Craig Watkins' Office Sees Conspiracy Behind News' Request for Public Records

Categories: Media
Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Craig_Watkins_061910.jpg
A judge asked the Dallas County District Attorney's Office and The Dallas Morning News to salvage their relationship Monday, but instead the two parties will duke it out in court.
A lawyer for the Dallas County District Attorney Craig Watkins says politics is behind a Dallas Morning News lawsuit seeking to force Watkins' office to comply with Texas' public records law and release documents about how the district attorney spends forfeiture funds.

"This is not about trying to get records," Russell Wilson, an assistant district attorney, told state District Judge Jim Jordan at a hearing Monday. The timing, Wilson said, was "suspicious" since the News filed its lawsuit on October 23, one week after its editorial board endorsed Republican Susan Hawk, who is running against Watkins in next week's election.

It's an interesting theory, and usually Unfair Park is willing to believe all sorts of dark motives lurk behind decisions at the Morning News, but it ignores the fact that News courthouse reporter Jennifer Emily filed her first request for records about Watkins' use of his office's civil forfeiture funds on September 4. She filed a second request for additional records on September 15. The News' lawyer sent his own letter asking about her request on October 1 and another on October 9. In the latter, he even warned the district attorney's office that the paper was ready to consider its legal options if Watkins' office didn't respond by October 13.

The News' suit says Watkins' office didn't respond at all to the September 4 request and only partly to the one filed September 15.

Emily filed her first request asking for checks, memos, invoices and emails on expenditures relating to the forfeiture fund because Watkins' had used money from that fund, which the government collects from criminals, to settle a claim from the driver of a car Watkins' rear-ended in 2013. The settlement required the other driver to keep it quiet, but news of the settlement leaked earlier this year.

Wilson pointed out that Emily and the District Attorney's Office have a "good working relationship" and that he and Emily had exchanged emails Monday morning, presumably not about the News' lawsuit. Emily had even brought the office cupcakes in the past, Wilson said.

"The relationship between the parties has been an informal one," Judge Jordan remarked Monday, "until now."

It's not unusual for beat reporters to develop casual relationships with the people they cover every day -- or to try to butter them up, for that matter. Cupcakes are a nice, homey touch, an update from the more traditional booze.

Bob Mong, the News' editor, said the relationship between his paper and the district attorney in terms of fulfilling open-records requests has been up and down. "It could be better," he said.

Wilson told Unfair Park he thinks Watkins' office has been readily available to the media, especially the News. He also thought the lawsuit was meant to serve the "political motives of the higher-ups there" at the paper.

We asked Mong whether he thought people might buy Wilson's suggestion. "I don't care," he replied.

The District Attorney's Office fulfilled part of Emily's request (Wilson kept a 5-inch thick file folder close to him at Monday's hearing). But an assistant district attorney also told Emily the forfeiture funds were being audited and some of the records were unavailable until some unspecified later date.

On September 22, Emily sent an email to an assistant district attorney saying she did not need the documents relating to the forfeiture fund. She insisted in court that she only meant part of the documents she requested and that she had told the assistant what those parts were in person before she sent the email. She sent the email thinking that would be understood.

Wilson argued that her wording could be construed as withdrawing her whole request. He also said that no one in Watkins' office refused to comply with her request.

The News' lawyer, Paul Watler, said the failure to comply constituted a refusal, and the district attorney should be forced to hand over the remaining documents.

The judge ruled Tuesday morning that the district attorney failed "in part" to comply with the News' request. "Compliance became confusing in light of the withdrawal of the request," Wilson told us Tuesday.

In December, Watkins will get to argue if Watkins has a compelling enough reason to withhold the rest of the documents. "We sort of won it and lost it," Mong, the News' editor, said.

December, coincidentally, is after the November general election.

Send your story tips to the author, Sky Chadde.


Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
19 comments
ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul
ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul topcommenter

Can't you all see that this is merely another instance of the white man putting his boot on the black man's neck in order to keep him down?


No Justus, No Peas.

leftocenter
leftocenter

"Cupcakes are a nice, homey touch, an update from the more traditional booze."

Well, um, er...I think anyone working that beat knows better than to bring in more booze...

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

As a unit, how is it rated? What's this DA's office record with respect to previous DA's offices.  What is it's conviction production and efficiency record?

How many convictions-to-arrests by category as compared to other DAs in the state and nation?

It seems that the core responsibility of the District Attorney is to remove the bad guys from the street as efficiently as possible.  Public Safety.

I would also like to know what the morale situation is, internally.  Are the troops happy with this guy?

And how is the general administration of the organization?  Aside from the leadership aspect, the DA must be a good administrator.  

I'd vote for the guy if he ranked well in these categories.

