THE COG! It Has a New Idea for the Trinity Toll Road. Be Very Very Afraid!

Categories: Schutze

cog_horizontal.jpg
Wikipedia
THE COG! is coming for you. You are powerless to escape. THE COG! never stops cogging.

The weird shadow government nobody knows about but that runs everything, called "THE COG!," headquartered near Six Flags amusement park in Arlington, is cooking up a plan to ram a new highway down the city's throat even if the city votes against it.

Well, that would be my interpretation of a story in The Dallas Morning News this morning by Brandon Formby. You're welcome to call me alarmist, paranoid and whatever. Just don't come crying when you have a 10-lane truck route down the Trinity River instead of the park citizens voted for 16 years ago.

Formby lays out a typically Byzantine strategy pursued by backroom power broker Michael Morris of the North Central Texas Council of Governments (NCTCOG) -- THE COG!. Morris is seeking to filch money from the feds and then get even more money from some private outfit like CINTRA, the Spanish toll road company Governor Rick Perry tried to sell Texas to when he was still pushing a private superhighway to be called the Trans-Siberian Highway.

No, wait. That wasn't it. Oh, yeah, Perry's gigantic highway and rail route, for which he wanted to gobble up private land by eminent domain, was to be called the Trans-Texas Corridor. But same idea. Anything with "THE COG!" or "Trans" in its name -- grab your babushka and run, which is what the Texas Legislature finally did when it killed Perry's Siberian pipe dream.

THE COG! was supposed to be a mere planning agency to make sure state and federal transportation money got spent fairly in the region. But over a period of years the behind-the-scenes boys realized that THE COG! held the purse strings for all the big public works projects that determine land value around them. Now, far from being a neutral planning agency, THE COG! has emerged as the one outfit that can make big things happen no matter what local communities near those things may think they want.

That's the story behind all those crazy overflow citizen meetings you may have seen on TV where outraged people in suburban and small town in North Texas communities are screaming. They don't want a toll road through their towns. Hey, if all of the communities along the proposed route don't want a toll road, then they don't have to have one, right? This is America!

Wrong. This is COGica, the land where an invisible government nobody ever heard of can ram a toll road down your throat whether you like it or not. That's exactly what I see between the lines in The Dallas Morning News story this morning. And by the way, my between-the-lines vision is 20/20.

What Formby has unearthed with some great reporting is this: Michael Morris, who is THE COG!'s commissar of transportation, wants to go to Austin and Washington and put together a deal in which the Trinity toll road could be built through Dallas with federal funds and private investment, even if Dallas votes against it.

No, wait. It's worse than that. Dallas is supposed to be a partner on the Trinity toll road project with the North Texas Tollway Authority (NTTA). The Michael Morris plan would get the road built even if both partners, Dallas and the NTTA, decide they don't want it.

That very possibility has been looming larger in recent months as more and more Dallas leaders have changed their minds and said they think ramming a 10-lane highway through the city practically on top of the river is a dumb idea. The NTTA has been giving signs it isn't enthusiastic about the plan either, and I can tell you why.

The News keeps reporting that the toll road will cost $1.5 billion to build. The last good figure I saw was $1.8 billion. But let's not quibble over billions. Seven years ago we told you here that an analysis by a nationally recognized consultant showed that tolls paid by drivers on a Trinity River toll road would raise only $70 million toward construction cost.

See also: Road Rage

So it's a bust as a toll road project. No private investors will kick in the better part of $2 billion to build something that will be in the hole $1.9 billion the day it opens, with no hope of recouping the red ink.

Aha! That's where the feds come in. Morris figures we go get a some huge fat federal subsidy, let's say $1.7 billion, and then we give the road away to a Spanish toll road company. They don't have to pay to build it, but they get to charge tolls and run it. And that way he gets to build it even if the next Dallas City Council votes against it and the NTTA washes its hands. For us, it's what you call a lose-lose situation.

The story on this road, what it will be, what it will do, what it will cost, has been one long unbroken series of lies since 1997 when the behind-the-scenes boys started fighting for it. This new move by Commissar Morris and THE COG! is but the latest chapter.

THE COG! is the ultimate governmental nightmare. What is that unsettling grinding sound that wakes you up at night? It's the sound of THE COG! grinding ever closer. You're trying to run, trying to run, but your legs won't move. THE COG! is coming!

