transmit, they are saying it is not difficult to control its transmission outside of the affected area. So far they are right...

riconnel8
riconnel8

@andypandy a 103 temperature, stomach pains and a headache.  The guy was sick and he told them he'd been to Liberia.  

I am between thinking that this was a insurance issue or that this is the kind of care( no care) we receive today. I have a friend in another state whose husband (white) had a ongoing medical problem always leading to sepsis.  He'd been hospitalized several times (good insurance) for it so they rigorously started monitoring symptoms at home.  He started showing symptoms, went to the hospital and was sent home being told he wasn't sick enough yet.  To come back when he got sicker.  He ended up back in the hospital, in a coma and died within the next week. 


The difference here is that Mr. Duncan was highly contagious.

hugh.farnham
hugh.farnham

@Flabbergasted @bvckvs You are more concerned with killing off a very important comment than protecting children.  People like you hide the truth, in this case the lie that the family members are healthy as horses.  Then you hide behind the skirts of "protecting the children" - like Janet Reno.

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

@RTGolden1 

The camel's nose has been under the tent for years, and we've been picking at it

did you have to go there?

ColonelAngus
ColonelAngus

@mavdog  "In the wake of the alert issued over the first case of Ebola diagnosed in the United States last week in Dallas, Obama said that "because of the measures that we've put in place, as well as our world-class health system and the nature of the Ebola virus itself - which is difficult to transmit - the chances of an Ebola outbreak in the United States is extremely low."


Looks a lot like the administration asserting that Ebola is difficult to transmit, no?


http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/politics/2014/10/06/obama-announces-tighter-screening-air-travelers-for-ebola/


riconnel8
riconnel8

@mavdog I've always wondered about the discrepancy between what the doctor or hospital charges and what my insurance company actually pays and wondered....why can't they just charge that in the first place and forget about the middleman/insurance company.


What happens to the difference of those two amounts?  Who, if anyone, picks that up or does it just disappear into thin air?

RTGolden1
RTGolden1 topcommenter

@hugh.farnham @Flabbergasted @bvckvs I don't think they're trying to kill off the comment, just the mention of the minor's name.


I agree with both: it is odd that residents of that apartment are, by the gov't's word, in sound health.  AND, you're a special kind of prick for posting a minor's name.  "13yr old son" would have gotten the same point across.

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

@ColonelAngus 

Looks a lot like the administration asserting that Ebola is difficult to transmit, no?

yeah, they are repeating what they've been told by the medical experts.

why wouldn't they?

RTGolden1
RTGolden1 topcommenter

@riconnel8 @mavdog For a private hospital, the difference in the billed amount vs. the insurance payout can be claimed as a loss, offsetting profits come tax time.

For a government run hospital (or gov't run anything) losses equate to increases in next year's budget proposals.

ColonelAngus
ColonelAngus

@mavdog @ColonelAngus  From the WaPo link above:


"Frieden warned Thursday that without immediate, concerted, bold action, the Ebola virus could become a global calamity on the scale of HIV. He spoke at a gathering of global health officials and government leaders at the World Bank headquarters in Washington. The president of Guinea was at the table, and the presidents of Liberia and Sierra Leone joined by video link. Amid much bureaucratic talk and table-thumping was an emerging theme: The virus is still outpacing the efforts to contain it."


If it is so hard to transmit, why would they be sounding the alarm about a potential global calamity?  This is the director of Obama's CDC after all.  Does he not qualify as a medical expert? 

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

And your point is?

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...