Frustrated Denton Councilman sees fracking ban as the only option

Enlarge Photo

Jake Dean

Denton homes that back up to producing wells.

Nicholas Sakelaris

Staff Writer- Dallas Business Journal

Email  |  LinkedIn  |  Twitter  |  Google+

Denton City Councilman Kevin Roden hears plenty of criticism of the Denton frack ban, but very few solutions.

That includes from the Denton Chamber of Commerce, the Texas Railroad Commission and the oil and gas industry itself, Roden wrote in a blog on his website.

The problem is that Denton has old abandoned oil wells all over the city, including near established neighborhoods, that could be redrilled as horizontal Barnett Shale wells, which require hydraulic fracking. The city’s ordinance, including its 1,200-foot setback requirement, is powerless to stop companies from drilling and fracking these wells -- no matter how close they are to homes -- because they are vested.

Got Energy? Sign up for our Energy Inc. newsletter here

That's what drove some Denton residents to gather signatures for a petition to ban fracking. Denton voters will consider the ban on fracking Nov. 4. If the referendum passes, it would be a first for a Texas city. The issue has become increasingly divisive for the city, with the chamber passing a resolution urging voters to reject the fracking ban.

The chamber cited the multimillion dollar impact the ban would have on the city, school district and universities, which was based on a study by Ray Perryman.

That didn’t sit well with Roden, who withdrew his membership from the chamber in protest.

“I’ve never seen even one policy recommendation coming from this body during the five or so years our community has struggled with this issue,” Roden said in his blog.

He’s willing to listen to solutions but “can’t lend financial support to the political hackery of an industry intent on harming my city.”

In an interview Tuesday morning, Roden said the city has been unsuccessful so far in crafting an ordinance that doesn’t get challenged in court. The Denton City Council voted earlier this month to extend its moratorium on drilling permit through Jan. 20 so it can continue working on it.

“It’s really state laws that need to change,” Roden said. “To me, that’s the leverage of a ban. You claim you want to fix this problem. You claim you want responsible regulations? Let’s stop this until you fix this.”

While supporters say a ban would cost the city up to $251 million, Roden said continuing to allow it affects the surface development of the city.

“The problem we already have 300 existing wells in the fastest-growing part of our city,” Roden said. “It’s a whole different situation when you get that close to people

They’re going to create a lot more enemies than friends if they continue to push this.”

Last week, Chris Faulkner, CEO of Breitling Energy (OTC: BECC), which has no operations in Denton, said banning fracking in a Texas city would have negative repercussions for the industry far beyond North Texas.

Two Texas Railroad Commissioners have made statements recently questioning whether Russia was behind many of the efforts to ban fracking in the United States and Europe, though they didn't single out Denton specifically.

Stay up to date on Texas energy news with the Energy Inc. news ticker, bringing you by-the-minute coverage from the Texas Business Journals.

Nicholas covers the energy, manufacturing, aviation and transportation beats for the Dallas Business Journal. Subscribe the Energy Inc. newsletter