My Voice Nation Help
46 comments
feldnick
feldnick

as always....."follow the money". To this day, I am still astounded at the consummate 'bait and switch' that was performed on the voters, when the Trinity River bond issue was first unveiled. There has got to be SOME way that

we can finally shut this bs down.

noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

As far as I'm concerned, NTCOG is the weakest cog in the entire process.  It was set up for cooperative planning by North Texas cities and counties.  It was not intended to be another layer of government. 


I believe I saw a family of East German Sewer Rats down there once.  So, we should preserve their habitat in pristine condition - including the the nasty water and foul odors.

fordamist
fordamist

The "Council of Governments" appeared around '70,  as "Regional Planning Commissions."  Too many people had an idea what an RPC was,  COG hid the idea.



noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

Where is the EPA when a time actually comes up when we need it?  Just imagine all of the habitats that will be destroyed, not to mention displaying for all the world to see a level of ignorance that is almost unmatched.


If I'm not mistaken, the Trinity River bottoms are a flood plain (to put it nicely).  I don't know why we couldn't leave it alone; it's our only claim to a waterway west of downtown.  But, when we're not in a drought, and it actually has water, it can flood and wipe out whatever is built at the bottoms. 


In my humble view, we don't need a roadway - and especially another toll road - downtown.  Furthermore, if we're going to build a tollroad, then federal or states funds must not be used, or it's a conflict of interest. 


The Dallas North Tollway and the toll road between Dallas and Ft. Worth were built at the expense of the operating company.  But, that's very different than building one at taxpayer expense and then charging a toll for it, and I'm sure each post-flood cleanup and repair of damage. 


What a stupid idea.

riconnel8
riconnel8

"Aha! That's where the feds come in. Morris figures we go get a some huge fat federal subsidy, let's say $1.7 billion, and then we give the road away to a Spanish toll road company. They don't have to pay to build it, but they get to charge tolls and run it. And that way he gets to build it even if the next Dallas City Council votes against it and the NTTA washes its hands. For us, it's what you call a lose-lose situation."

So what you are saying is that Cintra won't have any skin (money) in the game and they couldn't care less about any overruns?  That Cintra's debt being downgraded to junk bond status by Moody's won't matter? Nor will Cintra's failed full debt service payment (placing its SH 130 Concession Company in ‘technical default’) matter? Because Cintra is just building it...  Very clever and underhanded way to give Cintra monies.  Who exactly is Cintra btw?


So Cintra would be the troll that collects the toll?


What am I missing here?

bvckvs
bvckvs topcommenter

Perhaps if you'd name names, instead of just referencing obscure, private, corporations - then somebody might care.

But as long as you just keep screaming that the government is out to gitcha, you'll only ever get traction from the fringiest, libertarian-types... and nobody takes them seriously.

Catbird
Catbird

Interesting. Who owns the Trinity River? I seem to remember that President Clinton signed a law claiming ownership of all rivers and streams in the United States for the Bureau of Land Management. Maybe the same agency that recently claimed Federal ownership of portions of the Red River flood plain on the Oklahoma/Texas border.


If the Feds own the Trinity River and the flood plain between the levees then it's game over.


NCTCOG can do what ever they want if they control the right of way.  

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

It's called (gasp!) regional planning.  The population of the DFW Metroplex is expected to surpass 13 million people by the year 2060. You know, it might be in the area's best interest if the municipalities met and committed to some kind of loose overlay and strategic plan for water and a regional transportation grid.  Either that or just go ahead and determine the location of infrastructure with three-legged races and pie-eating contests.  Right next to the bearded woman and the dog-faced boy, and a barker who hawks to knock down the overpass!.

ColonelAngus
ColonelAngus

Jim, you are alarmist, paranoid and whatever.

WhiteWhale
WhiteWhale

All of you whiners need to shut up.  The truth is that Michael Morris and pals own all of north Texas.  You  are generously allowed to temporarily use the parts that are not needed at the moment.  So be thankful and pay you taxes, fees and tolls.

anon-mouse
anon-mouse

This is clearly due to Obama AND Obamacare.