The present dust up is not an election killer, even if true.  He could, after the election, merely express contrition, reimburse the county, promise to be more transparent . . . 

and not use Asst DAs (public employees at taxpayer expense) to represent him on personal infractions.  That's like using the fund to pay off personal problems.

WhiteWhale
WhiteWhale

It is all fun and games until the Feds indict some one

noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

Why does this remind me of the IRS scandal and the "the dog ate my disk drive" excuse used by the Obama Administration?


Watkins will stall this until after the election, not realizing that if he has nothing to hide, he is handing Susan Hawk a huge issue.


I know several Democrats who are voting for her, simply because they feel Watkins is soft on crime, incompetent, and anything but transparent.  That he feels it necessary to prove that is peculiar.

dfw_maverick
dfw_maverick

How dare the DMN ask for documents that detail how he spends money from his slush fund - He is obviously above that kind of scrutiny and should be able to spend that money on worthwhile projects such as buying the silence of an accident victim and checking for bugs in his office - Right on Craig

JFPO
JFPO

I can't remember the last time I voted for a Republican. Alas, all streaks must come to an end. Nicely done, Craig.

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

Sorry Craig, but you have become intoxicated by your power as DA. You have done many good things during your time on office.

Time for a change, Susan Hawk it is.

ozonelarryb
ozonelarryb

Given your sentiment, how did that Constitution shredding scumbag Henry Wade and your Ricky Perry last so long?

Yes, power corrupts. So toss every one of em every term.

noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

@ozonelarryb There is no question Henry Wade had a reputation of protecting Dallas by stepping on the line sometimes.  But, he - helped by Sheriff Smith and the DPD Police Chief - kept organized crime out of Dallas, and made Dallas inhospitable for those wanting to break the law. 


Rick Perry, on the other hand, has demonstrated no corruption while in office, and has been popular with voters because he does a good job ... except running for President.  :)

ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul
ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul topcommenter

@noblefurrtexas @ozonelarryb 

No, Wade did not keep organized crime out of Dallas.  he merely drew a line that they could operate within.

When Joe Campisi, Sr. was alive, there was curb parking on Mockingbird in front of the Egyptian Restaurant, even during rush hour.

The day after Joe was buried, the signs came down.

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

@noblefurrtexas

Henry Wade:

19 convictions overturned, reputation tarnished

http://www.nbcnews.com/id/25917791/ns/us_news-crime_and_courts/t/after-dallas-das-death-convictions-undone/#.VFDtE4c-DVo

google "Henry Wade Civello" or "Henry Wade Binion". the accommodation of organized crime and the DA's office is clear. Wade was a regular player at their poker games.

Rick Perry? "no corruption in office'? guess again..

http://www.expressnews.com/news/local/article/Scathing-audit-rakes-governor-s-office-over-Texas-5781625.php

http://trailblazersblog.dallasnews.com/2014/09/audit-perrys-business-fund-gave-millions-to-firms-universities-that-never-sent-an-application.html/

noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

@ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul @noblefurrtexas @ozonelarryb The Campisis, the Iannis, and a few of the other Mob-lite folks in town pretty much avoided any serious stuff.  Yes; there was gambling, bookmaking, some prostitution, and "favors" for Democrat politicians, but that's about it. (Some were involved in drugs - mostly grass, but I don't know which ones.)


For a long time, there was a picture in The Egyptian of Joe, Don Byrd, Henry Wade, and a few other prominent citizens playing golf.  So, Joe wasn't considered much of a criminal locally. (Houston was much worse, especially with Tony Valone.)

This was Carlos Marcello territory, but he knew causing trouble in Dallas would be double-trouble. He was a bad dude, and was one of the top tier of suspects in JFK's murder.

 



noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

@mavdog @noblefurrtexas Given the period when he was DA, and given his many years as a DA with a large and very busy office, I'd say 19 convictions overturned is not a bad record at all. 


Remember; it is the jurors who find people guilty, and not the DA.  He takes whatever the police give to him, investigates it, and takes is to a court and a judge and/or jury. 



ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul
ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul topcommenter

@noblefurrtexas @ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul @ozonelarryb 

The main thing is that the "local mob" wasn't allowed to start protection rackets or the favorite of controlling unions.


Wade figured it better to have groups that he could control to do the prostitution, gambling and bookmaking than the ones he couldn't.


After all, it was Binion who went to Vegas in the 50's as the Chicago and East Coast guys were making there inroads there.

mavdog
mavdog topcommenter

@noblefurrtexas

I'd say 19 convictions overturned is not a bad record at all. 

those convictions were overturned because the alleged criminal was proven to be innocent, not because of procedural error/mistakes.

when several of those convictions were overturned due to the prosecutor withholding evidence from the court and the defense, evidence that was material, that goes over the line. that is itself criminal behavior.

it IS a "bad record". there's no other way to look at it.

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...