FIRST!!!!!

sammerten
sammerten

From Formby's story: 

"But the RTC isn’t seeking to designate Trinity Parkway as a toll road. That decision was made more than 15 years ago when Dallas voters approved it as such."

Untrue!

Anon.
Anon.

Jim, you are correct. With THE COG! it is always about what the big boys want. You mention the Blacklands Tollroad that nobody along the route wants. That isn't quite correct. Greenville wants it because an owner of several thousand acres just outside of Greenville wants it. That toll road is a land development scheme outside of Greenville, nothing more. The TTC and Public Werks want to build it, and if they do then they will get paid, but the road will eventually go broke because the ridership projections just aren't enough to support a toll road between Garland and Greenville.

Hucksters never give up, they just find another get rich scheme that, in these two cases leaves the public holding the bag. Michael Morris is doing that with the Trinity Parkway and he is doing it with the Blacklands Tollroad. In one instance public support is evaporating and in the other the villigers are out for blood with torches and pitchforks.

I've said it here before, even Michael's plans have plans. Love him or hate him, he is the best politician in the region. He has cross pledged regional transportation revenues a thousand ways from Sunday in his attempts to bury the region under miles of concrete. So far no one has been able to slow him down.

tvlscat
tvlscat

There are 3 components to this. NTCOG, RTC and the Legislature. The Lege shut down the Trans-Texas Corridor. We need to stay on the backs of the RTC and the Lege if we want to shut this thing down. Sandy grayson is opposed, as is I believe, Clay Jenkins. We need to keep pressure on Anchia. I think Royce West might be a lost cause, though.

ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul
ThePosterFormerlyKnownasPaul topcommenter

Highway construction has always been about land development.


Just look at the reroute of TX114 through Las Colinas in the early 70s.

WylieH
WylieH

I suspect he's getting a big assist in this effort from Vonciel Jones Hill and Sheffie Kadane (both of whom are term-limited out) and Mayor Rawlings.

TheCredibleHulk
TheCredibleHulk topcommenter

When all you've got is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.

Morris is a fecking hammer.

Montemalone
Montemalone topcommenter

Keep electing republicans in Austin, this is what you get.

PlanoDave
PlanoDave

@bvckvs 

"...from the fringiest, libertarian-types... and nobody takes them seriously."

 Funny, but they seem to occupy your every waking thought...

Darren
Darren

@holmantx The problem is their planning sucks at best (incompetence) or is malicious (corruption in league /w land developers) at worst. 


Blacklands Corridor (as an example) or whatever it's called these days - their numbers are WAY off from what the state projects for population growth. Nobody wants it except for a few people on the outskirts of Greenville.


Surely people who are actually impacted by new rights-of-way should get some sort of say - perhaps more so than the bulk of people who are 10,20,50,100 miles out that actually get to "vote".


schermbeck
schermbeck

@holmantx And they'll be throwing a lot of the good stuff they do down the drain if they let Morris lead them down this dead end by forcing a road that nobody wants. Why is he trying so hard? That's the question you have to ask - the same question opponents of the Trinity East drilling permits asked when they saw the city disfiguring the planning process beyond all recognition. Before the secret memo became public. Perhaps there's another secret something motivating Morris.

wcvemail
wcvemail

@holmantx


Your first three sentences are exactly the reasoning behind The COG's formation. Ensure equitable inter- and intra-jurisdictional funding, minimize equity of the JWP variety, and it could be a good thing.

However, your post's second half describes the situation we have now, without the fair competition. The COG is like a Steam Era bulldozer, irresistible and wedded to out-of-date transportation goals.

kduble
kduble

@sammerten  Voters approved a river plan that included a parkway. It's true there was no mention of a tollroad.

PlanoDave
PlanoDave

@Anon. Love it or hate it, ya gotta respect the ability to build and wield that kind of power.  It's tough to be the King.

Anon.
Anon.

West may be a very rare creature: A Texas legislator who once bought stays bought.

PlanoDave
PlanoDave

@Montemalone Because every Republican thinks exactly the same way and has exactly the same values, right?


As you are nodding your head, please explain the Log Cabin Republicans...

wcvemail
wcvemail

@Montemalone

I was pleasantly surprised, flabbergasted even, that the Repub-dominated Lege stopped the Trans-Tx Land Grab and Cintra Contributions Laundering Scheme, LLC. That project would have been the very richest in Texas history, a lotta lotta potential bucks flying around.

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

@Darren @holmantx

If you left it up to the people who are directly impacted by the Part Taken, we wouldn't have DART (ha!).  Or railroads, highways, dams, you name it.  It's why we have Condemnation and Just Compensation - for the Public Good.

It's why no one takes seriously those in Deep Ellum or Downtown who want to knock down an overpass.

Dallas is part of a regional partnership that BUILT this Metroplex into something that attracted the Luddite walkabillies to downtown in the FIRST place.  Lose the connectivity, and the fools will walk someplace else.  It truly is moronic.  Silly on the face of it.

Again, if you allow some neighborhood full of idiots to knock down a freeway carrying 165,000 life blood a day - to sever a vital artery - after they promised to take the pain for the larger good, guess what everyone else of equal nitwittery will desire to do?

Cut their throats too.

And like the Trinity River project, you won't find nary an expert in a few years who was for it.

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

@wcvemail @holmantx

"The North Central Texas Council of Governments (NCTCOG) is a voluntary association of, by and for local governments, and was established to assist local governments in planning for common needs, cooperating for mutual benefit, and coordinating for sound regional development. NCTCOG's purpose is to strengthen both the individual and collective power of local governments and to help them recognize regional opportunities, eliminate unnecessary duplication, and make joint decisions."

Yeah.  Right.

NCTCOG serves a 16-county region of North Central Texas, which is centered around the two urban centers of Dallas and Fort Worth. NCTCOG has over 230 member governments including 16 counties, numerous cities, school districts, and special districts. 

Each member government appoints a COG voting representative from its governing body. These voting representatives make up the General Assembly, which annually elects the Executive Board. The Executive Board, composed of 13 locally elected officials, is the policy-making body for all activities undertaken by the Council of Governments, including program activities and decisions, regional plans, and fiscal and budgetary policies. The Board is supported by technical, study, and policy development committees and a professional staff headed by Mike Eastland, Executive Director.

snip!

So does the Mayor speak for our representation on this Council or does Staff?  Who do we ask or direct what we  want to see (or not see) happen?  Because it is a cinch the kids on the council never even heard of this "shadow" government (ha!).  Despite there probably is a committee covering its liaison.

I bet the City of Dallas doesn't swing a very big stick in all of that since we probably are considered just a namesake, and a no-growth repository for a low-end workforce.  Big things only happen someplace else.  We're the ones who want to . . . knock down overpasses and invoice suburbanites who expect us to clean up their auto accidents.

Bottom line - we ain't got no pull in that crowd, so you tell me - how do we bend them to our will?

ScottsMerkin
ScottsMerkin topcommenter

@JimSX Well if Jim admits this, then damn, there is no hope for the perfect person!

kduble
kduble

@holmantx Removing an urban overpass is a serious idea. Fort Worth did it. My wife and I attended a wedding at the T&P just yesterday and strolled around on the boulevard where the overpass had once stood.

noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

@holmantx One of the things I dislike most is for government to tell me it knows better than I do - but on MY money.

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

@wcvemail As a political subdivision, NCTCOG is subject to state laws governing open meetings, access to public records and conduct of public officials.

PlanoDave
PlanoDave

@Montemalone  I think the word I am looking for here is hypocritical.  Seems to describe you, man.  (The second sentence, not the first)

holmantx
holmantx topcommenter

@noblefurrtexas @holmantx

In this case the government is us.  It's local.  Dallas needs to get in there and participate, or at the very least show the citizen HOW it is acting in our best interests.  And since our representation is headed up by a member on the city council, we should start with him or her.

Of course, that's the problem (one of many) when identity politics sucks all the air out of the room.

We have no idea who's on first, and when we find out who that councilman is, we just go - good grief.

For in all probability, all the other cities have some competent players in there.  We've got idiots.

noblefurrtexas
noblefurrtexas topcommenter

@holmantx @noblefurrtexas I largely agree with you.  Seeing how Dallas County handled the Ebola case and aftermath convinced me they are clueless, especially the affirmative action hire who is the Dallas County Director of Health Services....which, around here, is a disservice.

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...